Future Philology? The Fate of a Soft Science in a Hard World

@article{Pollock2009FuturePT,
  title={Future Philology? The Fate of a Soft Science in a Hard World},
  author={Sheldon Ivan Pollock},
  journal={Critical Inquiry},
  year={2009},
  volume={35},
  pages={931 - 961}
}
There are two epigraphs I want to provide by way of preface to my brief account of the fortunes of philology. The first comes from Edmund Husserl (about whom what little I know comes from Hans-Georg Gadamer): “Not always the big bills, gentlemen; small change, small change!”1 I try to be as clear and concrete as possible in this essay because the subject demands it. The second comes from Bertolt Brecht: “Erst kommt das Fressen, dann kommt die Moral” (“chow down first, then talk about moral… 

Philology and the Problem of Culture

At present philology seems to find itself in a decisive moment, from which there can be different ways forward. By taking two of the most recent attempts at reinvigorating and even reinventing

Gender and Philology's Uncommon Sense

Philology, once central to the humanities—a discipline that spawned many other fields such as comparative literature, linguistics, anthropology, religious studies, folklore studies—has now become an

The Return to/of Theory

In his paper “The Return to Philology,” Paul de Man insists that philology and theory should not be in conflict, but should, rather, mutually enhance one another. This claim that the turn to theory

Vital Philology: On How to Foil the Immanent Extinction of Critique

Abstract:Using the motif of the hipster to consider the arrival of the concept “Anthropocene” into the orbit of critical theory, this essay establishes the grave existential consequences that issue

Philology in three dimensions

Philology, the discipline of making sense of texts, orients itself along three planes of meaning: the text’s genesis, its tradition of reception and its presence to the philologist’s own

Euro(tro)pology: Philology, World Literature, and the Legacy of Erich Auerbach

EuropE: rEmains At least since the late-eighteenth century, the fates of philology and Europe have been intimately intertwined. From William Jones to Friedrich Schlegel, from Silvestre de Sacy to

The Philological Thesis

This essay addresses the principal form and practice for linguistic domination, philology, to draw out a sense in which philology discombobulates the stabilizing terms it privileges and sends out at

A Suggested Reform in the Syllabuses of Philology and Philosophy

As happened in the conflict between von Wilamowitz-Moellendorff and Nietzsche, even today there are philologists who do not believe that philosophy is a respectable science. One of them is Tom

Reviews of The Nay Science

critique of German Indology in The Nay Science is aimed not merely at disclos-ing the ideologies and discourses of power animating the work of a certain body of researchers in a single subdiscipline

A Test Case in the Philology of Performance

Tall Tree, nest of the wind is an extraordinary, rich volume in which Ben Arps develops and explicates a new field of study: a philology of performance. The principal purpose of this book is to
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 15 REFERENCES

Forgetting Our Name, Remembering Our Mother

  • M. Holquist
  • Art
    PMLA/Publications of the Modern Language Association of America
  • 2000
It is notoriously the case that there is no satisfactory English equivalent for the German Literaturwissenschaft or the Russian literaturovedenie. On the cusp of a new millennium, we are a profession

Spinoza and Bible Scholarship

Spinoza is usually considered one of the creators of modern biblical scholarship and biblical criticism because of the views about the Bible that he expressed in the Tractatus Theologico-politicus

Manifesto of the Communist Party

Written: Late 1847; First Published: February 1848; Source: Marx/Engels Selected Works, Vol. One, Progress Publishers, Moscow, 1969, pp. 98-137; Translated: Samuel Moore in cooperation with Frederick

Provincializing the Social Sciences

  • The Politics of Method in the Human Sciences

There were European theories of linguistic kinship as early as the sixteenth century, though it is not clear to me to what degree 54

  • See Mohamad Tavakoli, Refashioning Iran: Orientalism, Occidentalism, and Historiography
  • 1988

Vico's Road: From Philology to Jurisprudence and Back

  • Giambattista Vico's Science of Humanity
  • 1976

The same essay may contain the only two pages Said ever wrote on Arabic philology, presumably the sum total of his corrective to those

  • Islam, Philology, and French Culture: Renan and Massignon
  • 1975

On page 26 Harpham offers another hollow dichotomy between philology and criticism deriving, it would appear, from de Man

  • Harpham and Ansgar Nünning, New Prospects in Literary Research
  • 1994