• Corpus ID: 14532710

From Observations to Hypotheses: Probabilistic Reasoning Versus Falsificationism and its Statistical Variations

@article{DAgostini2004FromOT,
  title={From Observations to Hypotheses: Probabilistic Reasoning Versus Falsificationism and its Statistical Variations},
  author={Giulio D'Agostini},
  journal={arXiv: Data Analysis, Statistics and Probability},
  year={2004}
}
  • G. D'Agostini
  • Published 22 December 2004
  • Computer Science
  • arXiv: Data Analysis, Statistics and Probability
Testing hypotheses is an issue of primary importance in the scientific research, as well as in many other human activities. Much clarification about it can be achieved if the process of learning from data is framed in a stochastic model of causes and effects. Formulated with Poincare's words, the "essential problem of the experimental method" becomes then solving a "problem in the probability of causes", i.e. ranking the several hypotheses, that might be responsible for the observations, in… 

Figures from this paper

Probably a discovery: Bad mathematics means rough scientific communication
TLDR
The main purpose of this note is to invite everybody, but especially journalists and general public, to mistrust claims not explicitly reported in terms of how much the authors should believe something, under well stated conditions and assumptions.
On a curious bias arising when the $\sqrt{χ^2/ν}$ scaling prescription is first applied to a sub-sample of the individual results
TLDR
The prescription does not guaranty statistical sufficiency, whose importance is reminded in this script, written with a didactic spirit, with some historical notes and with a language to which most physicists are accustomed.
The Waves and the Sigmas (To Say Nothing of the 750 GeV Mirage)
This paper shows how p-values do not only create, as well known, wrong expectations in the case of flukes, but they might also dramatically diminish the `significance' of most likely genuine signals.
Mass Determination of New Particle States
We study theoretical and experimental facets of mass determination of new particle states. Assuming supersymmetry, we update the quark and lepton mass matrices at the grand unification scale
Deconfinement energy threshold: analysis of hadron yields at 11.6 A GeV
We analyze the hadron yields obtained at the AGS in the range 11–11.6 A GeV and discuss strategies to identify possible deconfinement at this energy scale. These include consideration of chemical

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 14 REFERENCES
Science and Hypothesis
RECENT speculations in mathematical physics, and acquiescence in treatment in terms of unimaginable abstractions, have raised a general question about the use of hypothesis as a means of coordinating
Statistical Analysis and the Illusion of Objectivity
Bayesian Reasoning in Data Analysis: A Critical Introduction
While team-teaching a course on scientific reasoning, I stumbled on Giulio D’Agostini’s lectures and papers on Bayesian scientific reasoning for physicists and physics students, so it is a great
Frequentist and Bayesian Confidence Limits
Frequentist (classical) and the Bayesian approaches to the construction of confidence limits are compared. Various examples which illustrate specific problems are presented. The Likelihood Principle
Bayesian inference in processing experimental data: principles and basic applications
TLDR
The aim is to make the reader familiar, through examples rather than rigorous formalism, with concepts such as the following: model comparison, including the automatic Ockham's Razor filter provided by the Bayesian approach.
Bayesian model comparison applied to the Explorer–Nautilus 2001 coincidence data
TLDR
Bayesian reasoning is applied to the data by the ROG Collaboration, in which gravitational wave signals are searched for in a coincidence experiment between Explorer and Nautilus, giving a model comparison result in terms of Bayes factors, which quantify how the ratio of beliefs about two alternative models is modified by the experimental observation.
The World as I see It
  • H. L
  • Political Science
    Nature
  • 1935
AbstractHPHIS book ought to be entitled ‘The World as I feel It’, so suffused is it with a deep sincerity and a passion for justice. To Einstein the world is a painful place, not merely because of
Evidence for an oscillatory signature in atmospheric neutrino oscillation
Muon neutrino disappearance probability as a function of neutrino flight length L over neutrino energy E was studied. A dip in the L/E distribution was observed in the data, as predicted from the
From 'not wrong' to (maybe right)
TLDR
How ignoring glaring problems can sometimes lead to fruitful theories and how that can lead to new ideas in science.
BAYESIAN REASONING IN DATA ANALYSIS: A CRITICAL INTRODUCTION
Critical review and outline of the Bayesian alternative: uncertainty in physics and the usual methods of handling it a probabilistic theory of measurement uncertainty. A Bayesian primer: subjective
...
...