From Doing To Undoing: Gender as We Know It

@article{Risman2009FromDT,
  title={From Doing To Undoing: Gender as We Know It},
  author={Barbara J. Risman},
  journal={Gender \& Society},
  year={2009},
  volume={23},
  pages={81 - 84}
}
  • B. Risman
  • Published 1 February 2009
  • Sociology
  • Gender & Society
This symposium honors the importance of "doing gender" (West and Zim erman 1987) as a conceptual contribution to social th ught. I offer a critique not of the original concept but of how it has come to be used or, as I argue, misused. First, the concept has been so integrated into the sociological lexicon that the implicit feminist critique embedded within it sometimes disappears entirely. Second, the feminist use of doing gender has become so diffuse that we have created a tautology: whatever… 

“Someone Kept Sacrificing”: Disentangling Gender Ideology in Immigrant Narratives of Social Reproduction

  • A. Hari
  • Sociology
    Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society
  • 2018
“Doing gender,” the concept proposed by Candace West and Don H. Zimmerman in 1987, has been criticized on two fronts: first, it leaves little room for gender to be undone; second, it fails to

Doing/Undoing Gender in Research and Innovation – Practicing Downplaying and Doubt

  • Päivi Korvajärvi
  • Sociology
    Feminist Encounters: A Journal of Critical Studies in Culture and Politics
  • 2021
The aim of this article is to analyse the ways in which highly educated women ‘do’ and ‘undo’ gender when they reflect on their work and careers in research and innovation (R&I). The broader research

Redoing Gender, Redoing Religion

This article advances a critical gender lens on the sociology of religion by arguing that “doing gender” and “doing religion” function as intertwined systems of accountability. To demonstrate the

Alpha, Omega, and the Letters in Between: LGBTQI Conservative Christians Undoing Gender

Sociologists studying gender have debated West and Zimmerman’s premise that “doing gender is unavoidable,” seeking to ascertain whether people can “undo” or only “redo” gender. While sociologists

Doing, Undoing, or Redoing Gender?

Drawing from the perspectives of transgender individuals, this article offers an empirical investigation of recent critiques of West and Zimmerman’s “doing gender” theory. This analysis uses 19

'New Femininities' Fiction

I identify and analyse an emergent sub-genre of contemporary literature by women that I am calling ̳New Femininities‘ fiction. This fiction is about the distinctly feminine experience of

Ruling the Country Without Losing the Self

Despite the pursuit of gender equality emphasised by first, second, and third wave feminism, society continues to socially construct women as inferior to men, that their place should be in the home

From sex roles to gender structure

This article has two goals, an intellectual history of gender as a concept and to outline a framework for moving forward theory and research on gender conceptualized as a structure of social

Hegemonic Masculinity and the Possibility of Change in Gender Relations

Hegemonic masculinity was introduced as a concept which, due to its understanding of gender as dynamic and relational, and of power as consent, could explain both the persistence of male power and

Equality on His Terms: Doing and Undoing Gender through Men’s Discussion Groups

Efforts to promote gender equality often encourage changes to interpersonal interactions as a way of undermining gender hierarchy. Such programs are premised on the idea that the gender system can be
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 14 REFERENCES

Doing Gender

R e-reading Doing Gender has confirmed its status for me both as a landmark publication and as a missed opportunity. Its achievement was to build on, develop, and promote Garfinkel's (1967) focus on

Undoing Gender

“Doing Gender,” West and Zimmerman's (1987) landmark article, highlighted the importance of social interaction, thus revealing the weaknesses of socialization and structural approaches. However,

Gender As a Social Structure

In this article, the author argues that we need to conceptualize gender as a social structure, and by doing so, we can better analyze the ways in which gender is embedded in the individual,

Gender Vertigo: American Families in Transition

Gender Vertigo: American Families in Transition. Barbara Risman. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. 1998. 189 pp. ISBN 0-300-07215-5. $25.00 cloth. This work is a mix of feminist gender arguments,

Accounting for Doing Gender

W e're delighted to have "Doing Gender" and its sequelae as the subjects of this symposium. The serious readings of our work by Professors Connell, Jones, Kitzinger, Messerschmidt, Risman, Smith, and

Different Paths to Different Feminisms? Bridging Multiracial Feminist Theory and Quantitative Sociological Gender Research

This article examines the limitations of the sociological research on feminist identities and ideologies that ignores the intersection of race and gender. Drawing from multiracial feminist

Breaking the bowls : degendering and feminist change

Lorber argues that it is time to rebel against gender as a social institution-to challenge its basic processes and practices. Feminists have tried to restructure and change the dynamics of

What's Love Got To Do With It? Equality, Equity,Commitment and Women's Marital Quality

The companionate theory of marriage suggests that egalitarianism in practice and belief leads to higher marital quality for wives and higher levels of positive emotion work on the part of husbands.

Research or Rhetoric? A Response to Wilcox and Nock

In their essay "'Her' Marriage after the Revolutions," Wilcox and Nock reprise their recent Social Forces article where they drew several unsubstantiated conclusions about predictors of wives'

What's love got to do with it?

Science in the Bedroom: A History of Sex Research.By Vern L. Bullough. BasicBooks: 1994. Pp. 376. $25.