Fractal Analysis: Revisiting Pollock's drip paintings (Reply)

  title={Fractal Analysis: Revisiting Pollock's drip paintings (Reply)},
  author={R. P. Taylor and Adam P. Micolich and David Jonas},
Replying to: K. Jones-Smith & H. Mathur replyOur use of the term 'fractal' is consistent with that by the research community. In dismissing Pollock's fractals because of their limited magnification range, Jones-Smith and Mathur would also dismiss half the published investigations of physical fractals. On the basis of previous debates on limited-range fractals, a fractal description is particularly appropriate for Pollock's patterns because it is physically reasonable and because it is useful… Expand

Figures from this paper

Paper Mentions

Reply to Comment on "Drip Paintings and Fractal Analysis" by Micolich et al (arXiv:0712.165v1 [cond-mat.stat-mech])
We reply to the comment of Micolich et al and demonstrate that their criticisms are unfounded. In particular we provide a detailed discussion of our box-counting algorithm and of the interpretationExpand
1/f-Noise structures in Pollocks's drip paintings
The fractality and scaling properties of luminance patterns in Pollock's drip paintings, are studied in this paper. The painting is represented as a matrix array where each entry represents theExpand
Fractal analysis of tree paintings by Piet Mondrian (1872-1944)
It is suggested that Piet Mondrian's depiction of tree foliages exhibit fractal patterns of a specific dimension, which implies that fractality may possess an aesthetic value that affected Mondrian, perhaps in a similar way as it inspired Jackson Pollock, another famous painter who incorporated fractality in several of his paintings. Expand
The Abstract Expressionists and Les Automatistes: A shared multi-fractal depth?
A multifractal analysis of 'poured' paintings from the Abstract Expressionism and Les Automatistes movements shows that, although the D"0 and D"~ values vary between individual paintings, the collection of paintings exhibit a similar depth, suggesting a shared visual characteristic for this genre. Expand
Liquid crystals, fractals and art
We discuss the aesthetic appeal of liquid crystal textures and take a brief polarising microscopic tour through the wealth of the appearances of nematic, cholesteric, smectic and banana phases. SomeExpand
A Complex Story: Universal Preference vs. Individual Differences Shaping Aesthetic Response to Fractals Patterns
This article supports the established theory that the mid-range fractal patterns appear to be a universal construct underlying preference but also highlights the fragility of universal claims by demonstrating individual differences in preference for the interrelated concept of visual complexity. Expand
The Potential of Biophilic Fractal Designs to Promote Health and Performance: A Review of Experiments and Applications
This work discusses fractal fluency and demonstrates how it enhances the observer’s visual capabilities by focusing on experiments that have important practical consequences for improving the built environment. Expand
高島賞受賞記念 The Fractal Primate : Interdisciplinary Science and the Math behind the Monkey
This essay modestly attempts to exemplify how the interdisciplinary study of complex phenomena — in this case fractal patterns in individual-level behavioral organization — can provide novel insights into important ecological processes. Expand
Relationship between Fractal Dimension and Spectral Scaling Decay Rate in Computer-Generated Fractals
It is found that for 1-dimensional fractals, measurements of D and β obey the derived relationship, and to facilitate communication across disciplines, empirically derived equations for relating each measure of β to D are provided. Expand
Computer Analysis Reveals Similarities between the Artistic Styles of Van Gogh and Pollock
ABSTRACT Recent advances in computer vision and image processing have enabled basic automatic analysis of visual art. The author uses computer analysis to extract thousands of low-level numericalExpand


Fractal Analysis: Revisiting Pollock's drip paintings
This work investigates the contentions that Jackson Pollock's drip paintings are fractals produced by the artist's Lévy distributed motion and that fractal analysis may be used to authenticate works of uncertain provenance and finds that the paintings exhibit fractal characteristics over too small a range to be usefully considered as fractal. Expand
Fractal analysis of Pollock's drip paintings
Scientific objectivity proves to be an essential tool for determining the fundamental content of the abstract paintings produced by Jackson Pollock in the late 1940s. Pollock dripped paint from a canExpand
Is the Geometry of Nature Fractal?
Ofer BihamDaniel LidarOfer Malcai After fractals were first described in the 1970s, experimental researchers embraced them as a way to describe complex structures in nature. But is the worldExpand
Fractal Geometry of Nature
This book is a blend of erudition, popularization, and exposition, and the illustrations include many superb examples of computer graphics that are works of art in their own right. Expand
Is Nature Fractal?
David Avnir et al. ( Science 's Compass, 2 Jan., [p. 39][1]) report on the high proportion of hasty claims of fractality in Physical Review journals and end by saying that “[t]his is the fractalExpand
Quantifying Aesthetic Preference for Chaotic Patterns
Art and nature provide much of their aesthetic appeal from a balance of simplicity and complexity, and order and unpredictability. Recently, complex natural patterns have been produced by simpleExpand
Multifractal structure in nonrepresentational art.
The data suggest that the "edge" method can distinguish between artists in the same movement and is proposed to represent a toy model of visual discrimination. Expand
Fractal physiology
The nature of fractals and the use of fractals instead of classical scaling concepts to describe the irregular surfaces, structures, and processes exhibited by physiological systems are described.Expand
Fractal dynamics of human gait: stability of long-range correlations in stride interval fluctuations.
The fractal dynamics of spontaneous stride interval are normally quite robust and intrinsic to the locomotor system, and this fractal property of neural output may be related to the higher nervous centers responsible for the control of walking rhythm. Expand
The Limited Scaling Range of Empirical Fractals
The notion of the abundance of fractals is critically re-examined in light of surprising data regarding the scaling range in empirical reports on fractality.