Forty Years of Spotted Owls? A Longitudinal Analysis of Logging Industry Job Losses

  title={Forty Years of Spotted Owls? A Longitudinal Analysis of Logging Industry Job Losses},
  author={William R. Freudenburg and Lisa J. Wilson and Daniel J O'Leary},
  journal={Sociological Perspectives},
  pages={1 - 26}
The protection of habitat for an officially designated “threatened” species, the Northern Spotted Owl, is widely seen as having endangered the survival of a very different “species,” namely the rural American logger. In spite of the widespread agreement on this point, however, it is not clear just how many jobs have been endangered, over just how long a period, due to the protection of spotted-owl habitat and of the environment more broadly. In the present paper, we analyze longer term… Expand

Figures and Tables from this paper

A Response to “Forty Years of Spotted Owls? A Longitudinal Analysis of Logging Industry Job Losses”
One wonders if the spotted owl controversy will ever really end or if it will simply migrate from current policy forums to the arena of historical debate, where it may continue virtually forever.Expand
Labor market impacts of land protection: The Northern Spotted Owl
Abstract Environmental policies often draw criticism due to their potential impacts on labor market outcomes. Previous work has studied sector-specific impacts following air quality regulations, orExpand
Understanding poverty and unemployment on the Olympic Peninsula after the Spotted Owl
Abstract Conserving the natural ecology of an area through environmental restrictions has become increasingly common. The harvest limitations on national forests in the habitat of the NorthernExpand
The Sky Will Not Fall Economic Responses to Protection of At-Risk Species and Natural Ecosystems
Historically, resource managers, policy makers, and the public have viewed resource-management decisions as requiring a tradeoff between the economy and the environment. Here in the PacificExpand
The effect of endangered species regulations on local employment: Evidence from the listing of the lesser prairie chicken
The U.S. Endangered Species Act is often criticized as pitting people against species by conserving habitat at the cost of jobs. Critics of current conservation policies argue that the protection ofExpand
Social and economic consequences of wolf (Canis lupus) establishments in Sweden
Wildlife contributes with many benefits to humans but also brings economic costs. From being eradicated in Scandinavia the grey wolf (Canis lupus) is returning to South-Western Sweden and people areExpand
Chapter 8: Socioeconomic well-being and forest management in northwest forest plan- area communities
Given the need to conserve forest biodiversity and produce forest products, President Clinton’s vision for the Northwest Forest Plan (NWFP, or Plan) was that it would provide “a balanced andExpand
Management on the basis of the best scientific data or integration of ecological research within management? Lessons learned from the Northern spotted owl saga on the connection between research and management in conservation biology
The case of the Northern spotted owl has now become a classic case study in conservation biology, characterized by a harsh social battle but also by the quantity and quality of the research performed, making me wonder whether environmental laws should not more frequently target the incorporation of science into the management process itself rather than “only” basing management on the best scientific data available. Expand
The Controversy Over Protected Areas and Forest-Sector Employment in Norrbotten, Sweden: Forest Stakeholder Perceptions and Statistics
Even as environmental protection constitutes an aim of national policy, the conservation of productive forest may impact communities reliant on local employment, with one example being NorrbottenExpand
Forest Fights and Forest Rights: Working Forests as a Strategy for Reducing Tensions in New York State
The politics of forest land use are rooted in two tensions: how land is used, and whose interests are represented in land use decisions. We analyzed the potential of a large-scale New York StateExpand


The rock, the beach, and the tidal pool: People and poverty in natural resource‐dependent areas
Abstract Explaining why poverty exists in natural resource‐dependent areas (NRDAs) presents a formidable challenge, given variability in the nature, spatial manifestations, and social character ofExpand
Natural resources and rural poverty: A closer look
Abstract The review by Humphrey et al. (1993) is arguably the most important effort to date to advance our understanding of poverty in resource‐dependent communities—one that is likely to beExpand
National Parks: The American Experience.
This third edition of Alfred Runte's "Yosemite: The Embattled Wilderness" includes a new essay on recent environmental issues and concerns, especially as they center on Yellowstone National Park. Expand
Resources and hopes in Newfoundland
Newfoundland has historically relied on its natural resources, without broader industrialization. Exploitation and population growth have now exceeded these resources’ sustainable yields. WithExpand
The sound of crashing timber: Moving to an ecological sociology
Jobs versus X species controversies have been analyzed from several perspectives, such as social construction of nature. None consider the ecosystem conditions or the consequences for other ecosystemExpand
A `Good Business Climate' as Bad Economic News?
Abstract One common concern about strong environmental regulations is that they will detract from one area's “business climate,” limiting or driving away economic growth. Ironically, although theExpand
Trends in public opinion toward environmental issues: 1965–1990
Abstract A comprehensive review of available longitudinal data on public opinion toward environmental issues since 1965 suggests the following conclusions regarding trends in public concern overExpand
Wilderness and the American Mind
Roderick Nash's classic study of changing attitudes toward wilderness during American history, as well as the origins of the environmental and conservation movements, has received wide acclaim sinceExpand
Environmental sociology: Toward a paradigm for the 21st century
This paper briefly outlines the origins and contributions of environmental sociology to date, going on to propose ways in which the existing research can be used as a foundation for a new generationExpand
Community And The Northwestern Logger: Continuities And Changes In The Era Of The Spotted Owl
Community and the northwestern logger community as an idea: a conceptual issue with practical implications the historical context overview of the northwestern loggers social world the attributes ofExpand