# For and Against Methodologies: Some Perspectives on Recent Causal and Statistical Inference Debates

@article{Greenland2017ForAA, title={For and Against Methodologies: Some Perspectives on Recent Causal and Statistical Inference Debates}, author={Sander Greenland}, journal={European Journal of Epidemiology}, year={2017}, volume={32}, pages={3-20} }

I present an overview of two methods controversies that are central to analysis and inference: That surrounding causal modeling as reflected in the “causal inference” movement, and that surrounding null bias in statistical methods as applied to causal questions. Human factors have expanded what might otherwise have been narrow technical discussions into broad philosophical debates. There seem to be misconceptions about the requirements and capabilities of formal methods, especially in notions… Expand

#### Topics from this paper

#### Paper Mentions

#### 54 Citations

Is the Smog Lifting?: Causal Inference in Environmental Epidemiology.

- Medicine, Psychology
- Epidemiology
- 2019

Broad areas of agreement are shared concerning the utility of and need for many approaches to causal inference in environmental epidemiology, including the idea that causal-inference methods should represent a range approaches such as studies that emulate randomized experiments if possible and use of instrumental variables. Expand

Causal reasoning in epidemiology: Philosophy and logic

- Psychology
- 2020

Abstract This commentary adds to a lively discussion of causal modeling, reasoning and inference in the recent epidemiologic literature. We focus on fundamental philosophical and logical principles… Expand

The Epidemiologic Toolbox: Identifying, Honing, and Using the Right Tools for the Job.

- Medicine, Psychology
- American journal of epidemiology
- 2020

It is argued that a more detailed treatment of biases that impact single-sample estimation problems would benefit all types of epidemiologic studies and increase the utility of such research to improve public health. Expand

Theory and methodology: essential tools that can become dangerous belief systems

- Medicine
- European Journal of Epidemiology
- 2018

The divergence from Dr. Karp on the role of theory and methods in research is raised, although matching serves to illustrate the authors' points in a familiar epidemiologic context. Expand

Statistical tests, P values, confidence intervals, and power: a guide to misinterpretations

- Medicine, Psychology
- European Journal of Epidemiology
- 2016

Misinterpretation and abuse of statistical tests, confidence intervals, and statistical power have been decried for decades, yet remain rampant. A key problem is that there are no interpretations of… Expand

On wagging tales about causal inference.

- Sociology, Medicine
- International journal of epidemiology
- 2017

Causal modelling is agnostic about whether ‘race’ is an inherent feature of individuals, or a property of the social, economic, political and historical circumstances in which individuals live and die. Expand

Invited Commentary: The Need for Cognitive Science in Methodology

- Computer Science, Medicine
- American journal of epidemiology
- 2017

It is concluded that methodological development and training should go beyond coverage of mechanistic biases to cover distortions of conclusions produced by statistical methods and psychosocial forces. Expand

Analysis goals, error-cost sensitivity, and analysis hacking: Essential considerations in hypothesis testing and multiple comparisons.

- Medicine
- Paediatric and perinatal epidemiology
- 2020

Issues arising in single-parameter inference (such as error costs and loss functions) that are often skipped in basic statistics, yet are crucial to understanding controversies in testing and multiple comparisons are reviewed. Expand

Null Hypothesis Testing ≠ Scientific Inference: A Critique of the Shaky Premise at the Heart of the Science and Values Debate, and a Defense of Value‐Neutral Risk Assessment

- Engineering, Medicine
- Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis
- 2019

An ideal of value‐neutrality is defended, whereby the core inferential tasks of risk assessment—such as weighing evidence, estimating parameters, and model selection—should be guided by the aim of correspondence to reality. Expand

Testing Complex Social Theories With Causal Mediation Analysis and G-Computation: Toward a Better Way to Do Causal Structural Equation Modeling

- Computer Science
- Sociological Methods & Research
- 2019

Analysis of data from two randomized experiments shows that making similar parametric assumptions to SEMs and using G-computation improve the viability of effect decomposition, and how causal mediation analysis improves upon SEM is discussed. Expand

#### References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 237 REFERENCES

Causal criteria and counterfactuals; nothing more (or less) than scientific common sense

- Computer Science, Medicine
- Emerging themes in epidemiology
- 2006

It is argued that lists of causal considerations and formalizations of the counterfactual definition of causation are nevertheless useful tools for promoting scientific thinking and set us on the path to the common sense of scientific inquiry. Expand

When Can History Be Our Guide? The Pitfalls of Counterfactual Inference

- Computer Science
- 2007

This paper develops easy-to-apply methods to evaluate counterfactuals that do not require sensitivity testing over specified classes of models and finds evidence that many scholars are inadvertently drawing conclusions based more on modeling hypotheses than on evidence in the data. Expand

The tale wagged by the DAG: broadening the scope of causal inference and explanation for epidemiology.

- Psychology, Medicine
- International journal of epidemiology
- 2016

It is suggested that in epidemiology no one causal approach should drive the questions asked or delimit what counts as useful evidence, and that the field of epidemiology should consider judicious use of the broad and flexible framework of 'inference to the best explanation'. Expand

Practical implications of modes of statistical inference for causal effects and the critical role of the assignment mechanism.

- Computer Science, Medicine
- Biometrics
- 1991

A fundamental conclusion is that in nonrandomized studies, sensitivity of inference to the assignment mechanism is the dominant issue, and it cannot be avoided by changing modes of inference, for instance, by changing from randomization-based to Bayesian methods. Expand

Invited commentary: hypothetical interventions to define causal effects--afterthought or prerequisite?

- Medicine
- American journal of epidemiology
- 2005

The study by Haight et al. highlights the need for a sharp definition of the causal effect of interest in epidemiologic research and proposes methods based on inverse probability weighting in the context of counterfactual theory for causal inference from complex longitudinal data. Expand

The role of counterfactual theory in causal reasoning.

- Medicine
- Annals of epidemiology
- 2016

This commentary concludes that counterfactual theory dictates that causal questions must be framed in terms of well-defined interventions does not and suggests that the gold standard for thinking about causal inference in epidemiology is the thought experiment. Expand

Causality and causal inference in epidemiology: the need for a pluralistic approach

- Psychology, Medicine
- International journal of epidemiology
- 2016

The characteristics of the restricted potential outcomes approach (RPOA) are described and it is argued that there is a methodological movement which advocates these principles, not just for solving particular problems, but as ideals for which epidemiology as a whole should strive. Expand

Rejoinder to discussion of 'Philosophy and the practice of Bayesian statistics'.

- Computer Science, Medicine
- The British journal of mathematical and statistical psychology
- 2013

The main point of our paper was to dispute the commonly held view that Bayesian statistics is or should be an algorithmic, inductive process culminating in the calculation of the posterior… Expand

Causal inference in public health.

- Psychology, Medicine
- Annual review of public health
- 2013

It is argued that in public health this framework is more suitable, providing an estimate of an action's consequences rather than the less precise notion of a risk factor's causal effect. Expand

Statistics and Causal Inference

- Mathematics
- 1986

Abstract Problems involving causal inference have dogged at the heels of statistics since its earliest days. Correlation does not imply causation, and yet causal conclusions drawn from a carefully… Expand