Flames over the Somme: A Retort to William Philpott

@article{Greenhalgh2003FlamesOT,
  title={Flames over the Somme: A Retort to William Philpott},
  author={Elizabeth M. Greenhalgh},
  journal={War in History},
  year={2003},
  volume={10},
  pages={335 - 342}
}
This response to William Philpott’s ‘Why the British Were Really on the Somme’ (War in History xi, 4) underlines Philpott’s failure to take adequate account of French sources, dismisses his long defence of Kitchener as beside the point and views his ‘strategic paradox’ as no more convincing for its reiteration. His ‘seven types of success’, offered as an alternative to my judgement that the 1916 battle of the Somme was a failure, are demonstrated to be fragile, nugatory and unsubstantiated. The… 
10 Citations

Joffre and the Origins of the Somme: A Study in Allied Military Planning

This paper examines the origins of the Battle of the Somme within the context of French Commander-in-Chief Joseph Joffre's effort to coordinate Allied military operations in 1916 and to mount a

Unwilling allies?: Tommy-Poilu relations on the Western Front 1914-1918

This thesis examines the relationships and interactions between British and French soldiers on the Western Front of the First World War. To date the historical approaches to inter-allied relations

France's Forgotten Victory

France won the First World War. This simple fact is all but forgotten in the English-speaking world. Either the combination of blockade and the now efficient British citizen army on the one hand, or

Haig's Intelligence: GHQ and the German Army, 1916–1918

Haig's Intelligence is an important new study of Douglas Haig's controversial command during the First World War. Based on extensive new research, it addresses a perennial question about the British

Coalition Warfare—Echoes from the Past

: The dilemmas posed by coalition warfare were a subject of academic interest in the inaugural issue of Parameters in 1971. Lieutenant Colonel James B. Agnew examined the unified command model

The conceptual origins of the control of the air : British military and naval aviation, 1911-1918

This thesis examines the conceptual origins of the control of the air in Britain between 1911 and 1918. It concludes that military and naval aviators possessed an innate understanding of the concept,

‘You Provide the Pixels and I’ll Provide the War’ — Computer Games, Cinema and Narrative

Chapter 1 deals with the narrative and stories of First World War games. Games focused on the Second World War have long been tightly linked to cinematic portrayals to the extent that notable Second

The British Army and the First World War

This is a major new history of the British army during the Great War written by three leading military historians. Ian Beckett, Timothy Bowman and Mark Connelly survey operations on the Western Front

References

David French writes that the German naval staff saw the peace note as a 'step towards securing a victor's peace': D. French, The Strategy of the Lloyd George Coalition

  • Of cial Statement of War Aims and Peace Proposals