First international consensus conference on standardization of oncoplastic breast conserving surgery


To obtain consensus recommendations for the standardization of oncoplastic breast conserving surgery (OPS) from an international panel of experts in breast surgery including delegates from the German, Austrian and Swiss societies of senology. A total of 52 questions were addressed by electronic voting. The panel’s recommendations were put into context with current evidence and the report was circled in an iterative open email process until consensus was obtained. The panelists considered OPS safe and effective for improving aesthetic outcomes and broadening the indication for breast conserving surgery (BCS) towards larger tumors. A slim majority believed that OPS reduces the rate of positive margins; however, there was consensus that OPS is associated with an increased risk of complications compared to conventional BCS. The panel strongly endorsed patient-reported outcomes measurement, and recommended selected scales of the Breast-Q™-Breast Conserving Therapy Module for that purpose. The Clough bi-level classification was recommended for standard use in clinical practice for indicating, planning and performing OPS, and the Hoffmann classification for surgical reports and billing purposes. Mastopexy and reduction mammoplasty were the only two recognized OPS procedure categories supported by a majority of the panel. Finally, the experts unanimously supported the statement that every OPS procedure should be tailored to each individual patient. When implemented into clinical practice, the panel recommendations may improve safety and effectiveness of OPS. The attendees agreed that there is a need for prospective multicenter studies to optimize patient selection and for standardized criteria to qualify and accredit OPS training centers.

DOI: 10.1007/s10549-017-4314-5

3 Figures and Tables

Cite this paper

@article{Weber2017FirstIC, title={First international consensus conference on standardization of oncoplastic breast conserving surgery}, author={W. Weber and Savas D. Soysal and Mahmoud B. El-Tamer and Virgilio S. Sacchini and Michael Knauer and Christoph Tausch and Nik Hauser and Andreas R. G{\"{u}nthert and Yves Harder and Elisabeth A Kappos and Fabienne Dominique Schwab and Florian Fitzal and Peter Christian Dubsky and Vesna Bjelic-Radisic and Roland Reitsamer and R. Koller and Joerg Heil and Markus Hahn and Jens Uwe Blohmer and J{\"{u}rgen Hoffmann and Christine Solbach and Christoph D. Heitmann and Bernd Gerber and Martin Dieter Haug and Christian Kurzeder}, journal={Breast Cancer Research and Treatment}, year={2017}, volume={165}, pages={139-149} }