Explicit Bayesian Analysis for Process Tracing: Guidelines, Opportunities, and Caveats

@article{Fairfield2017ExplicitBA,
  title={Explicit Bayesian Analysis for Process Tracing: Guidelines, Opportunities, and Caveats},
  author={Tasha Fairfield and Andrew Emile Charman},
  journal={Political Analysis},
  year={2017},
  volume={25},
  pages={363 - 380}
}
Bayesian probability holds the potential to serve as an important bridge between qualitative and quantitative methodology. Yet whereas Bayesian statistical techniques have been successfully elaborated for quantitative research, applying Bayesian probability to qualitative research remains an open frontier. This paper advances the burgeoning literature on Bayesian process tracing by drawing on expositions of Bayesian “probability as extended logic” from the physical sciences, where probabilities… 
Updating Bayesian(s): A Critical Evaluation of Bayesian Process Tracing
Given the increasing quantity and impressive placement of work on Bayesian process tracing, this approach has quickly become a frontier of qualitative research methods. Moreover, it has dominated the
A Set-Theoretic Approach to Bayesian Process Tracing
TLDR
The article shows that Bayesian process tracing and set-theoretic process tracing are not alternatives to each other but rather two sides of the same coin.
The Bayesian foundations of iterative research in qualitative social science: a dialogue with the data
TLDR
It is argued that mechanisms for distinguishing exploratory from confirmatory stages of analysis that have been suggested in the context of APSA’s DA-RT transparency initiative are unnecessary for qualitative research that is guided by logical Bayesianism.
Understanding Bayesianism: Fundamentals for Process Tracers
TLDR
This work focuses on clarifying issues involving mutual exclusivity of hypotheses, evidentiary import, adjudicating among more than two hypotheses, and the logic of iterative research, with the goal of elucidating how Bayesian analysis operates and pushing the field forward.
A Dialogue with the Data: The Bayesian Foundations of Iterative Research in Qualitative Social Science
TLDR
It is argued that mechanisms for distinguishing exploratory from confirmatory stages of analysis that have been suggested in the context of APSA’s DA-RT transparency initiative are unnecessary for qualitative research that is guided by logical Bayesianism.
Diagnostic evaluation and Bayesian Updating: Practical solutions to common problems
TLDR
The article tackles evidence packages (one of the most problematical practical issues), proposing ways to set boundaries of single observations that can be considered independent and handled numerically and how to handle evidence packages when numerical probability estimates are not available.
Return to the Scene of the Crime: Revisiting Process Tracing, Bayesianism, and Murder
Abstract In a recent article, I argued that the Bayesian process tracing literature exhibits a persistent disconnect between principle and practice. In their response, Bennett, Fairfield, and Charman
Comparative Methods and Process Tracing
TLDR
This report focuses on analytic transparency, leaving transparency in generating and sharing evidence to other QTD reports and differentiates between core recommended practices and emerging practices that might be considered, depending on the costs entailed, by authors, reviewers, and readers.
A Bayesian Perspective on Case Selection
TLDR
This paper presents a far simpler Bayesian perspective on case selection, where the single overarching principle is to maximize information that will help develop, refine, and/or compare hypotheses.
Process Tracing and the Problem of Missing Data
TLDR
This article conceptualizes “missingness” as it relates to process tracing, describes different scenarios in which it is pervasive, and presents three ways of addressing the problem.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 53 REFERENCES
A Set-Theoretic Approach to Bayesian Process Tracing
TLDR
The article shows that Bayesian process tracing and set-theoretic process tracing are not alternatives to each other but rather two sides of the same coin.
Mixing Methods: A Bayesian Approach
We develop an approach to multimethod research that generates joint learning from quantitative and qualitative evidence. The framework—Bayesian integration of quantitative and qualitative data
Understanding Process Tracing
  • D. Collier
  • Sociology
    PS: Political Science & Politics
  • 2011
Abstract Process tracing is a fundamental tool of qualitative analysis. This method is often invoked by scholars who carry out within-case analysis based on qualitative data, yet frequently it is
Bayesian data analysis.
  • J. Kruschke
  • Political Science
    Wiley interdisciplinary reviews. Cognitive science
  • 2010
TLDR
A fatal flaw of NHST is reviewed and some benefits of Bayesian data analysis are introduced and illustrative examples of multiple comparisons in Bayesian analysis of variance and Bayesian approaches to statistical power are presented.
Bayesian Methods : A Social and Behavioral Sciences Approach
TLDR
Bayesian Decision Theory Introducing Decision Theory Basic Definitions Regression-Style Models with Decision Theory James-Stein Estimation Empirical Bayes Exercises Monte Carlo and Related Iterative Methods.
The Oxford Handbook of Political Methodology
Political methodology has changed dramatically over the past thirty years, and many new methods and techniques have been developed. Both the Political Methodology Society and the
Bayesian Analysis for the Social Sciences
TLDR
This chapter discusses Bayesian analysis for simple models, which focuses on the case for hierarchical modeling, and its applications in the Social Sciences and Simulation Based Bayesian Analysis.
Case Studies and the Statistical Worldview: Review of King, Keohane, and Verba's Designing Social Inquiry: Scientific Inference in Qualitative Research
Gary King, Robert O. Keohane, and Sydney Verba's Designing Social Inquiry exploits the metaphor of researcher-as-statistician to develop guidelines for conducting social scientific research that are
The Logic of Process Tracing Tests in the Social Sciences
This article discusses process tracing as a methodology for testing hypotheses in the social sciences. With process tracing tests, the analyst combines preexisting generalizations with specific
Scientific Reasoning: The Bayesian Approach
TLDR
This new edition of Howson and Urbach's account of scientific method from the Bayesian standpoint includes chapter exercises and extended material on topics such as regression analysis, distributions densities, randomisation and conditionalisation.
...
...