Explaining the IPV Arrest Decision: Incident, Agency, and Community Factors

@article{Dichter2011ExplainingTI,
  title={Explaining the IPV Arrest Decision: Incident, Agency, and Community Factors},
  author={Melissa E. Dichter and Steven C. Marcus and Melissa Morabito and Karin V. Rhodes},
  journal={Criminal Justice Review},
  year={2011},
  volume={36},
  pages={22 - 39}
}
Over the last half century in the United States, we have seen the criminal system become increasingly aggressive in its response to violence against intimate partners. Although policies have been implemented to encourage arrest, police continue to maintain discretion over whether or whom to arrest in cases of intimate partner violence (IPV). Using data from three national data sets, we examined the contributions of incident, agency, and community factors on the police arrest decisions… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Factors that affect the arrest decision in domestic violence cases
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to examine domestic violence calls for service data in one Florida county for a two-year period from July 2004 through July 2006. Design/methodology/approach –
A 10-Year Study of the Impact of Intimate Partner Violence Primary Aggressor Laws on Single and Dual Arrest
TLDR
The authors found that the existence of primary aggressor laws does appear to result in officer reluctance to make any arrest, and though these laws do result in a reduction in dual arrests, this reduction was not statistically significant and was undoubtedly a result of inter-state variation in implementation as well as variations in statutory framework.
What Makes Police Officers Act? Police Response to Instances of Intimate Partner Violence
TLDR
Regression analyses suggest variations in police response based on sociodemographic, violence, and neighborhood characteristics; however, overall satisfaction with police actions taken were not found to be significantly different among victims based on these characteristics.
The Nexus Between Intimate Partner Violence and Stalking: Examining the Arrest Decision
The present study used a stratified random sample of 332 case files from a sizable, urban police department located in one of the five largest and most diverse U.S. cities to examine the effect of
Intimate partner abuse: cases involving protective order violations versus those that do not
TLDR
Findings include differences between these two types of calls (with protective order cases less likely to be between parties currently in a relationship, for the offender lesslikely to be present when police arrive, and more likely to end up in arrest) and differences and similarities in the predictors of arrest.
The lethality assessment program: Which survivors of intimate partner violence are most likely to participate?
TLDR
There was differential use of the intervention based on the following: jurisdiction, severe violence at the incident, perpetrator’s use of a weapon ever in the relationship, PTSD symptomology, and women’'s prior protective actions and utilization of domestic violence advocacy services.
Same-Sex Couples and the Police: A 10-Year Study of Arrest and Dual Arrest Rates in Responding to Incidents of Intimate Partner Violence
TLDR
Examining the police response to incidents involving same-sex and heterosexual couples in 2,625,753 cases across 5,481 jurisdictions in 36 states and Washington, D.C. shows that incidents with same- sex couples are less likely to result in arrest, but far more likely toresult in dual arrests, in most incident configurations.
INTIMATE PARTNER VIOLENCE IN U.S. METROPOLITAN AREAS: THE CONTEXTUAL INFLUENCES OF POLICE AND SOCIAL SERVICES*
Although community responses to the problem of intimate partner violence typically focus on increasing and improving policing and social services, few studies have examined the relationship among
Race and the Likelihood of Intimate Partner Violence Arrest and Dual Arrest
Research on the impact of race on the likelihood an incident of intimate partner violence will result in arrest is mixed. Some scholars find racial minorities to be at lower risk of arrest, some find
Intimate Partner Violence Among Sexual Minorities: Predicting Police Officer Arrest Decisions
Intimate partner violence (IPV) among sexual minorities (SM) remains a considerable social problem. Police response to survivors can have a significant impact on recovery, case attrition, and suspect
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 52 REFERENCES
Policy, Place, and Perpetrators: Using NIBRS to Explain Arrest Practices in Intimate Partner Violence
This study presents the results of a multilevel analysis of arrest outcomes in intimate partner incidents reported to the police. Using NIBRS data for 2000 in combination with data from other
Police Response to Interpersonal Violence: Defining the Parameters of Legal Control
This paper examines factors influencing how police handle violence between citizens. Police decision-making in violent encounters reflects styles of control, three of which are considered in this
Double Your Trouble: Dual Arrest in Family Violence
When arrest is mandated for domestic violence crimes the arrest of two individuals, or dual arrest, often occurs. This study examines the characteristics of the crime and the people caught in dual
Dual Arrest Decisions in Domestic Violence Cases: The Influence of Departmental Policies
TLDR
Results indicate that officers who believed that their department would support arrest of both parties are more likely to arrest both parties, while experienced officers were more likely than novice officers to use dual arrest.
Police Involvement in Domestic Violence: The Interactive Effects of Victim Injury, Offender’s History of Violence, and Race
TLDR
Examining those factors most important in predicting the police-reporting behavior of 1535 female victims of intimate-perpetrated violence taken from the National Crime Victimization Survey during 1987-1992 finds that Black victims, victims who sustained injury as the result of their victimization, and victims who reported that the offender had not victimized them before were more likely to report their victimizations to police.
The Influence of Mandatory Arrest Policies, Police Organizational Characteristics, and Situational Variables on the Probability of Arrest in Domestic Violence Cases
Prior research into factors predicting arrest in domestic violence cases is limited in three regards: (a) no examination of whether mandatory arrest policies are associated with increased risk of
Police responses to battering in a progressive pro-arrest jurisdiction
This study was conducted in Boulder County, Colorado, a jurisdiction with a pro-arrest policy in place since 1986 and with a progressive agency, the Domestic Abuse Prevention Project (DAPP), designed
Mandatory Arrest and Prosecution Policies for Domestic Violence
New laws and policies in domestic violence cases, such as mandatory arrest and no-drop prosecution, have been implemented despite empirical evidence that arrest and prosecution may not in fact deter
The Paradox of Women Arrested for Domestic Violence
Increasingly, women are being arrested for domestic violence charges as part of dual arrests (when their partner is also arrested) or as a result of their own actions. Could this phenomenon be
Law Enforcement Officers' Attitudes about the Appropriate Responses to Woman Battering*
The debate over the appropriate police response to cases of battered women has intensified over the last two decades, with the majority of the research focusing on the deterrent aspect of pro-arrest
...
...