Explaining Scientific and Technical Emergence Forecasting

  title={Explaining Scientific and Technical Emergence Forecasting},
  author={James R. Michaelis and Deborah L. McGuinness and Cynthia Chang and John S. Erickson and Daniel Hunter and Olga Babko-Malaya},
  booktitle={Applications of Social Media and Social Network Analysis},
In decision support systems such as those designed to predict scientific and technical emergence based on analysis of collections of data the presentation of provenance lineage records in the form of a human-readable explanation has been shown to be an effective strategy for assisting users in the interpretation of results. This work focuses on the development of a novel infrastructure for enabling the explanation of hybrid intelligence systems including probabilistic models—in the form of… 


Towards explanation of scientific and technological emergence
A network-modeling framework that is used in the ARBITER system is described and a novel hybrid approach using probabilistic foundations in combination with semantic technology is described to explain hybrid approaches to indicator-based analysis and emergence detection.
Applied Actant-Network Theory: Toward the Automated Detection of Technoscientific Emergence from Full-Text Publications and Patents
The team has applied the primary insights of actant network theory developed within the disciplines of Science and Technology Studies and the history of technology and science to create a pragmatic theory of technoscientific emergence that articulates emergence in terms of the robustness of actan networks.
Modeling Debate within a Scientific Community
An algorithm for recognizing debate in large document collections is presented and the results of applying these indicators to data from several fields classified by subject matter experts show that system outputs have high agreement with SME's judgments.
Knowledge-Worker Requirements for Next Generation Query Answering & Explanation Systems
The analyst requirements and response to the explanation component of the KANI system are described and it is believed the explanation infrastructure, its interface for analysts and knowledge workers, and the provenance requirements are all contributions that are leverageable beyond the Kani implementation.
Explaining Conclusions from Diverse Knowledge Sources
This work aims at explaining conclusions derived from a combination of structured and unstructured sources by producing unified traces of extraction and deduction processes in the Proof Markup Language (PML), an OWL-based formalism for encoding provenance for inferred information.
Flexible creation of indicators of scientific and technological emergence: Emerging phenomena and big data
The paper describes how ARBITER uses these indicators in a flexible manner to infer a wide variety of patterns of interest using customizable models that capture the user's understanding of what is important in emergence.
Tracking Information Extraction from Intelligence Documents
We describe here some of the research underlying the development of KANI (Knowledge Associates for Novel Intelligence), a hybrid system that combines large scale information extraction (IE) with
Explaining inferences in Bayesian networks
The proposed Explaining BN Inferences (EBI) procedure for explaining how variables interact to reach conclusions generates high quality, concise and comprehensible explanations for BN inferences, in particular the underlying compensation mechanism that enables BN to outperform alternative prediction systems, such as decision tree.
Explaining answers from the Semantic Web: the Inference Web approach
Explanation in Probabilistic Systems: Is It Feasible? Will It Work?
It is argued that the observed discrepancies between human and probabilistic reasoning and the anticipated difficulties in building user interfaces are not a good reason for rejecting probability theory, and provide motivation for a normative treatment of uncertainty.