Expert opinion on electoral systems: So which electoral system is “best”?

  title={Expert opinion on electoral systems: So which electoral system is “best”?},
  author={Shaun Bowler and David M. Farrell and Robin T. Pettitt},
  journal={Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties},
  pages={19 - 3}
Electoral systems are now much more prone to reform than 10–20 years ago, and as a consequence electoral system specialists are developing a useful sideline in advising on electoral system design across the globe. Given that in many of the recent cases of electoral system design some variant of a “mixed‐member” electoral system has been adopted, one might be forgiven for concluding that the electoral system specialists are themselves leaning towards this particular electoral system family. So… 
From Duverger to the Seat Product: seeking a pattern in experts’ evaluation of electoral systems
ABSTRACT Widely influential Duverger’s “law” and “hypothesis” describe the main direction of influence of electoral rules on party systems; however, their formulations are quite blurry what makes
Revisiting Electoral Engineering: Party Systems and Electoral Reforms in Turkey, Northern Ireland, Guyana, and Sri Lanka
Three decades after pioneering work by Donald Horowitz and Arend Lijphart set the terms of the scholarly debate on electoral system design, research on the relationship between electoral formulas and
Electoral Reform and Political Pluralism in Local Government
Electoral reform to a system of direct election of mayors has recently been promoted in a number of countries. It has been advocated as a way of strengthening local government, improving governance,
We Know Which One We Prefer but We Don't Really Know Why: The Curious Case of Mixed Member Electoral Systems
The literature on electoral systems is one of the more well developed within political science. Unlike many branches of the discipline it has successfully developed a series of commonly adopted
Electoral system effects re-examined using the largest vote share variable
ABSTRACT In the search for a less controversial pattern between electoral systems and party systems, especially the institutional conditions for multipartism, this article develops and analyses a
The effects of electoral reform on party campaigns, voters and party systems at the local level: from single member plurality to the single transferable vote in Scotland
ABSTRACT Local electoral reform is important because local politics is a ‘missing link’ in understanding how electoral reform impacts upon political behaviour. This article discusses this question
Reconceptualising Electoral Reform
This article delineates the three waves of development in the study of electoral reform: the systematic description and consequences of electoral systems; the analysis of major reform and its
The transfers game: A comparative analysis of the mechanical effect of lower preference votes in STV systems
Debates about electoral reform revolve around giving voters more choice. Consequently, reformers often favor adopting the single transferable vote, a candidate-based system that allows voters to rank


British Voters and Their Criteria for Evaluating Electoral Systems
The problem with measuring voter attitudes towards electoral systems is that few either know or care much about them. Earlier quantitative research on attitudes in Britain by Dunleavy and his
Mixed-member electoral systems : the best of both worlds?
Part 1 Placing mixed-member systems in the world of electoral systems: Matthew Soberg Shugart and Martin P. Wattenberg, mixed-member electoral systems - a definition and typology Matthew Shugart,
Electoral Systems: A Comparative Introduction
The Study of Electoral Systems.- The Single Member Plurality System and its Cousins.- Majority Electoral Systems: Two-Round Systems and the Alternative Vote.- The List Systems of Proportional
Elections in Australia, Ireland, and Malta under the Single Transferable Vote: Reflections on an Embedded Institution
The Single Transferable Vote, or STV, is often seen in very positive terms by electoral reformers, yet relatively little is known about its actual workings beyond one or two specific settings. This
How electoral systems matter for democratization
Electoral rules delimit the democratic game, but are also part of the game. In conjunction with political culture and skills they lead to an electoral system. This overview first addresses their
Mapping the Indices of Seats–Votes Disproportionality and Inter-Election Volatility
Measures of electoral system disproportionality and of party system volatility (as well as malapportionment and vote splitting) present similar statistical issues in terms of deciding what index is
Electoral “efficiency” and the move to mixed-member systems
Understanding the Dynamics of Electoral Reform
After a long period of stasis 1993 marked a burst of change in liberal democracies' electoral arrangements. There were major shifts in three established democratic countries (Italy, Japan, and New
Voter behavior under STV-PR: Solving the puzzle of the Irish party system
This paper examines voter preferences when voters are allowed to rank order large numbers of candidates both within and between different parties (STV-PR). How voters complete such a ballot has
Comparative Constitutional Engineering: An Inquiry into Structures, Incentives and Outcomes
Preface - Foreword to the Second Edition - PART 1: ELECTORAL SYSTEMS - Majoritarian and Proportional Systems - Who Gets Elected? - The Importance of Electoral Systems - Choosing an Electoral System -