Evolutionary ideas and ‘empirical’ methods: the analogy between language and species in works by Lyell and Schleicher

@article{Taub1993EvolutionaryIA,
  title={Evolutionary ideas and ‘empirical’ methods: the analogy between language and species in works by Lyell and Schleicher},
  author={Liba Chaia Taub},
  journal={The British Journal for the History of Science},
  year={1993},
  volume={26},
  pages={171 - 193}
}
  • L. Taub
  • Published 1 June 1993
  • Psychology
  • The British Journal for the History of Science
In the Origin of Species, Charles Darwin (1809–82) briefly drew an analogy between languages and species, suggesting that the genealogical relationships between languages provide a model for discussing the descent and modification of species. Further, he suggested that just as languages often contain some vestige of earlier speech, for example silent, unpronounced letters, so the rudimentary organs of animals can provide clues about genealogy and descent. 

"Curiously parallel": analogies of language and race in Darwin's Descent of man. A reply to Gregory Radick.

  • S. Alter
  • Biology
    Studies in history and philosophy of biological and biomedical sciences
  • 2008

Lenguas y especies, algo más que una analogía

TLDR
There seems to be a deeper connection between languages and species than the one Darwin thought, but this connection can be explained more properly by applying a structuralist evolutionary model and the concept of exaptation than by a strict Darwinian functionalist one.

Scholars and their metaphors: on Language Making in linguistics

Abstract This article deals with the powerful role of metaphors in the process of Language Making throughout the history of linguistics. It departs from the assumption that metaphors play an

Species, languages, and the horizontal/vertical distinction

TLDR
It is concluded that this trend within this family of phylogenetic species concepts that attempts to restore the priority of the horizontal dimension should be affirmed and that the species-as-individuals view should be abandoned.

Curiously the same: swapping tools between linguistics and evolutionary biology

TLDR
It is argued that conceptual tools borrowed from linguistics contributed to the Darwinian revolution in biology; that theoretical tools of evolutionary change can in some cases be applied to both genetic and linguistic data without having to assume the underlying evolutionary processes are exactly the same.

Ludwig Noiré and the Debate on Language Origins in the 19th Century

Among the scholars who tackled the topic of language origins in the 19th century, the German philosopher Ludwig Noire (1829–1889) deserves special mention. To him, the unique sociability of humans

Reading the Fossils of Faith: Thomas Henry Huxley and the Evolutionary Subtext of the Synoptic Problem

In a book loaded with metaphors of assault and retaliation, Andrew Dickson White's A History of the Warfare of Science with Theology in Christendom saved one of the best for Darwin. “Darwin's Origin

The Analysis of Verbal Behavior 2002 , 18 , 71-91 The Selectionist Meaning of C . S . Peirce

The selectionist meaning of C. S. Peirce and B. F Skinner, which has an empirical existence, is advanced against essentialist meaning, which does not. Against a tradition that advocates essentialist

The Selectionist Meaning of C. S. Peirce and B. F. Skinner

  • R. Moxley
  • Psychology, Philosophy
    The Analysis of verbal behavior
  • 2002
The selectionist meaning of C. S. Peirce and B. F Skinner, which has an empirical existence, is advanced against essentialist meaning, which does not. Against a tradition that advocates essentialist

Christianity's Forgetting

This essay addresses how the long process of the “Aryanisation” of Christian Europe in which it forgot its own provenance is conveyed in the history of the family tree. It traces the image of the

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 28 REFERENCES

The science of language and the evolution of mind: Max Müller's quarrel with Darwinism.

  • E. Knoll
  • Psychology
    Journal of the history of the behavioral sciences
  • 1986
TLDR
Max Müller drew on Kant's work, Romantic Naturphilosophie, and his views on the history of language and the relation of language to thought to maintain that language showed a difference not in degree but in kind between man and the lower primates.

Victorian Oxford and the Science of Language

  • L. Dowling
  • Linguistics
    PMLA/Publications of the Modern Language Association of America
  • 1982
In the career of the once famous and now all but forgotten Oxford philologist F. Max Muller we may trace not only the changed assumptions about language brought about in the nineteenth century by

From Locke to Saussure: Essays on the Study of Language and Intellectual History

Leibniz on Locke on language the study and use of etymology in Leibniz the history of linguistics and Professor Chomsky Locke's reputation in 19th-century England the tradition of Condillac

The Meaning of Evolution: The Morphological Construction and Ideological Reconstruction of Darwin's Theory.

TLDR
The Meaning of Evolution The Morphological Construction and Ideological Reconstruction of Darwin's Theory Robert J. Richards argues that current perspectives on Darwin and his theory are both ideologically motivated and scientifically unsound.

Forerunners of Darwin, 1745-1859

TLDR
This volume brings together several important essays on the history of the idea of evolution by such leading scholars as Arthur O. Lovejoy, Bentley Glass, Owsei Temkin, C. C. Gillispie, Francis C. Haber, and Jane Oppenheimer.

The Non-Darwinian Revolution: Reinterpreting a Historical Myth, Peter J. Bowler. 1988. The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD. 238 pages. ISBN: 0-8018-3678-6. $27.50

"Timely and cogent in its aims and arguments, it should prompt debate and discussion leading to fresh critical and historiographical insights concerning all those topics that historians of science,

A Dictionary of Linguistics.

a) the general run of traditional grammatical terms, even though they already appear in standard dictionaries and works of reference; b) the more frequently used terminology of the field of

Portraits of linguists: A biographical source book for the history of western linguistics, 1746-1963

"Portraits of Linguists" is a standard biographical work in the history and theory of linguistics and a resource for all scholars of 18th, 19th and early 20th-century Western linguistics. Edited by

Language: Its Nature, Development, and Origin

Book 1: History of Linguistic Science 1. Before 1800 2. Beginning of the nineteenth century 3. Middle of the nineteenth century 4. End of the nineteenth century Book 2: The Child 5. Sounds 6. Words

The Evolution Theory

TLDR
This is a reprint of the first English edition which was translated from the second German edition and provides an account of the development of Weismann's theories on evolution in which he extended and developed further Darwin's original account of natural selection.