Evolution, Population Thinking, and Essentialism

@article{Sober1980EvolutionPT,
  title={Evolution, Population Thinking, and Essentialism},
  author={Elliott Sober},
  journal={Philosophy of Science},
  year={1980},
  volume={47},
  pages={350 - 383}
}
  • E. Sober
  • Published 1 September 1980
  • Philosophy
  • Philosophy of Science
Ernst Mayr has argued that Darwinian theory discredited essentialist modes of thought and replaced them with what he has called "population thinking". In this paper, I characterize essentialism as embodying a certain conception of how variation in nature is to be explained, and show how this conception was undermined by evolutionary theory. The Darwinian doctrine of evolutionary gradualism makes it impossible to say exactly where one species ends and another begins; such line-drawing problems… 
Essentialism in Biology
TLDR
The many meanings of the notion of essentialism in psychology and social science as well as science are outlined, and pro- and anti-essentialist views are discussed, and some recent historical revisionism is discussed.
Nothing in Ethics Makes Sense Except in the Light of Evolution? Natural Goodnessand Evolutionary Biology
Philippa Foot (2001) and Rosalind Hursthouse (1999), along with other philosophers, have argued for a metaethical position, the natural goodness approach, that claims moral evaluations are, or are on
Darwinian Metaphysics: Species And The Question Of Essentialism
TLDR
It is suggested that Putnam's, Kripke's and Wiggins' errors stem from adopting an account of the point of scientific classification which implies that relationally-defined kinds are likely to be of little value, an account which is inapplicable to biology.
Population thinking as trope nominalism
TLDR
It is argued that, properly conceived, Mayr’s population thinking is a version of trope nominalism: the view that biological property-types do not exist or at least they play no explanatory role, which rules out any version of essentialism about biological kinds.
Dehumanization, Essentialism, and Moral Psychology
Despite its importance, the phenomenon of dehumanization has been neglected by philosophers. Since its introduction, the term “dehumanization” has come to be used in a variety of ways. In this paper,
What is Innateness
In behavioral ecology some authors regard the innateness concept as irretrievably confused whilst others take it to refer to adaptations. In cognitive psychology, however, whether traits are 'innate'
Homology thinking reconciles the conceptual conflict between typological and population thinking
This paper attempts to reconcile the conceptual conflict between typological and population thinking to provide a philosophical foundation for extended evolutionary synthesis (EES). Typological
Cultural evolutionary theory as a theory of forces
TLDR
It is argued that the explanatory role of population-level descriptions in cultural evolutionary theory is best understood within a dynamical framework—that is, a framework according to which cultural evolution theory is a theory of forces.
Historical biological essentialism.
  • Michael Devitt
  • Philosophy
    Studies in history and philosophy of biological and biomedical sciences
  • 2018
Aristotelian essentialism: essence in the age of evolution
TLDR
It is claimed that if Aristotelian Essentialism’s fundamental ontology consists of dispositional properties, and if its characteristic metaphysical machinery is interpreted within the framework of contemporary evolutionary developmental biology, an evolved essentialism is available.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 62 REFERENCES
Development of Biology in Aristotle and Theophrastus: Theory of Spontaneous Generation
IN THE Metaphysics Aristotle quite often uses biological examples, but they seem to be taken from general knowledge rather than from his own biological works as we now have them. This is shown by the
The Principle of Parsimony
  • E. Sober
  • Philosophy
    The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
  • 1981
The principle of parsimony has typically been described and defended as if it were a deletion rule, counseling agnosticism. Ockham, followed by those after him who liked the razor to which he gave
Are Species Really Individuals
TLDR
Griselin's argument is argued that species as chunks of the genealogical nexus are individuals, not classes of similar things, and that their names are proper names to be defined ostensively in a manner analogous to a christening.
Francis Galton's contribution to genetics
  • R. Cowan
  • History
    Journal of the history of biology
  • 1972
TLDR
Francis Galton's role in the development of genetics has been somewhat puzzling to historians; they cannot understand why his contemporaries found his work so stimulating; many of the founders of modem genetics were inspired by his work, particularly his most important book, Natural Inheritance.
Word and Object
TLDR
This edition offers a new preface by Quine's student and colleague Dagfinn Follesdal that describes the never-realized plans for a second edition of Word and Object, in which Quine would offer a more unified treatment of the public nature of meaning, modalities, and propositional attitudes.
A Radical Solution to the Species Problem
TLDR
Hull (1974) has lately endorsed the idea that, from the point of view of evolutionary theory, biological species and monophyletic taxa are individuals, and Mayr (1969a), while not going so far, strongly emphasizes the point that species are more than just nominal classes.
Punctuated equilibria: an alternative to phyletic gradualism
Editorial introduction. Moving from populations to species. we recall that the process of speciation as seen through the hyperopic eyes of the paleontologist is an old and venerable theme. But the
The Rise of Embryology
THIS book by the emeritus professor of anatomy at Stanford University is probably the most complete work on the history of embryology which has yet been produced. It deals both with the discovery of
From a Logical Point of View
TLDR
It is the wish of the author to keep general terms distinct from abstract singular terms, so that the over-all dis­ pensability of some assumption that has always rankled as ad hoc and unintuitive is discovered.
Aristotle: the growth and structure of his thought
Preface Abbreviations Part I. Intellectual Development: 1. Life and writings 2. The pupil of Plato 3. The critic of Plato 4. The philosopher of nature 5. The founder of systematic research Part II.
...
...