Evidence and argumentation: A reply to Everett (2009)

  title={Evidence and argumentation: A reply to Everett (2009)},
  author={Andrew David Cilene Nevins and Andrew David Cilene Pesetsky and Andrew David Cilene Rodrigues},
  pages={671 - 681}
This discussion note is a brief response to Everett (2009, E09), which was a reply to our assessment (Nevins, Pesetsky, & Rodrigues 2009, NPR but if they are correct nonetheless, they weaken rather than strengthen the case against embedding. We conclude with a discussion of comparable questions of argumentation and evidence that arise elsewhere in E09, and the relevance of these issues to the public discussion of CA's claims. 
Leaving the myth behind: A reply to Adger (2015)
In this article we address some of the criticism of Vyvyan Evans’ work by David Adger. We argue that Adger (i) fails to evaluate Evans’ work appropriately, (ii) narrowly focuses on allegedExpand
Recursion in language : a critical discussion.
The role of recursion in sentences is examined and the hypothesis that it also plays an important role in the structuring of discourse is investigated, which would confirm the view that recursion is a fundamental feature of language. Expand
A Pragmatic and Philosophical Examination of Everett’s Claims About Pirahã
This paper discusses Everett’s (Curr Anthropol 46(4):621–646, 2005) claim that Piraha lacks words for the existential and the universal quantifiers. Everett bases his argument on his analysis of theExpand
Actions in practice: On details in collections
Several of the contributions to the Lynch et al. Special issue make the claim that conversation-analytic research into epistemics is ‘routinely crafted at the expense of actual, produced andExpand
A refutation of universal grammar
Abstract This paper offers a refutation of Chomsky's Universal Grammar (UG) from a novel perspective. It comprises a central part, clarifications and comparisons. The central part starts with anExpand
Some reflections on the notion of recursion1
The paper examines the different ways in which the notion of ‘recursion’ has been conceived and defined in linguistics, from Chomsky’s early works to the present day. Two meanings appear toExpand
A refutation of “a refutation of universal grammar”(Lin, f. 2017. Lingua 193. 1–22.)
Abstract Lin (2017), according to the author, “offers a refutation of Chomsky’s Universal Grammar (UG) from a novel perspective”. Unfortunately, “novel” does not mean logical or valid. On theExpand
The Acquisition of Language: Evidence in Syntax
This paper aims to discuss the two main approaches to language acquisition and present the main ideas behind the nativist and the usage-based account. The concomitant argument between the two sidesExpand
Anxious tribalism and the loss of the metanarrative seen in Daniel Everett’s mission amongst the Pirahã
This article works with the notion of “tribal anxiety” as being a concern over the maintenance of an overarching story and a pressure that causes new identity to emerge. It considers the loss ofExpand
Syntactic Structures and Recursive Devices: A Legacy of Imprecision
It is shown that there were profound ambiguities surrounding the notion of recursion in the 1950s, and that this was partly due to the fact that influential texts such as Syntactic Structures neglected to define what exactly constituted a recursive device. Expand


Pirahã Culture and Grammar: A Response to Some Criticisms
This article responds to criticisms of the proposals of Everett 2005 by Nevins, Pesetsky, and Rodrigues (2009, this issue). It argues that their criticisms are unfounded and that Pirahã grammar andExpand
Pirahã Exceptionality: A Reassessment
Everett (2005) has claimed that the grammar of Pirahã is exceptional in displaying 'inexplicable gaps', that these gaps follow from a cultural principle restricting communication to 'immediateExpand
The faculty of language: what is it, who has it, and how did it evolve?
We argue that an understanding of the faculty of language requires substantial interdisciplinary cooperation. We suggest how current developments in linguistics can be profitably wedded to work inExpand
The faculty of language: what is it, who has it, and how did it evolve?
We argue that an understanding of the faculty of language requires substantial interdisciplinary cooperation. We suggest how current developments in linguistics can be profitably wedded to work inExpand
Cultural Constraints on Grammar and Cognition in Pirahã
The Pirah language challenges simplistic application of Hocketts nearly universally accepted design features of human language by showing that some of these features (interchangeability,Expand
The faculty of language
Rev Soc Bras Fonoaudiol. 2007;12(4):343-5 (1) Pós-graduanda em Lingüística e Língua Portuguesa pela Pontifícia Universidade Católica de Minas Gerais – PUC-Minas – Belo Horizonte (MG), Brasil;Expand
Directionality and Logical Form: On the Scope of Focusing Particles and Wh-in-situ
Preface. Abbreviations used in glosses. Introduction. Notes. 1. Selected earlier work on the syntax and semantics of focusing particles. 2. Movement to a scope position: quantificational and scalarExpand
Number as a cognitive technology: Evidence from Pirahã language and cognition
The results suggest that language for exact number is a cultural invention rather than a linguistic universal, and that number words do not change the authors' underlying representations of number but instead are a cognitive technology for keeping track of the cardinality of large sets across time, space, and changes in modality. Expand
Handbook of Amazonian Languages
This volume includes grammatical descriptions of Wai Wai, Warekena, a comparative survey of morphosyntactic features of the Tupi-Guarani languages, and a paper on interclausal reference phenomena in Amahuaca. Expand
New experimental results
  • New experimental results
  • 2009