Evaluating offending behaviour programmes

@article{Hollin2008EvaluatingOB,
  title={Evaluating offending behaviour programmes},
  author={Clive R. Hollin},
  journal={Criminology \& Criminal Justice},
  year={2008},
  volume={8},
  pages={106 - 89}
}
  • C. Hollin
  • Published 1 February 2008
  • Law
  • Criminology & Criminal Justice
Despite considerable investment there has been a marked reluctance by the Home Office to publish the evaluations of the various Pathfinder Programmes. Arguably, this reluctance stems from the `official' view that the commissioned researchers conducted the wrong type of research, specifically in not using randomized control trials (RCTs). The utility of RCTs is considered here with particular reference to the evaluation of the Offending Behaviour Pathfinder Programmes. It is argued that the Home… 

Tables from this paper

Arguments about Methods in Criminal Justice Evaluation

The chapter considers the change of position of the Home Office on the value of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) in England and Wales which took place around 2003 after the end of the Crime

Random assignment in sexual offending programme evaluation: the missing method

Purpose The need for random assignment in sexual offending programme evaluation is clear. Decades of high dependence on weak-inference methodology, that of observational studies, has

Gold standard or fool’s gold? The pursuit of certainty in experimental criminology

This article assesses some of the claims made for experimental research in the field of rehabilitation of offenders. It suggests that both policy officials and evaluators have tended to over-invest

Lessons from a successful and failed random assignment testing batterer program innovations

With increasing pressure to conduct experimental evaluations of domestic violence interventions, it is important to weigh further the most challenging aspect of experimental designs: the

Cognitive skills programmes for offenders

Abstract Following the impact of the meta-analyses and ‘What Works’ in offender treatment, cognitive skills programmes for offenders have become widely used in both the community and in custody. This

Treatment of offenders : the delivery and sequencing of interventions

This thesis investigates the issues of treatment programme effectiveness and issues surrounding programme implementation such as the sequencing of interventions. Chapter 1 presents a historical

An investigation of attrition from community-based offending behaviour programmes

Objectives: This thesis investigates attrition from community-based cognitive-skills offending behaviour programmes. Part one of the thesis investigates the influence of attrition on the reconviction

A systematic review and meta-analysis on the effects of young offender treatment programs in Europe

ObjectivesTo examine the effectiveness of young offender rehabilitation programs in Europe as part of an international project on the transnational transfer of approaches to reducing

Sexual Offending Treatment Programmes: The Importance of Evidence-Informed Practice

For practitioners and policymakers wanting to be guided by evidence, the dearth of high-quality outcome studies for sexual offending treatment programmes could be drawn upon to question their use in

Problems in the measurement of dynamic risk factors in sexual offenders

ABSTRACT Having valid and reliable tools to measure ‘dynamic’ risk factors and minimising assessor bias is said to be critical in helping to make decisions regarding how individuals convicted of
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 71 REFERENCES

Improving the delivery and organisation of mental health services: Beyond the conventional randomised controlled trial

The best methods available for evaluating the delivery and organisation of mental health services are outlined, using salient examples frommental health services research to present a narrative methodological overview.

The Probation Service ‘Pathfinders’

Part of the programme of research funded under the Crime Reduction Programme was a group of evaluative studies of innovative probation service projects known as ‘Pathfinders’. These projects were

Limitations of Experimental Evaluation of Batterer Programs

Two recent experimental evaluations of batterer programs produced little or no evidence of program effect for conventional batterer counseling compared to a control group and must be viewed with caution because of methodological limitations.

Pretend it works

This article is about the use of evidence from evaluation research undertaken on, and as part of, the Home Office Reducing Burglary Initiative. More generally, it is a case study about the uses and

How the resettlement of prisoners promotes desistance from crime

The article considers current developments in the ‘resettlement’ of prisoners in the light of recent theory and research on factors promoting desistance from crime. While recognizing improvements

Challenges in Using Nonrandomized Studies in Systematic Reviews of Treatment Interventions

The use of study designs other than RCTs in EPC reports addressing questions of the effectiveness of treatment interventions are examined and recommendations for the use of these studies in systematic reviews of treatment intervened are offered.

Why do evaluation researchers in crime and justice choose non-experimental methods?

Despite the general theoretical support for the value and use of randomized controlled experiments in determining ‘what works’ in criminal justice interventions, they are infrequently used in

Offending behaviour programmes in the community: The effects on reconviction of three programmes with adult male offenders

Purpose. This study presents the findings of an evaluation of the effect on reconviction of three general offending behaviour programmes in the English and Welsh Probation Service with adult male

What works in resettlement? Findings from seven Pathfinders for short-term prisoners in England and Wales

This article presents findings from the evaluation of Phase One of the resettlement ‘Pathfinder’, which was funded under the Home Office Crime Reduction Programme. Seven projects (four probation-led

Beyond intention to treat.

It is a special pleasure to review approaches beyond intention to treat (ITT) for an audience of epidemiologists and draw robust conclusions based on simple contrasts between groups as randomized.
...