Ethics of Using Language Editing Services in An Era of Digital Communication and Heavily Multi-Authored Papers

@article{Lozano2014EthicsOU,
  title={Ethics of Using Language Editing Services in An Era of Digital Communication and Heavily Multi-Authored Papers},
  author={George A. Lozano},
  journal={Science and Engineering Ethics},
  year={2014},
  volume={20},
  pages={363-377}
}
  • G. Lozano
  • Published 10 May 2013
  • Computer Science, Mathematics, Medicine, Physics
  • Science and Engineering Ethics
Scientists of many countries in which English is not the primary language routinely use a variety of manuscript preparation, correction or editing services, a practice that is openly endorsed by many journals and scientific institutions. These services vary tremendously in their scope; at one end there is simple proof-reading, and at the other extreme there is in-depth and extensive peer-reviewing, proposal preparation, statistical analyses, re-writing and co-writing. In this paper, the various… 
Outsourced English revision, editing, publication consultation, and integrity services should be acknowledged in an academic paper
The victimization of this journal, or targeted attack by a network of “rogue” editors (Pinna et al. 2020), does not come as a complete surprise. The issues of mistrust, concealment, and other lapses
Intellectual contributions meriting authorship: Survey results from the top cited authors across all science categories
TLDR
Most researchers agreed with the NIH criteria and grant authorship to individuals that draft the manuscript, analyze and interpret data, and propose ideas, however, thousands of the researchers also value supervision and contributing comments to the manuscript whereas the NIH recommends discounting these activities when attributing authorship.
Intellectual contributions meriting authorship: Survey results from the top cited authors across all science categories
TLDR
Almost 6,000 of the top cited authors in all science categories were surveyed with a list of 25 research activities that were adapted from the National Institutes of Health (NIH) authorship guidelines, finding that responses varied widely from individuals in the same discipline, same level of experience, and same geographic region.
Ethics in Academic Writing Help for International Students in Higher Education: Perceptions of Faculty and Students
International students often turn to various sources for help, including writing center tutors, friends, faculty mentors, online sources such as Google translate, and proofreading and editorial
Preparing Manuscript from Thesis Material and Selecting Journals for Submission
TLDR
Familiarizing oneself with manuscript submission and tracking system helps in publishing the thesis work in a shorter time frame.
The elephant in the room: multi-authorship and the assessment of individual researchers
TLDR
Correcting for multi-authorship would end gratuitous authorship and allow proper attribution and unbiased comparisons.
Responsible Conduct of Research and Ethical Publishing Practices: A Proposal to Resolve ‘Authorship Disputes’ over Multi-Author Paper Publication
Responsible conduct of research and ethical publishing practices are debatable issues in the higher education literature. The literature suggests that ‘authorship disputes’ are associated with
Authorship in science: A critical analysis from a Foucauldian perspective
This article aims to contribute to the discussion on authorship in contemporary science from Foucauldian and Kuhnian perspectives, highlighting the social aspects of science and the role of
Writing scientific articles for TD
TLDR
TD exists to disseminate relevant information particularly to doctors working in remote, poorly-resourced, situations, particularly in the tropics and subtropical regions, and has adopted a policy of never rejecting an article on the basis of the quality of its English.
...
1
2
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 76 REFERENCES
Authorship and Publication Practices in the Social Sciences: Historical Reflections on Current Practices
TLDR
Whether improved standards will reduce either misattribution or perceptions of inappropriate attribution of credit within social science disciplines will likely depend on how well authorship issues are addressed in responsible conduct of research education (RCR), in research practice, and in each association’s ongoing efforts to influence normative practice by specifying and clarifying best practices.
When authorship fails. A proposal to make contributors accountable.
TLDR
The requirement that all participants be named as contributors will eliminate the artificial distinction between authors and acknowledgees and will enhance the integrity of publication.
Authorship: time for a paradigm shift?
  • R. Smith
  • Computer Science, Medicine
    BMJ
  • 1997
TLDR
The notion of authorship in science needs to be scrapped and the powerful will be authors and the powerless ignored or simply acknowledged.
Prescribed practices of authorship: review of codes of ethics from professional bodies and journal guidelines across disciplines
TLDR
The lack of and variety of authorship definitions in journals and professional organizations across scientific disciplines may be confusing for the researchers and lead to poor authorship practices.
Best Practices for Allocating Appropriate Credit and Responsibility to Authors of Multi-Authored Articles
TLDR
This short review addresses the problem by characterizing modern challenges to a fair system for allocating authorship and offers a list of best practice principles and recommendations for determining authors in multi-authored publications on the basis of a review of existing standards.
Measuring Co-Authorship and Networking-Adjusted Scientific Impact
TLDR
Metrics are needed to measure the networking intensity for a single scientist or group of scientists accounting for patterns of co-authorship and networking in scientific appraisals to offer incentives for more accountable co-Authorship behaviour in published articles.
Authorship! Authorship! Guests, ghosts, grafters, and the two-sided coin.
TLDR
Whichever strategy is employed, the product of research is embodied in a manuscript that, once published, allows others to try to replicate and extend the work.
A Systematic Review of Research on the Meaning, Ethics and Practices of Authorship across Scholarly Disciplines
TLDR
A systematic review of evidence about authorship issues and synthesis of research on authorship across all research fields found high prevalence of authorship problems may have severe impact on the integrity of the research process.
Do medical journals provide clear and consistent guidelines on authorship?
  • E. Wager
  • Medicine, Psychology
    MedGenMed : Medscape general medicine
  • 2007
TLDR
Journals do not provide consistent guidance about authorship and many editors are therefore missing an important opportunity to educate potential contributors and to improve the accuracy, fairness, and transparency of author listing.
European Medical Writers Association (EMWA) guidelines on the role of medical writers in developing peer-reviewed publications
TLDR
Ethical standards for professional medical writers who prepare papers for publication in medical journals are defined, stressing the importance of respecting widely recognised authorship criteria and in particular of ensuring that those listed as named authors have full control of the content of papers.
...
1
2
3
4
5
...