Essentialism, Social Constructionism, and beyond

  title={Essentialism, Social Constructionism, and beyond},
  author={Andrew Sayer},
  journal={The Sociological Review},
  pages={453 - 487}
  • A. Sayer
  • Published 1 August 1997
  • Philosophy
  • The Sociological Review
Anti-essentialism has criticised a range of targets, from cultural essentialism and biological reductionism to causal explanation and foundationalism, and concerning topics ranging from markets to ‘race’, identity and sexuality. The paper assesses these diverse lines of critique. Some social phenomena, like identities, clearly do not have essences, but it does not follow from this that other phenomena we study do not have essences or something like them. While a strong, or deterministic… 
Varieties of Capitalism: Some Philosophical and Historical Considerations
The literature on varieties of capitalism has stimulated some authors to challenge notions of ‘essentialism’ and even the concept of capitalism itself. This essay argues that the existence of
Essentialism and the Social
In this paper I show that two senses are often assigned to essences in frameworks that award them a significant ontological status. There is both a defining sense and a more concrete-explanatory
What is the ‘ social construction of nature ’ ? A typology and sympathetic critique
This paper seeks to clarify what is meant by the ‘social construction of nature’, which has become a crude but common term used to describe very different understandings of nature, knowledge and the
The naturalistic turn in feminist theory: A Marxist-realist contribution
After a time dominated by nature-phobia, a naturalistic turn is emerging within feminist theory. Welcoming this new theoretical embrace of nature and sympathising with its insistence that nature is
What is the ‘social construction of nature’? A typology and sympathetic critique
This paper seeks to clarify what is meant by the ‘social construction of nature’, which has become a crude but common term used to describe very different understandings of nature, knowledge and the
Overcoming Essentialism: Notes On The Underclass Debate
According to the ideological individualism that accompanied the laissez-faire policies of the nineteenth century, a ‘free market’ allowed individuals to realise their ability to make wealth and,
Embracing essentialism: A realist critique of resistance to discursive power
This article argues that, contrary to its detractors, essentialism is a necessary concept in understanding resistance to managerial discourses. The article first suggests that essentialism, under a
Critical Realism and the Limits to Critical Social Science
The paper assesses the aims and arguments of critical social science and the reconstructions of it provided by critical realist philosophy. It argues that attempts to derive normative conclusions on
Feminism and Critical Realism
Standpoint theory One of the obvious casualties has been feminist standpoint theory (FST). This emerged out of the philosophy of consciousness raising, which held that women had common experiences by
Reality Disjunctures and Epistemological Encampment: Addressing Relevance in Constructionist Perspectives on Social Problems
Constructionist perspectives on social problems have remained a fairly encapsulated subfield of sociology, frequently seen as hostile to notions of objective reality. Interactions surrounding a


Sociology and the Case for Realism
It is argued that in the present era of ecological threat we need a critical sociology, which requires a realist ontology. Using Beck's Risk society as an example, I maintain that to the extent that
What is Nature for?
NATURE, natural, and the group of words derived from them, or allied to them in etymology, have at all times filled a great place in the thoughts and taken a strong hold on the feelings of mankind.
The Concept of ‘Difference’
This article investigates the different ways in which the concept of 'difference' has been deployed in recent feminist writing and debate. Historically, feminism has displayed a tension between what
Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference
Thoughts for a Prologue. Introduction. Part I: Orientations. 1. Militant Particularism and Global Ambition. 2. Dialectics. 3. A Cautionary Tale on Internal Relations. 4. The Dialectics of Discourse.
Essentialism, which essentialism? Some implications of reproductive and genetic techno-science.
Franklin draws a parallel with the AIDS epidemic which could have been the opportunity to spread knowledge and acceptance of varied forms of sexuality but has instead been used to shore up a traditional sexual morality and a renewed vilification of homosexuality.
Many Marxist geographers are involved in the current attempt within human geography to create nonessentialist forms of social explanation. This project has been carried forward with great, though
Sociological Reasoning: Towards a Past-Modern Sociology
Introduction - Contemporary Developments in Social Theory: The Right Time for a Past-modern Sociology - A Rich and Complex Ontology - Analysis and Textuality: Players, Dreamers and Despots in
Enlightened Women: Modernist Feminism in a Postmodern Age
This is a bold and controversial feminist, philosophical critique of postmodernism. Whilst providing a brief and accessible introduction to postmodernist feminist thought, Enlightened Women is also a
The ‘New’ Regional Geography and Problems of Narrative
The growth of interest in a ‘new’ or reconstructed regional geography is discussed and some of the methodological issues which it raises are examined. The movement originated in radical geography and
Simians, Cyborgs and Women: The Reinvention of Nature
women are free.' (Mrs. R F Hussein, 'Ornaments or Badge of Slavery', Mclhilcl (Women), May, July, 1903) Even those who love Calcutta will admit that it is not an easy place for academic