England's Divergence from China's Yangzi Delta: Property Relations, Microeconomics, and Patterns of Development

  title={England's Divergence from China's Yangzi Delta: Property Relations, Microeconomics, and Patterns of Development},
  author={Robert Brenner and Christopher M. Isett},
  journal={The Journal of Asian Studies},
  pages={609 - 662}
In the great divergence, Kenneth Pomeranz (2000) proposes a radical revision of our understanding of the pattern of economic evolution in the eastern and western ends of Eurasia over the course of the early modern and modern periods, roughly late Ming and Qing. A recent restatement of the standard or traditional view can be found in the macro-economic historian Angus Maddison's account of world economic development in the very long run, The World Economy: A Millennial Perspective (2001), which… 

The Economic History of China: From Antiquity to the Nineteenth Century

China's extraordinary rise as an economic powerhouse in the past two decades poses a challenge to many long-held assumptions about the relationship between political institutions and economic

Why the West Became Rich Before China and Why China Has Been Catching Up with the West Since 1949: Another Explanation of the ‘Great Divergence’ and ‘Great Convergence’ Stories

The goal of this paper is to offer a non-technical interpretation of the “Great Divergence” and “Great Convergence” stories. After reviewing existing explanations in the literature, I offer a

Production, Circulation, and Accumulation: The Historiographies of Capitalism in China and South Asia

  • A. Liu
  • History, Economics
    The Journal of Asian Studies
  • 2019
In light of the emergent “history of capitalism” field in Euro-American history, this article reviews and critically situates how the category “capitalism” has been debated within the

Why was there no capitalism in Early Modern China

In this paper, we initially bear on the Marxist debate on the transition from feudalism to capitalism to ask the following question: why couldn’t Early Modern China make the leap to capitalism, as we

Statistical Bases for a Chronology of Economic Divergence Between Imperial China and Western Europe, 1636–1839

This chapter evaluates the data used, defined and disputed by scholars engaged in providing a statistically based chronology for divergence in order to “test” the key revisionist proposition, namely,

Primitive accumulation in modern China

This article surveys the history of primitive accumulation in China, from the early 1980s to the mid 2000s. It observes that the principal means of primitive accumulation have been the transformation

China Normal: Patterns of urbanization, industrialization, and trade on a Eurasian discursive base

Abstract Comparative historians have illuminated the weaknesses in the Europe-derived and Europe-centred historical paradigms of the preceding century-and-a-half, while questioning the factual

Marxism and the politics of positioning China in world history

This paper critically traces Marxist and certain other relevant traditions of knowledge about China's evolving position in the capitalist modern world, seeking to place current struggles over the

Explaining the Great Divergence

The boom in global history that The Great Divergence helped to stimulate has produced much new analysis of the path of economic change that preceded the Industrial Revolution. This can be used to

Integration Under Expanding Inner Asian Influence, II

South Asia as a whole exhibited some of the same developmental features as individual Southeast Asian and European polities, Japan, and China. In familiar, if somewhat languid fashion, intervals



Chinese Capitalism, 1522-1840

This book is a unique contribution by China's leading economic historians to the study of the country's economic history. It is an impressive summing-up of the evidence, collected over a period of

The great divergence : China, Europe, and the making of the modern world economy

"The Great Divergence" brings new insight to one of the classic questions of history: Why did sustained industrial growth begin in Northwest Europe, despite surprising similarities between advanced

The origins of backwardness in Eastern Europe : economics and politics from the Middle Ages until the early twentieth century

Reaching back centuries, this study makes a convincing case for very deep roots of current Eastern European backwardness. Its conclusions are suggestive for comparativists studying other parts of the

Development or Involution in Eighteenth-Century Britain and China? A Review of Kenneth Pomeranz's The Great Divergence: China, Europe, and the Making of the Modern World Economy

Kenneth pomeranz argues that “the great divergence” between development and involution in Europe and China did not occur until after 1800. Until then, Europe and China were comparable in population

The Japanese Colonial Empire, 1895-1945

CIRCUMSTANCES AND MOTIVATIONS Japan's rise as a colonial power stands as an anomaly in the history of modern imperialism, one that can be understood only in the context of Japan's historical and

Between Sinocentrism and Eurocentrism: Debating Andre Gunder Frank's Re-Orient: Global Economy in the Asian Age

Abstract Numerous theories have been advanced explaining the transition from feudalism to capitalism in western Europe, frequently by Marxists in the pages of Science & Society. Recently, however, a

Chinese economic performance in the long run

This book is unique in its depth of perspective. It uses a comparative approach to explain why China’s role in the world economy has changed so dramatically in the last thousand years. It concludes

Chinese Modernity and the Peasant Path: Semicolonialism in the Northern Yangzi Delta

Introduction: modernity, the semicolonial process and alternative histories Part I. Signposts: The Ming-Qing Transition and Beyond: 1. Agrarian class relations and peasant history in the Southern

Europe and the Rise of Capitalism

Preface Acknowledgements Introduction 1. European Development: Approaching a Historical Explanation Michael Mann 2. States and Societies: The Miracle in Comparative Prespective John A. Hall 3. The