• Corpus ID: 32109943

Empirical Bayes methods for monitoring health care quality

@article{Houwelingen2020EmpiricalBM,
  title={Empirical Bayes methods for monitoring health care quality},
  author={Hans C. van Houwelingen and Ronald Brand and Thomas A. Louis},
  journal={arXiv: Methodology},
  year={2020}
}
The paper discusses empirical Bayes methodology for repeated quality comparisons of health care institutions using data from the Dutch VOKS study that annually monitors the relative performance and quality of nearly all Dutch gynecological centres with respect to different aspects of the childbirths taking place in these centres. This paper can be seen as an extension of the pioneering work of Thomas, Longford and Rolph and Goldstein and Spiegelhalter. First of all, this paper introduces a new… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

QHC48058 869..874
TLDR
The currently used Dutch outcome indicators are not suitable for ranking hospitals, and the uncertainty within hospitals caused a poor (<50%) rankability in three indicators and moderate rankability (50e75%) in the other four indicators.
Causal variance decompositions for institutional comparisons in healthcare
TLDR
The goal here is to help identify good QIs rather than comparing hospitals in terms of an already chosen QI, and so it focuses on the presence and magnitude of overall variation in care between the hospitals rather than the pairwise differences between any two hospitals.
Ranking hospital performance based on individual indicators: can we increase reliability by creating composite indicators?
TLDR
Pooling highly-correlated binary indicators can result in a composite ordinal indicator with high rankability, but it is recommended that binary indicators be combined to increase rankability only if they represent the same concept of quality of care.
Investigating hospital heterogeneity with a competing risks frailty model
TLDR
An additive gamma frailty model to account for correlation between frailtsies in a competing risks model is proposed, to model frailties at center level.
Simultaneous confidence intervals for ranks with application to ranking institutions
TLDR
A novel method based on Tukey's honest significant difference (HSD) test to construct simultaneous CIs for the true ranks based on Monte-Carlo based method which results in shorter CIs while keeping control of the simultaneous coverage is presented.
Rethinking the Funding Line at the Swiss National Science Foundation: Bayesian Ranking and Lottery
Funding agencies rely on peer review and expert panels to select the research deserving funding. Peer review has limitations, including bias against risky proposals or interdisciplinary research. The
Simultaneous confidence intervals for ranks using the partitioning principle
TLDR
This work presents a generic method based on the partitioning principle in which the parameter space is partitioned into disjoint subsets and then each one of them is tested at level α to show that any procedure which produces simultaneous CIs for ranks can be written as a partitioning procedure.
Intensive care unit benchmarking : Prognostic models for length of stay and presentation of quality indicator values
De afgelopen jaren is het bewustzijn voor de kwaliteit van zorg bij belanghebbenden gegroeid. De hoge kosten voor IC-zorg leiden ertoe dat een groot deel van het budget voor de gezondheidszorg wordt

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 23 REFERENCES
Empirical Bayes methods for estimating hospital-specific mortality rates.
TLDR
This work uses an empirical Bayes model and a logistic regression model to represent the different sources of variation in observed hospital-specific mortality rates and finds substantial between-hospital variation in the unadjusted death rates from the national data base.
Statistical Methods for Profiling Providers of Medical Care: Issues and Applications
TLDR
A class of performance indices based on posterior tail probabilities of relevant model parameters that indicate the degree of poor performance by a provider are proposed and applied to profile hospitals on the basis of 30-day mortality rates for a cohort of elderly heart attack patients.
Hierarchical Generalized Linear Models in the Analysis of Variations in Health Care Utilization
TLDR
A broad class of studies of variations in health care utilization and outcomes involve the analysis of multilevel clustered data and the analytic strategy needs to account for correlations induced by clustering and to handle the presence of large variations in cluster size.
Comparing risk-adjustment methods for provider profiling.
TLDR
This study compares eight different risk- Adjustment methods as applied to a CABG surgery population of 28 providers to create a common metric by which to display the results of these various risk-adjustment methodologies with regard to dichotomous outcomes such as in-hospital mortality.
Indicators of clinical performance
  • M. Mckee
  • Medicine, Political Science
    BMJ
  • 1997
Last week, Baroness Jay announced that Britain's Department of Health, in association with the BMA, intends to publish measures of clinical performance. This means that, in future, potential patients
The future of biostatistics: expecting the unexpected.
TLDR
The paper explores the future of (clinical) biostatistics and some dreams and nightmares of the author are sketched.
League Tables and Their Limitations: Statistical Issues in Comparisons of Institutional Performance
TLDR
The paper emphasizes that statistical methods exist which can contribute to an understanding of the extent and possible reasons for differences between institutions and urges caution by discussing the limitations of such methods.
Measuring performance in the NHS
TLDR
The government's consultation paper on assessing performance proposes moving from a narrow focus on activity and financial targets to a wider view of what the NHS is seeking to achieve and suggests a framework for achieving it, but is strangely silent on how to make these new measures work.
Annual league tables of mortality in neonatal intensive care units: longitudinal study
TLDR
Annual league tables of hospital mortality were inherently unreliable for comparing hospital performance or for indicating best practices, and Prospective studies of risk adjusted outcome in hospitals grouped according to specific characteristics would provide better information and be a better use of resources.
Meta-analysis in clinical trials.
...
...