Embodied simulation, an unproductive explanation: comment on Gallese and Sinigaglia

@article{Bruin2012EmbodiedSA,
  title={Embodied simulation, an unproductive explanation: comment on Gallese and Sinigaglia},
  author={L. C. De Bruin and Shaun Gallagher},
  journal={Trends in Cognitive Sciences},
  year={2012},
  volume={16},
  pages={98-99}
}

Figures from this paper

Editorial: Reaching to Grasp Cognition: Analyzing Motor Behavior to Investigate Social Interactions
TLDR
This Research Topic brought together researchers studying socially relevant aspects of cognition with a wide range of methodologies and theoretical points of view to represent the status of the field and foresee future developments.
A second-person neuroscience in interaction 1
Abstract In this response we address additions to as well as criticisms and possible misinterpretations of our proposal for a second-person neuroscience. We map out the most crucial aspects of our
Language is handy but is it embodied?
Neural Activity while Imitating Emotional Faces is Related to Both Lower and Higher-Level Social Cognitive Performance
TLDR
Activity in limbic, right inferior frontal, and inferior parietal areas during imitation of emotional faces correlated with performance on emotion evaluation, social inference - minimal,social inference - enriched, and the RAD tests, which show a role for this network in both lower-level and higher-level social cognitive processes.
Which Future for Neuroscience in Forensic Psychiatry: Theoretical Hurdles and Empirical Chances
Almost all of the world’s legal systems assume that criminal responsibility can-not be established if the defendant was not capable to appreciate the wrongful-ness of his/her actions ( 1).
Complementary actions
TLDR
This mini-review aims to provide an up-to-date overview of the processes and the specific activations underlying complementary actions in the perception–action cycle and prompts us to scrutinize what is taking place behind the scenes.
Gestural Dimension of the Perceptuomotor Compatibility Effect in the Speech Domain
This behavioral study shows for the first time that the auditory perception of vowels influences silent labial responses. During a perceptual decision task, participants were instructed to choose and
Eye contact enhances interpersonal motor resonance: comparing video stimuli to a live two-person action context
TLDR
This study highlights the effectiveness and feasibility of adopting paradigms with high ecological validity for studying the modulation of mirror system processes by subtle social cues, such as eye gaze, within a naturalistic two- person action context.
Reading One's Own Mind: Hazlitt, Cognition, Fiction
This essay analyzes William Hazlitt's Essay on the Principles of Human Action as a bridge between eighteenth-century theories of sympathy and social feeling and more recent philosophical and

References

SHOWING 1-8 OF 8 REFERENCES
Morphing voxels: the hype around structural imaging of headache patients.
  • A. May
  • Medicine, Psychology
    Brain : a journal of neurology
  • 2009
TLDR
The studies in cluster headache patients prompted the use of stereotactic stimulation of the hypothalamic target point identified by functional and structural neuroimaging, but it is more than questionable to use this point as a definite answer to the source of the headache in clusters.
A mirror up to nature
What is so special about embodied simulation?
Mirroring, Simulating and Mindreading
TLDR
It is argued that the best mirroring-mindreading thesis would claim that mirror processes cause, rather than constitute, selected acts of mindreading, and that bi-level simulationism creates an unbridgeable ‘gap’ in intention reading.
Is social cognition embodied?