Electoral Malapportionment

  title={Electoral Malapportionment},
  author={Graeme David Orr and Ron Levy},
  journal={Griffith Law Review},
  pages={638 - 665}
  • G. Orr, R. Levy
  • Published 1 January 2009
  • Political Science
  • Griffith Law Review
This article revisits the zonal malapportionment and ‘Johrymander’ endemic in Queensland’s electoral system before the Fitzgerald Inquiry and examines how reform was won. Fitzgerald spent little time justifying his intuition that an unfair electoral system eroded accountability, and devolved to the Electoral and Administrative Review Commission (EARC) the task of rewriting Queensland electoral law. It did so by adopting precepts well established in other Australian jurisdictions; the process… 
Rethinking voter identification: its rationale and impact
ABSTRACT Voter ID is a contentious issue in electoral democracies worldwide. This article surveys arguments for and against voter ID in the Australian context, presenting data from the first election
Partisan Manipulation of the Democratic Process and the Comparative Law of Democracy
This dissertation argues for institutionally focused judicial oversight of the law of democracy in order to minimize partisan manipulation of the democratic process. Elected representatives have
The Deliberative Case for Constitutional Referenda
Abstract In this article I examine controversies over the use of referenda and plebiscites for constitutional reform. My chief example is a recent development toward plebiscitary democracy in


Gerrymandering and Political Cartels
As redistricting reaches its decennial peak, and as courts await the next round of redistricting litigation, it is worthwhile revisiting some of the fundamental tenets of the law governing
Regulating Impartiality: Electoral Boundary Politics in the Administrative Arena
The author examines impartiality in cases of politically contentious decision making. Many jurisdictions delegate decisions over matters such as the establishment of fair election ground rules to
In Defense of Foxes Guarding Henhouses: The Case for Judicial Acquiescence to Incumbent-Protecting Gerrymanders
Responding to Samuel Issacharoff's forthcoming article, "Gerrymandering and Political Cartels," this article argues against judicial intervention in the redistricting process to prevent
A revisionist interpretation of the impact of Queensland's electoral scheme
In December 1989 Queensland voters changed their government from National Party to Labor Party. Labor had been out of office since August 1957, a record period of opposition for a major party. How is
Working the System: Government in Queensland
Most of what has been written about Queensland politics over recent years has focused on the political style and policies of Sir Joh Bjelke-Petersen and his personal dominance of the Queensland
Democracy, development and anti‐corruption strategies: Learning from the Australian experience
Corruption was once thought of as peculiarly and inextricably linked to underdevelopment. It was believed that, after the 'take-off into economic growth, many of the characteristics of poverty would,
Restraining Elective Dictatorship: The Upper House Solution?
If Australians, Canadians and Americans are, like Britons, living under ‘elective dictatorships’ then how can their elected, single-party ‘government machines’ be kept in check? That is the key
Western Australian electoral reforms: Labor finally succeeds
Australian electoral systems have a history of malapportionment, designed to give added voting weight to rural and remote areas. However, by 2000, all Australian jurisdictions except Western
Prelude to Quebec's Quiet Revolution: Liberalism Versus Neo-Nationalism, 1945-1960
In this study of the intellectual origins of Quebec's Quiet Revolution of the 1960s, Michael Behiels has provided the most comprehensive account to date of the two competing ideological movements
The Evolving Parameters of Quebec Nationalism
This article focuses on how Canada’s French minority in Quebec developed a nationalist discourse and used its provincial state to strengthen its economic and political status within the federation.