Effective Vulnerability Assessment of Tamper-Indicating Seals

  title={Effective Vulnerability Assessment of Tamper-Indicating Seals},
  author={R. K. Johnston},
  journal={Journal of Testing and Evaluation},
  • R. Johnston
  • Published 1 July 1997
  • Computer Science
  • Journal of Testing and Evaluation
Security seals are widely used to detect tampering or unauthorized entry. In the author's view, existing standards for vulnerability assessment of security seals are incomplete. This paper discusses the critical attributes of effective vulnerability assessment. These include: a clear understanding of what seal vulnerability assessment is and why it is undertaken; use of appropriate assessment personnel; assessment at the earliest possible stage of seal development; analysis conducted with the… 

Figures from this paper

Analyzing Vulnerability Results for Tags and Tamper-Indicating Seals
The U.S. Army frequently uses seals to detect pilferage and tampering with weapons during storage and shipment, and also to secure ammunition, medical supplies, soldier’s personal property, courier packages, and classified documents.
Tamper-indicating seals : practices, problems, and standards
Tamper-indicating seals have been used by customs officials for over 7,000 years. Today, seals are widely used to help counter theft, smuggling, sabotage, vandalism, terrorism, and espionage. Despite
Electronic fiber seal and the analysis of its vulnerability
The operating principle of electronic fiber seal is studied, the key technology of a certain electronic Fiber seal is pointed out, and its possible existing vulnerability is analyzed to lay a solid foundation for the improvement of seal tamper-proof ability and its application.
How to choose and use seals
Introduction Tamper-­‐indicating seals have been in use for well over 7,000 years.[1,2] Today, seals are widely used for a variety of applications including cargo security, computer media, warehoused
Tamper‐indicating seals for nuclear disarmament and hazardous waste management
Tamper‐indicating seals have important applications in many areas, including nuclear disarmament and hazardous waste management. There are, however, many theoretical and practical problems with
Tamper detection for safeguards and treaty monitoring: Fantasies, realities, and potentials
Tamper detection 2 has an important role to play in domestic nuclear security and safeguards, as well as in international verification and treaty monitoring. Unfortunately, ideas about tamper
Suggestions for choosing and using tags and seals, and for effective tamper detection, are developed for waste management applications.
Safeguarding this and verifying that: Fuzzy concepts, confusing terminology, and their detrimental effects on nuclear husbandry
Words and concepts may have remarkable power, especially in international matters where subtleties and ambiguities in meaning can have major implications for treaty interpretation and compliance. In
supports academic freedom and a researcher's right to publish; therefore, the Laboratory as an institution does not endorse the viewpoint of a publication or guarantee its technical correctness.
A multi-camera system for damage and tampering detection in a postal security framework
A multi-camera system for parcel inspection which detects signs of damages and cues of tampering, and storing the model for future comparative analysis when required by the system, based on extracting 3D shape and appearance information.


Vulnerability assessment of passive tamper-indicating seals
The authors examined 79 different passive, tamper-indicating seals. A number of these are in use, or under consideration, for nuclear security, nonproliferation and weapons control, radioactive waste
Tamper-indicating devices and safeguards seals evaluation test report. Volume 1
Results of the testing provide comparative ratings for the various seals, recommendations for using currently available seals, and a new tamper-indicating technology.
Improving tamper-evident packaging
DOE's Tags and Seals Program, Verification Technologies
    2] Department of Transportation Physical Security Manual
    • 2] Department of Transportation Physical Security Manual
    • 1977
    Federal Specification for Seals, Antipilferage
      Vulnerability Assessment of 40 Commercial and Government Tags and Seals
      • Proceedings of the Security Seal and Tamper- Indicating Device Forum, Naval Facilities Engineering Service Center, Oxnard California, August 23-24, 1995, pp. 2-1 to 2-7.
      • 1995
      Standard Guide for Inspection and Evaluation of Tampering of Security Seals
      • ASTM Standard F1158-88, ASTM
      Advances in Treaty Verification Technology
      • Energy and Technology Review, January 1992, pp. 4-60.
      • 1992
      Federal Specification for Seals, Antipilferage, " U.S. Government Specification FF-S-2738, Superintendent of Documents
      • Federal Specification for Seals, Antipilferage, " U.S. Government Specification FF-S-2738, Superintendent of Documents
      • 1990