Effective Altruism and Collective Obligations

  title={Effective Altruism and Collective Obligations},
  author={Alexander Dietz},
  pages={106 - 115}
  • A. Dietz
  • Published 19 June 2018
  • Philosophy
  • Utilitas
Effective altruism (EA) is a movement devoted to the idea of doing good in the most effective way possible. EA has been the target of a number of critiques. In this article, I focus on one prominent critique: that EA fails to acknowledge the importance of institutional change. One version of this critique claims that EA relies on an overly individualistic approach to ethics. Defenders of EA have objected that this charge either fails to identify a problem with EA's core idea that each of us… 

Effective Altruism and Systemic Change

One of the main objections against effective altruism (EA) is the so-called institutional critique, according to which the EA movement neglects interventions that affect large-scale institutions.

Collective Obligations and the Institutional Critique of Effective Altruism: A Reply to Alexander Dietz

In a recent article in this journal, Alexander Dietz argues that what I have called the ‘institutional critique of effective altruism’ is best understood as grounded in the claim that ‘EA relies on

Effective Justice

Effective Altruism is a social movement which encourages people to do as much good as they can when helping others, given limited money, time, effort, and other resources. This paper first identifies

Beyond Moral Efficiency: Effective Altruism and Theorizing about Effectiveness

Abstract In this article I provide a conceptual analysis of an underexplored issue in the debate about effective altruism: its theory of effectiveness. First, I distinguish effectiveness from

Each-We Dilemmas and Effective Altruism

In his interesting and provocative article ‘Being Good in a World of Need’, Larry Temkin argues for the possibility of a type of Each-We Dilemma in which, if we each produce the most good we can

Institutional change and the limitations of consumer activism

  • J. Reese
  • Business
    Palgrave Communications
  • 2020
Organizations that aim to encourage or mitigate social change frequently face strategic trade-offs between changing the behaviour of individuals or institutions. This paper provides a conceptual

Don't Go Chasing Waterfalls: Against Hayward's “Utility Cascades”

Abstract In his article “Utility Cascades”, Max Khan Hayward argues that act-utilitarians should sometimes either ignore evidence about the effectiveness of their actions or fail to apportion their



Effective Altruism and its Critics

Effective altruism is a philosophy and a social movement that aims to revolutionise the way we do philanthropy. It encourages individuals to do as much good as possible, typically by contributing

The Institutional Critique of Effective Altruism

In recent years, the effective altruism movement has generated much discussion about the ways in which we can most effectively improve the lives of the global poor, and pursue other morally important

Philosophical Critiques of Effective Altruism

What is most striking in published commentaries on effective altruism written by philosophers is that they are often derisive and contemptuous in tone yet weak in argument. The objections they

Thinking as a Team: Towards an Explanation of Nonselfish Behavior

  • R. Sugden
  • Economics
    Social Philosophy and Policy
  • 1993
For most of the problems that economists consider, the assumption that agents are self-interested works well enough, generating predictions that are broadly consistent with observation. In some

Group Agency and Overdetermination

A morally objectionable outcome can be overdetermined by the actions of multiple individual agents. In such cases, the outcome is the same regardless of what any individual does or does not do. (For

Joint duties and global moral obligations

In recent decades, concepts of group agency and the morality of groups have increasingly been discussed by philosophers. Notions of collective or joint duties have been invoked especially in the

Utilitarianism and Co-Operation

The author identifies and defines the features of traditional utilitarian theories which account for their appeal, demonstrates that no theory which is "exclusively act-oriented" can have all the

What We Together Ought to Do*

I argue that we have not only individual reasons for action but also collective reasons for action: reasons which apply to us as a group. I next argue that if we together have a reason to act, then I

Collectives' Duties and Collectivization Duties

Plausibly, only moral agents can bear action-demanding duties. This places constraints on which groups can bear action-demanding duties: only groups with sufficient structure—call them


  • A. Levi
  • Psychology
    Disability and the Media
  • 2012
The attractive young man of good character, good parts, good family, and good expectations, who nevertheless takes dismayingly great pleasure in the company of chambermaids and such, is quaintly