Economics as a Philosophical Science

  title={Economics as a Philosophical Science},
  author={Robin George Collingwood},
  journal={The International Journal of Ethics},
  pages={162 - 185}
  • R. Collingwood
  • Published 1 January 1926
  • Economics, Philosophy
  • The International Journal of Ethics
The science of economics enjoys today so vast a prestige, especially as compared with the philosophical sciences, that an attempt to treat economics philosophically might seem almost an insult. But the writer of this paper intends no such disrespect to existing economics as would be implied in a philosophical treatment of the empirical laws which economists reach by induction from the study of facts. What is intended is rather to throw light on some of the fundamental conceptions which… 
Just Pricing ? A Modern Scholastic Puzzle
The tradition of just price theory is generally regarded in contemporary economic literature, and certainly in media editorials and commentary, as an outmoded and naïve approach to commercial life.
The power of “mapping the territory”. Why economists should become more aware of the performativity of their models
Abstract Economics is not simply about representing reality; it is also about shaping it, an approach encapsulated in Donald MacKenzie’s aphorism that economics is best conceived as an “engine, not
Patrolling the Boundaries of Politics: Collingwood, Political Analysis and Political Action
Debates over whether a certain thing is (or ought to be) construed as ‘political’ are frequent and frequently interminable. This article argues that approaches to the proper understanding, scope and
T.M. Knox and the study of economic activity
Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to show how T.M. Knox sought to conceptualise economic activity in the context of his philosophical background and in relation to the analysis of the nature of
Economic Theory and the Roman Monetary Economy
Modern economics tantalizes historians, promising them a set of simple verbal and mathematical formulas to explain and even retrospectively predict historical actions and choices. Colin P. Elliott
On Writing Roman Economic History
History-writing is a subjective art. The historian is an agent – an individual who selects, arranges, interprets and emplots a series of ‘facts’ within a narrative determined, whether consciously or
Negation and Imagination in Economic Calculus
The paper presents the concept of a recursive calculus of the economy. Economic decisions gain their self-reference from the fact that they contradict each other with regard to their decreasing
R.G. Collingwood on civility and economic licentiousness
Purpose - Working on the assumption that civility is the core value of R.G. Collingwood's political philosophy, the paper aims to examine the capacity of civility to curb economic excess in the
Critical Realism … or Critical Idealism?
Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to argue that the school of thought known as Critical Realism and the thinkers involved in the current revival of interest in British Idealism would benefit
G. L. S. Shackle’s Place in the History of Subjectivist Thought
Most of us are familiar with an experience that, baffling and discouraging as it is in the narrower context of expounding subjectivist doctrine, points to the existence of a deeper problem pertaining