Earthquakes Cannot Be Predicted

  title={Earthquakes Cannot Be Predicted},
  author={R. Geller and D. Jackson and Y. Kagan and F. Mulargia},
  pages={1616 - 1616}
Can the time, location, and magnitude of future earthquakes be predicted reliably and accurately? In their Perspective, Geller et al.'s answer is “no.” Citing recent results from the physics of nonlinear systems “chaos theory,” they argue that any small earthquake has some chance of cascading into a large event. According to research cited by the authors, whether or not this happens depends on unmeasurably fine details of conditions in Earth's interior. Earthquakes are therefore inherently… Expand
Rethinking Earthquake Prediction
Abstract—We re-examine and summarize what is now possible in predicting earthquakes, what might be accomplished (and hence might be possible in the next few decades) and what types of predictionsExpand
Earthquakes can be stress-forecast
In 1997, Geller et al. wrote 'Earthquakes Cannot Be Predicted' because scale invariance is ubiquitous in self-organized critical systems, and the Earth is in a state of self-organized criticalityExpand
Short-Term Earthquake Prediction: Reality, Research Promise, or a Phantom Project?
The state-of-the-art, obtained results, and possible perspectives of short-term prediction of strong earthquakes are analyzed. Based on examples of specific research it is shown that such predictionExpand
Earthquake prediction: a critical review
SUMMARY Earthquake prediction research has been conducted for over 100 years with no obvious successes. Claims of breakthroughs have failed to withstand scrutiny. Extensive searches have failed toExpand
Are earthquakes predictable ?
The answer to the above question depends on the definition of earthquake prediction. We discuss several definitions and possible classifications of earthquake prediction methods. We also considerExpand
Why is earthquake prediction research not progressing faster
Abstract As a physical phenomenon, earthquakes must be predictable to a certain degree. However, the problem is difficult, because the source volume inside the earth is inaccessible to directExpand
Are earthquakes predictable
SUMMARY The answer to the above question depends on the definition of earthquake prediction. We discuss several definitions and possible classifications of earthquake prediction methods. We alsoExpand
Cannot Earthquakes Be Predicted
Robert J. Geller et al. are on shaky ground when they state, in the title of their Perspective ([1][1]), that earthquakes cannot be predicted. In spite of their advice, we should not stop studyingExpand
Earthquake prediction: Is it a practicable scientific perspective or a challenge to science?
It is shown that the main problem in earthquake prediction consists not in separating a useful signal on an imminent strong earthquake from noise but in determining the character of the signalExpand
Earthquakes can be Predicted
The aim of this research is to discover a reliable and scientific precursor that is theoretically able to predict all earthquakes, within specified parameters, within a few days, in this case withinExpand


Evaluating the statistical validity beyond chance of ‘VAN’ earthquake precursors
SUMMARY All predictions of the future can be to some extent successful by chance. This is a crucial issue mostly overlooked in assessing the validity of earthquake precursors. We analyseExpand
Initial rupture of earthquakes in the 1995 Ridgecrest, California Sequence
Close examination of the P waves from earthquakes ranging in size across several orders of magnitude shows that the shape of the initiation of the velocity waveforms is independent of the magnitudeExpand
A simulation of earthquake occurrence
Abstract Using an electronic computer, a two dimensional model of blocks connected to one another by springs, is used to simulate earthquakes. The frequency of occurrence of events (slips of one orExpand
Observational evidence for earthquakes as a nonlinear dynamic process
Abstract Herein I review experimental evidence for earthquake scale-invariance. Earthquake occurrence exhibits scaling properties: the temporal correlations of earthquakes are power law and theExpand
Statistical tests of VAN earthquake predictions: Comments and reflections
The papers in the debate show that precise consideration of whether various events should be considered as having been successfully predicted is one of the key issues for statistical testing of theExpand
Implications of earthquake triggering and rupture propagation for earthquake prediction based on premonitory phenomena
A simple model of earthquake triggering and rupture propagation, based on concepts of earthquake mechanism commonly accepted, suggests that earthquake prediction (especially prediction of magnitude)Expand
Statistical physics, seismogenesis, and seismic hazard
The scaling properties of earthquake populations show remarkable similarities to those observed at or near the critical point of other composite systems in statistical physics. This has led to theExpand
New seismic gap hypothesis: Five years after
We use earthquake data from 1989–1994 to test a forecast by Nishenko based on the seismic gap theory. We refer to this forecast as the “New Seismic Gap” hypothesis, because it is the first globalExpand
Evidence for a constant b-value above magnitude 0 in the southern San Andreas, San Jacinto and San Miguel Fault Zones, and at the Long Valley Caldera, California
The cumulative b-value (the slope of the Gutenberg — Richter relationship between earthquake occurrence rate and magnitude) is commonly found to be constant (∼1). Network catalogues, however, revealExpand
Evaluation of the applicability of the time‐ and slip‐predictable earthquake recurrence models to Italian seismicity
SUMMARY The applicability of the time- and slip-predictable earthquake recurrence models to Italian seismicity is tested through a more stringent statistical procedure than previously employed.Expand