Dynamic phase shift within a falling glass cube is negligible: comment on ‘Relativistic theory of the falling retroreflector gravimeter’

@article{Svitlov2018DynamicPS,
  title={Dynamic phase shift within a falling glass cube is negligible: comment on ‘Relativistic theory of the falling retroreflector gravimeter’},
  author={Sergiy Svitlov},
  journal={Metrologia},
  year={2018},
  volume={55},
  pages={609 - 613}
}
A recent paper (Ashby 2018 Metrologia 55 1) provides a rigorous relativistic treatment of the laser interferometer with a free-falling cube retroreflector. When considering the phase shift due to the light propagation within the glass cube, the associated effect was found to be 6.8 µGal. The constant phase shift was misinterpreted in the data analysis, producing a pseudo effect. We show that the time-dependent phase shift within the glass cube causes a negligible bias of the computed gravity… 
Reply to ‘Dynamic phase shift within a falling glass cube is negligible: comment on ‘Relativistic theory of the falling cube gravimeter’’
In the subject paper Ashby (2018 Metrologia 55 1–10) of the comment Svitlov (2018 Metrologia 55 609–13), light propagation through an absolute gravimeter was analyzed, including the propagation delay
Reply to ‘Comment on Relativistic theory of the falling cube gravimeter’
The comment (Křen and Pálinkás 2017 Metrologia 55 314–5) claims that the paper Relativistic theory of the falling cube gravimeter (Ashby 2017 Metrologia 55 1–10) is incorrect. The authors of this
Use of the relativistic phase-time equation in absolute ballistic gravimetry
The signal recorded in absolute ballistic gravimeters and used to track the trajectory of the free-falling corner-cube was recently studied for the first time in full agreement with relativistic
Comparison of Open and Solid Falling Retroreflector Gravimeters
We study whether the optical properties of a solid glass retroreflector influence the value of the acceleration of gravity g determined by dropping both solid and open retroreflectors in an absolute
Relativistic theory of the falling cube gravimeter ∗
In the subject paper [1] of the comment [2], light propagation through an absolute gravimeter was analyzed, including the propagation delay through the falling retroreflector and through the vacuum.
On the effect of the light propagation within the corner-cube reflector of absolute gravimeters
We have assessed the implications of the in-cube light propagation effect in absolute gravimeters, and found it contradictory to existing theoretical and experimental data. We maintain that the

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 14 REFERENCES
No correction for the light propagation within the cube: comment on ‘Relativistic theory of the falling retroreflector gravimeter’
Although the equation of motion developed in the paper (Ashby 2018 Metrologia 55 1) depends on the parameters of the falling cube, such as the depth and refraction index, the parameters are only
Comment on ‘Relativistic theory of the falling retroreflector gravimeter’
In the paper by Ashby (2018 Metrologia 55 1–10) the correction due to the time delay of light propagated through the prism retroreflector of absolute gravimeters is discussed. Accordingly, the
Reply to ‘Comment on Relativistic theory of the falling cube gravimeter’
The comment (Křen and Pálinkás 2017 Metrologia 55 314–5) claims that the paper Relativistic theory of the falling cube gravimeter (Ashby 2017 Metrologia 55 1–10) is incorrect. The authors of this
Relativistic theory of the falling retroreflector gravimeter
We develop a relativistic treatment of interference between light reflected from a falling cube retroreflector in the vertical arm of an interferometer, and light in a reference beam in the
Experimental assessment of the speed of light perturbation in free-fall absolute gravimeters
Precision absolute gravity measurements are growing in importance, especially in the context of the new definition of the kilogram. For the case of free fall absolute gravimeters with a
"Gabl", an Absolute Free-Fall Laser Gravimeter
A high-precision laser gravimeter for measuring the absolute value of gravitational acceleration by the free-fall method has been built in the Siberian Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences
Development of new free-fall absolute gravimeters
The design and first results of two free-fall absolute gravimeters are reported: a stationary gravimeter is designed and can be used as a reference system and a portable gravimeter is aimed at field
A new generation of absolute gravimeters
TLDR
The design improvements incorporated in a new generation of absolute gravimeters, the FG5, have led to an instrumental uncertainty estimate of 1,1 × 10-8 m s-2 (1,0 μGal).
Correction due to the finite speed of light in absolute gravimeters
Equations (45) and (47) in our paper [1] in this issue have incorrect sign and should read The error traces back to our formula (3), inherited from the paper [2]. According to the technical
Frequency-domain analysis of absolute gravimeters
An absolute gravimeter is analysed as a linear time-invariant system in the frequency domain. Frequency responses of absolute gravimeters are derived analytically based on the propagation of the
...
...