Dualism Revisited: Body vs. Mind vs. Soul

@article{Richert2008DualismRB,
  title={Dualism Revisited: Body vs. Mind vs. Soul},
  author={Rebekah A. Richert and Paul L. Harris},
  journal={Journal of Cognition and Culture},
  year={2008},
  volume={8},
  pages={99-115}
}
A large, diverse sample of adults was interviewed about their conception of the ontological and functional properties of the mind as compared to the soul. The existence of the mind was generally tied to the human lifecycle of conception, birth, growth and death, and was primarily associated with cognitive as opposed to spiritual functions. In contrast, the existence of the soul was less systematically tied to the lifecycle and frequently associated with spiritual as opposed to cognitive… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Mind, Soul and Spirit: Conceptions of Immaterial Identity in Different Cultures

The cognitive science of religion has recently focused attention on whether concepts of mind, soul, and spirit derive from the same or different intuitive foundations of immaterial identity. The

Individual Differences in Conceptions of Soul, Mind, and Brain

We examined how people see the role of the brain, the mind, and the soul in biological, psychobiological, and mental states. Three clusters of participants were identified. The monists attributed

The essence of soul concepts: how soul concepts influence ethical reasoning across religious affiliation

Abstract Current research on how humans conceptualize other humans has focused on the hypothesis that we have a dualistic conception of others, differentiating the functions of the body from the

Beliefs about Origins and Eternal Life: How Easy Is Formal Religious Theory Development?

ABSTRACT Two studies investigated children’s and their parents’ reasoning about their mental and bodily states during the time prior to biological conception–“preexistence.” Prior research has

Minds, bodies, spirits, and gods: Does widespread belief in disembodied beings imply that we are inherent dualists?

It is argued that belief in disembodied beings requires cultural learning-a learned dualism and may be prevalent not because the authors are developmentally predisposed to entertain them but because they are counterintuitive and thus have a social transmission advantage.

The Prevalence of Mind-Body Dualism in Early China

This study helps test the proposed universality of folk dualism, adds a new quantitative approach to the methods used in the humanities, and opens up a new and valuable data source for cognitive scientists: the record of dead minds.

A Tale of Two Perspectives: How Psychology and Neuroscience Contribute to Understanding Personhood

Empirical science, such as psychology and neuroscience, employ diverse methods to develop data driven models and explanations for complex phenomena. In research on the self, differences in these

Rethinking people’s conceptions of mental life

This work conducted four large-scale studies designed to assess people’s conceptions of mental life more directly and discovered an organization that differs strikingly from the experience–agency framework: Instead of a broad distinction between experience and agency, these studies consistently revealed three fundamental components ofmental life—suites of capacities related to the body, the heart, and the mind.

I've got a feeling: Urban and rural indigenous children's beliefs about early life mentality.

Similarities and differences in concepts of mental life among adults and children in five cultures.

How do concepts of mental life vary across cultures? By asking simple questions about humans, animals and other entities - for example, 'Do beetles get hungry? Remember things? Feel love?' - we
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 10 REFERENCES

The folk psychology of souls

  • J. Bering
  • Psychology
    Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • 2006
The central thesis of the present article is that an organized cognitive “system” dedicated to forming illusory representations of psychological immortality, the intelligent design of the self, and the symbolic meaning of natural events evolved in response to the unique selective pressures of the human social environment.

The natural emergence of reasoning about the afterlife as a developmental regularity.

Findings suggest that developmental mechanisms underlie intuitive accounts of dead agents' minds, and that older children and adults were likely to attribute epistemic, emotional, and desire states to dead agents.

Children's developing conceptions of the mind and brain.

Evidence is presented to show that by ages 4 and 5 years children commonly regard the brain as an internal mindlike entity associated with a class of distinctly mental acts, which runs counter to previous characterizations of young children as failing to distinguish mental from overt behavioral acts.

Is there room for the soul?

  • J. Tolson
  • Psychology
    U.S. news & world report
  • 2006
Terry Sejnowski, the director of Salk's Computational Neurobiology Laboratory, whose recent research suggests that the authors' conscious minds play less of a role in making decisions than many people have long assumed, admits that it's hard to separate rationalizing from decision making.

Understanding Mortality and the Life of the Ancestors in Rural Madagascar

Together, the two studies replicate and extend findings obtained with Western children showing that, in the course of development, different conceptions of death are elaborated-a biological conception in which death terminates living processes and a religious conception inWhich death marks the beginning of a new form of spiritual existence.

Other Worlds: Notions of Self and Emotion among the Lohorung Rai

This important ethnographic study explores the world-view of the Lohorung Rai, a hill tribe of about 3,000 members living in Eastern Nepal. These rice farmers have a tradition of migration combined

Anthropomorphism or Preparedness? Exploring Children's God Concepts

Historically, the development of God concepts in human cognition has been explained anthropomorphically. In other words, for children especially, God is a big, superhuman who lives in the sky. Recent

Religion and the 2004 Presidential Campaign

In 2004, pollsters found that an individual’s level of religious commitment and activity was the primary indicator of voting behavior. Evangelical Christians turned out in record numbers and moral

The Ghost in My Body: Children's Developing Concept of the Soul

Two experiments were conducted to explore whether children, who have been exposed to the concept of the soul, differentiate the soul from the mind. In the first experiment, 4- to 12-year-old children

Religion, Attitudes, and Social Behavior.