Does the FDA have the authority to trump the Declaration of Helsinki?

@article{Goodyear2009DoesTF,
  title={Does the FDA have the authority to trump the Declaration of Helsinki?},
  author={M. Goodyear and T. Lemmens and D. Sprumont and G. Tangwa},
  journal={BMJ : British Medical Journal},
  year={2009},
  volume={338}
}
A new rule seems to be more about imperialism than harmonisation 
20 Citations
Foreign Bodies: The New Victims of Unethical Experimentation
Despite a number of beneficent outcomes, clinical trials on human subjects have exposed some of the worst forms of state crime, most notably in Nazi Germany. Even with the subsequent establishment ofExpand
Ethical issues associated with using human biological material in collaborative research with developed countries: a case study
A research report submitted to the Faculty of Health Sciences, Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics, University of the Witwatersrand, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MasterExpand
Illegitimate Authorship and Flawed Procedures: Fundamental, Formal Criticisms of the Declaration of Helsinki
TLDR
This article wants to have a closer look at the two criticisms, considered to be the most fundamental, that argue that the last revision process of the Declaration of Helsinki failed to meet the standards for fair, democratic procedures. Expand
An ethics perspective on responsibilities of investigators, sponsors and research participants.
TLDR
This paper is a review of crosscutting guidelines and mix of the key responsibilities of investigators, sponsors, study participants together with their communities. Expand
Pharmaceuticalisation and ethical review in South Asia: issues of scope and authority for practitioners and policy makers.
TLDR
Some of the tensions that emerge for ERC members as the capacity to conduct credible ethical review of clinical trials is developed across the region are identified. Expand
The placebo mystique: Implications for clinical trial methodology
  • V. Clifford
  • Medicine
  • Journal of paediatrics and child health
  • 2011
TLDR
This study aimed to assess doctors' understanding of the requirements for placebo use in clinical trials and suggested that reliance on placebos may be because of methodological misconceptions. Expand
Ethical Considerations in Clinical Research
Abstract This chapter deals with basic information about one of the essential dimensions of clinical research: ethics. It begins with a brief background on the historical aspects of human researchExpand
Procedure versus process: ethical paradigms and the conduct of qualitative research
TLDR
The implications of contrasting ethical paradigms for the conduct of qualitative research and the value of ‘empirical ethics’ as a means of liberating qualitative research from an outmoded and unduly restrictive research governance framework based on abstract prinicipalism are considered. Expand
Why comply with a code of ethics?
  • G. Spielthenner
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • Medicine, health care, and philosophy
  • 2015
TLDR
The paper argues that while ethical codes do not necessarily yield reasons for action, professionals can have genuine reasons for complying with a code, which may, however, be rather weak and easily overridden by reasons for deviating from the code. Expand
Rethinking the Therapeutic Obligation in Clinical Research
A highly debated question in the field of human medical research is the ethically fundamental distinction between clinical research and clinical care. In this regard, the “therapeutic obligation”Expand
...
1
2
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 12 REFERENCES
US exceptionalism comes to research ethics
"The survival of liberty in our land increasingly depends on the success of liberty in other lands. The best hope for peace in our world is the expansion of freedom in all the world"
Fresh thinking about the Declaration of Helsinki
TLDR
A comprehensive approach to ethical research is presented to provide a framework for future generations of scientists to consider the role of science in society and how to promote human rights. Expand
Clinical Trials Guidelines at Odds With U.S. Policy
The World Medical Association last week reaffirmed its opposition to the use of placebos in clinical trials and urged trial sponsors to provide care for participants after studies are done.
CIOMS' placebo rule and the promotion of negligent medical practice.
TLDR
The authors call for an explicit recognition by CIOMS and the World Medical Association of the binding nature of national law and invite national regulatory agencies and other legal scholars to clarify the legal standards in their jurisdiction and to improve awareness of the existence of legal obligations in the context of research. Expand
History and Theory of Human Experimentation: The Declaration of Helsinki and Modern Medical Ethics
Despite having been revised and criticised over the years, the Declaration of Helsinki remains one of the most important and internationally known ethics codes world-wide. Yet we know relativelyExpand
Human subject protection; foreign clinical studies not conducted under an investigational new drug application. Final rule.
  • Medicine
  • Federal register
  • 2008
TLDR
The final rule updates the standards for the acceptance of foreign clinical studies not conducted under an IND and helps ensure the protection of human subjects and the quality and integrity of data obtained from these studies. Expand
Ethical and scientific implications of the globalization of clinical research.
  • J. Adler
  • Medicine
  • The New England journal of medicine
  • 2009
TLDR
D diagnosis of myocardial injury by real-time recording of ST segments of the electrocardiogram in a patient receiving general anesthesia for electroconvulsive therapy and Comparative ef3. Expand
Moral imperialism and multi-centric clinical trials in peripheral countries.
TLDR
The paper proposes the establishment of regulatory and social control systems for clinical trials implemented in peripheral countries, through the formulation of ethical norms that reflect the specific contexts of these countries, along with the drawing up and validation of their own national norms. Expand
Trials on trial: the Food and Drug Administration should rethink its rejection of the Declaration of Helsinki
  • Nature
  • 2008
...
1
2
...