Does encouraging a belief in determinism increase cheating? Reconsidering the value of believing in free will

@article{Nadelhoffer2020DoesEA,
  title={Does encouraging a belief in determinism increase cheating? Reconsidering the value of believing in free will},
  author={Thomas Nadelhoffer and Jason Shepard and Damien L. Crone and Jim Albert Charlton Everett and Brian D. Earp and Neil Levy},
  journal={Cognition},
  year={2020},
  volume={203}
}
A key source of support for the view that challenging people's beliefs about free will may undermine moral behavior is two classic studies by Vohs and Schooler (2008). These authors reported that exposure to certain prompts suggesting that free will is an illusion increased cheating behavior. In the present paper, we report several attempts to replicate this influential and widely cited work. Over a series of five studies (sample sizes of N = 162, N = 283, N = 268, N = 804, N = 982) (four… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Professional Judges’ Disbelief in Free Will Does Not Decrease Punishment
There is a debate in psychology and philosophy on the societal consequences of casting doubts about individuals’ belief in free will. Research suggests that experimentally reducing free will beliefs
Are post-error adjustments influenced by beliefs in free will? A failure to replicate Rigoni, Wilquin, Brass and Burle, 2013
TLDR
The present study found a difference in the scores on the questionnaire, thus a reduced belief in free will, after reading the Crick text, but did not find any difference in post-error slowing between the anti-free will and control groups.
Does Belief in Free Will Increase Support for Economic Inequality?
Does belief in free will increase support for economic inequality? Five studies using diverse measures and methods yield mixed evidence for this question. Study 1 finds belief in free will is
Does Belief in Free Will Increase Support for Economic Inequality?
Does belief in free will increase support for economic inequality? Five studies using diverse measures and methods tested this question. Study 1 finds belief in free will is associated with increased
Does social psychology persist over half a century? A direct replication of Cialdini et al.'s (1975) classic door-in-the-face technique.
TLDR
Testing whether a classical social psychological finding that was published nearly half a century ago can be successfully replicated in another country on another continent suggests that at least some social psychological findings can transcend a particular time, place, and population.
It’s in Your Control: Free Will Beliefs and Attribution of Blame to Obese People and People with Mental Illness
People’s belief in free will is shown to influence the perception of personal control in self and others. The current study tested the hypothesis that individuals who believe in free will attribute
Comparing the Psychometric Properties of Two Japanese-Translated Scales of the Free Will and Determinism-Plus Scale
TLDR
Results revealed that while both FAD+ and FAD-J consist of the same four subscales as the original Fad-Plus, some differences exist in the item-level psychometric characteristics.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 73 REFERENCES
The Value of Believing in Free Will
TLDR
The study of whether inducing participants to believe that human behavior is predetermined would encourage cheating suggests that the debate over free will has societal, as well as scientific and theoretical, implications.
Measuring and Manipulating Beliefs and Behaviors Associated with Free Wil l The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
Free will is typically considered a cornerstone of moral and legal responsibility. So what would happen if our belief in free will turned out to be nothing but a sophisticated illusion? One concern
Believing versus Disbelieving in Free Will: Correlates and Consequences
Some people believe more than others in free will, and researchers have both measured and manipulated those beliefs. Disbelief in free will has been shown to cause dishonest, selfish, aggressive, and
Belief in free will affects causal attributions when judging others’ behavior
TLDR
Overall, these studies show that believing in free will impacts fundamental social-cognitive processes that are involved in the understanding of others’ behavior, and psychological research demonstrates that questioning its existence impacts social behavior.
The Influence of (Dis)belief in Free Will on Immoral Behavior
TLDR
The results show that participants who were primed with a text defending neural determinism – the idea that humans are a mere bunch of neurons guided by their biology – administered fewer shocks and were less vindictive toward the other participant, and this finding only held for female participants, showing the complex interaction between gender, beliefs in free will and moral behavior.
Free will beliefs predict attitudes toward unethical behavior and criminal punishment
TLDR
Evidence is found that the link between free will beliefs and intolerance of unethical behavior was moderated by variations in countries’ institutional integrity, defined as the degree to which countries had accountable, corruption-free public sectors.
Are Free Will Believers Nicer People? (Four Studies Suggest Not)
  • D. Crone, N. Levy
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Social psychological and personality science
  • 2019
TLDR
The findings suggest that the FWB–moral behavior association (and accompanying concerns regarding decreases in FWBs causing moral degeneration) may be overstated.
Determined to conform: Disbelief in free will increases conformity
Does disbelief in free will reduce people's willingness to exert the effort needed for autonomous thought and action rather than simply conforming to group norms? Three studies tested the hypothesis
This Isn’t the Free Will Worth Looking For
According to previous research, threatening people’s belief in free will may undermine moral judgments and behavior. Four studies tested this claim. Study 1 used a Velten technique to threaten
The freedom to excel: Belief in free will predicts better academic performance
Abstract Increasing evidence supports the importance of beliefs in predicting positive outcomes in life. We examined the performance implications of the belief in free will as an abstract,
...
1
2
3
4
5
...