Does Negative Priming Reflect Inhibitory Mechanisms? A Review and Integration of Conflicting Views

@article{Tipper2001DoesNP,
  title={Does Negative Priming Reflect Inhibitory Mechanisms? A Review and Integration of Conflicting Views},
  author={Steven P. Tipper},
  journal={Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology},
  year={2001},
  volume={54},
  pages={321 - 343}
}
  • S. Tipper
  • Published 1 May 2001
  • Psychology, Biology
  • Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology
Negative priming has traditionally been viewed as a reflection of an inhibitory mechanism of attention. However, recent accounts have suggested that negative priming does not reflect inhibitory mechanisms. Rather, slowed reaction times on negative priming trials are either due to retrieval of incompatible response tags or of mismatching perceptual information, or due to extra processes needed to distinguish past from present information. In contrast, it is proposed that there is no firm… 
Negative Priming as a Memory Phenomenon
TLDR
This review presents four models to explain the negative priming effect as well as their essential empirical evidence and concludes that only the distractor inhibition and the episodic retrieval models have survived empirical testing so far.
It is not the copy of record Negative priming in free recall reconsidered
Negative priming in free recall is the finding of impaired memory performance when previously ignored auditory distracters become targets of encoding and retrieval. This negative priming has been
Negative Priming in Free Recall Reconsidered
TLDR
It is found that ignoring auditory distracters is neither sufficient nor necessary to produce the effect of negative priming in free recall, and the effect is more readily accounted for by a buildup of proactive interference occurring whenever 2 successively presented lists of words are drawn from the same semantic category.
Negative Priming 1985 to 2015: A Measure of Inhibition, the Emergence of Alternative Accounts, and the Multiple Process Challenge
In this article, three generations of authors describe the background to the original article; the subsequent emergence of vigorous debates concerning what negative priming actually reflects, where
NegativePrimingasa MemoryPhenomenon A Review of 20Years of Negative Priming Research
TLDR
This review presents four models to explain the negative priming effect as well as their essential empirical evidence and concludes that only the distractor inhibition and the episodic retrieval models have survived empirical testing so far.
Probe distractors can influence negative priming by perceptual grouping
TLDR
The results suggest that perceptual mechanisms can influence negative priming via a race in the probe trial through the role of prime-probe similarity and perceptual interference.
Long and Short-term Negative and Positive Priming
TLDR
Two empirical studies are presented that demonstrate robust and general long-term negative priming without multiple stimulus repetitions and show that repetition increases and delay decreases the effect ofnegative priming.
Selective and nonselective transfer: positive and negative priming in a multiple-task environment.
TLDR
A complex pattern of positive and negative transfer that cannot easily be explained through activation-inhibition of mental structures is observed, and that pattern provides evidence in favor of transfer-appropriate processing.
An event-related potentials study of identity positive and negative priming.
  • J. Hinojosa, Angel Villarino, D. Luna
  • Psychology
    International journal of psychophysiology : official journal of the International Organization of Psychophysiology
  • 2007
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 124 REFERENCES
Selective attention: a reevaluation of the implications of negative priming.
TLDR
The results from a series of experiments demonstrate that selection between 2 competing prime items is not required to observe negative priming.
Determinants of negative priming.
TLDR
A critical review of the negative priming literature suggests that inhibition is a flexible, postselection process operating to prevent recently rejected information from quickly regaining access to effectors, thus helping to establish coherence among selected thought and action streams.
Dual mechanisms of negative priming.
TLDR
The data suggest that contextual variables critically determine whether negative priming is largely due to inhibition or to episodic retrieval, with patterns of performance indicating different sources ofnegative priming effects.
Negative priming without ignoring
Negative priming is conventionally defined by slowed responses to a target item that appeared previously as a distractor. As a result, it is widely assumed that negative priming is caused by an act
Persistence of negative priming: II. Evidence for episodic trace retrieval.
TLDR
Negative priming appears to depend on temporal discriminability of the priming episode, which is slower or less accurate than to new stimuli when delay varies between subjects.
Negative priming from ignored distractors in visual selection: A review
  • E. Fox
  • Psychology
    Psychonomic bulletin & review
  • 1995
TLDR
The present paper reviews the NP literature and considers the evidence for each of the three accounts, called theselective inhibition, feature mismatching, andepisodic retrieval hypotheses, respectively.
Action-centred negative priming: Evidence for reactive inhibition
Experiments are described in which the spatial relationship between a stimulus and respondent is held constant in terms of visual and body-centred coordinates, while the complexity of the response is
Behavioural Goals Determine Inhibitory Mechanisms of Selective Attention
TLDR
Whether distractor inhibition is an invariant process that occurs in the same way for each act of selection, or whether it is a flexible process that adjusts to particular behavioural goals is examined.
A Resource Account of Inhibition
In a letter-naming task, a letter will be named more slowly if it was a distractor on the previous trial This negative priming effect has been instrumental in renewed interest in inhibition The
Negative priming between response modalities: Evidence for the central locus of inhibition in selective attention
TLDR
An experiment is reported in which the locus of inhibition is investigated by looking at whether or not inhibition is isolated in output modalities (for example, verbal naming or manual keypress).
...
...