Does Facial Processing Prioritize Change Detection?

  title={Does Facial Processing Prioritize Change Detection?},
  author={Miko M. Wilford and Gary L Wells},
  journal={Psychological Science},
  pages={1611 - 1615}
There is broad consensus among researchers both that faces are processed more holistically than other objects and that this type of processing is beneficial. We predicted that holistic processing of faces also involves a cost, namely, a diminished ability to localize change. This study (N = 150) utilized a modified change-blindness paradigm in which some trials involved a change in one feature of an image (nose, chin, mouth, hair, or eyes for faces; chimney, porch, window, roof, or door for… 

Figures from this paper

Change detection vs. change localization for own-race and other-race faces.

The other-race effect (ORE) is a well-known phenomenon in which people discriminate and recognize faces from their ethnic group more accurately than faces from other ethnic groups. Holistic

Holistic face processing can inhibit recognition of forensic facial composites.

It is concluded that recognition is impaired because unlike real faces, composites contain inaccuracies and holistic face processing makes it difficult to perceive identifiable features, and identification of forensic facial composites can be enhanced by presenting composites in a misaligned format.

Processing Differences between Feature‐Based Facial Composites and Photos of Real Faces

Summary: Computer-generated faces (composites) constructed by select2ing individual facial features (e.g. eyes, nose, mouth) are poorly recognized because this process contrasts with the natural

Holistic processing improves change detection but impairs change identification

Results from an experiment with 62 participants support the theory that holistic processing improved the detection of change but obstructed its identification and support this trade-off in processing holistic forms.

The effects of face inversion on perceiving- and sensing-based change detection.

The findings indicate that face inversion does not reduce the ability to sense there was a change in the absence of identification, but rather it reduces the able to consciously identify specific characteristics of faces in service of perceiving-based discriminations, and suggests that sensing responds to global differences across the visual image, rather than to changes in holistic processing of the visual input.

Improving face identification of mask-wearing individuals

Research has consistently shown that concealing facial features can hinder subsequent identification. The widespread adoption of face masks due to the COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the critical

Facial Wipes don't Wash: Facial Image Comparison by Video Superimposition Reduces the Accuracy of Face Matching Decisions

In cases of disputed CCTV identification, expert testimony based on the results of analysis by facial image comparison may be presented to the Jury. However, many of the techniques lack empirical

Advances in Facial Composite Technology, Utilizing Holistic Construction, Do Not Lead to an Increase in Eyewitness Misidentifications Compared to Older Feature-Based Systems

The results showed that neither type of composite construction had an effect on participants’ accuracy on a subsequent identification task, suggesting that facial composite systems, including holistic systems, may not negatively impact subsequent eyewitness identification evidence.

Facial composites and the misinformation effect: How composites distort memory

Purpose This study examined how constructing and viewing facial composites affects memory accuracy. Method Participants (n = 240) viewed a target face for 60 s; half were then randomly assigned



Attention to Faces: A Change-Blindness Study

Two experiments with the flicker task of the change-blindness literature found that upright faces receive more efficient attention than inverted faces, and that faces shown with normal contrast receive moreefficient attention than faces shown in photographic negative.

Features and their configuration in face recognition

For normal faces, altering the spatial location of the eyes not only impaired subjects’ recognition of the eye features but also impaired their Recognition of the nose and mouth features—features whose spatial locations were not directly altered.

The representations of spacing and part-based information are associated for upright faces but dissociated for objects: Evidence from individual differences

This work used an individual-differences approach to test whether the shape of face parts and the spacing among them are indeed processed by dissociated mechanisms, whereas the parts and spacing of nonface objects are processed by distinct mechanisms.

Conditions for Facelike Expertise With Objects

Attentive exposure to objects in a difficult training regimen is not sufficient to produce facelike expertise, and qualitatively different types of expertise with objects of a given geometry can arise depending on the type of training.

Local and Relational Aspects of Face Distinctiveness

  • H. LederV. Bruce
  • Psychology
    The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology
  • 1998
The results suggest that at least two dimensions of facial information contribute to a face's apparent distinctiveness, but that these sources of information are differentially affected by turning the face upside-down.

Attention to Configural Information in Change Detection for Faces

Results suggest that attention is automatically directed to second- order relations in upright faces, but not first-order relations, and that this pattern of attentional allocation is similar across features.

When a face is (or is not) more than the sum of its features: Configural and analytic processes in facial temporal integration

To investigate temporal integration in face recognition, top and bottom halves of pictures of famous people were presented sequentially, either upright or inverted, with varying temporal intervals

Why does picture-plane inversion sometimes dissociate perception of features and spacing in faces, and sometimes not? Toward a new theory of holistic processing

The results argue that holistic/configural processing for upright faces integrates exact feature shape and spacing between blobs and describes two plausible approaches to this process.

Parts and Wholes in Face Recognition

  • J. TanakaM. Farah
  • Psychology
    The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology
  • 1993
The hypothesis that face recognition is holistic predicts that a part of a face will be disproportionately more easily recognized in the whole face than as an isolated part, relative to recognition of the parts and wholes of other kinds of stimuli.