Disorder and Public Spaces in Montreal: Repression (And Resistance) Through Law, Politics, and Police Discretion

  title={Disorder and Public Spaces in Montreal: Repression (And Resistance) Through Law, Politics, and Police Discretion},
  author={Marie-{\`E}ve Sylvestre},
  journal={Urban Geography},
  pages={803 - 824}
This study shows that the control of disorder in Montreal, Canada, and its consequences for the occupation of public spaces by the homeless, are neither directly dictated by the law nor rely only on the law as a source of legitimacy and authority. They also depend on other forms of expression of state power expressed through local policies, architectural changes, political demands, police discretion, and policing practices, which in turn have connections to the law. This combination of factors… 
The Control of Public Spaces in Montreal in Times of Managerial Justice1
In Montreal, homeless people and protesters receive a disproportionate number of statements of offence. These statements of offence are issued by the Montreal police department for the homeless and
Spatial Tactics in Criminal Courts and the Politics of Legal Technicalities
This paper documents court-imposed bail and sentencing conditions with spatial dimensions, such as red zones, no contact conditions, curfews and prohibitions to demonstrate, issued in the context of
Governing public nuisance: Collaboration and conflict regarding the presence of homeless people in public spaces of Montreal
Exclusionary policing has been a strong, enduring trend for responding to the presence of marginalised groups in public spaces of Western cities – at times so dominant that it overshadows the
Policing cities: Incivility, disorder, and societal transformations
Over the past 30 years, we have been witnessing a rise in incivility policing across western but also non-western cities. The term “incivility policing” refers to bans and exclusion aimed at drinking
Taking the Law to the Streets: Legal and Spatial Tactics Deployed in Public Spaces to Control Protesters and the Homeless in Montreal
Author(s): Fortin, Veronique | Advisor(s): Bibler Coutin, Susan | Abstract: Homeless people and protesters in Montreal have at least one thing in common: both groups (and they are by no means
Navigating the Territories of Law - Introduction to Red Zones: Criminal Law and the Territorial Governance of Marginalized People
In Red Zones, Marie-Eve Sylvestre, Nicholas Blomley, and Celine Bellot examine the court-imposed territorial restrictions and other bail and sentencing conditions that are increasingly issued in the
Good Relations, Micro-Entrepreneurship, and Permissive Spaces: "Transitional" Homelessness in St. Petersburg
This study examines how survival strategies of homeless people in St. Petersburg, Russia, have been affected by "rollback" and "rollout" patterns of neoliberalism. The chaotic transition to a market
Who Banishes? City Power and Anti-homeless Policy in San Francisco
Despite cross-disciplinary attention to laws targeting homeless behavior in cities, systematic analysis of the power dynamics behind the adoption and implementation of such laws is surprisingly
Narratives of Punishment: Neoliberalism, Class Interests and the Politics of Social Exclusion
This is a response piece to Eoin O'Sullivan's article "Varieties of Punitiveness in Europe: Homeless and Urban Marginality" in which O'Sullivan challenges the grand narrative according to which the
Beyond criminocentric dogmatism: Mapping institutional forms of punishment in contemporary societies
This article aims to question the role criminal justice and criminal law play in structuring the set of dominant conditioning questions in criminology. Based on socio-legal approaches and past


The Annihilation of Space by Law: The Roots and Implications of Anti‐Homeless Laws in the United States
There is a link between changes in the contemporary political economy and the criminalization of homelessness. Anti-homeless legislation can be understood as an attempt to annihilate the spaces in
Policing the homeless in Montreal: is this really what the population wants?
Since the 1990s in Montreal, the implementation of community policing and the enforcement of anti-disorder programmes has had dramatic consequences on the homeless. Relying on empirical evidence from
The Common Place of Law: Stories from Everyday Life
This study explores the different ways people view the law. It identifies three common narratives: one is based on the idea of the law as magisterial and remote; another views the law as a game with
  • Political Science, Law
  • 2009
The mission of the Commission des droits de la personne et des droits de la jeunesse is to defend the principles set out in the Charter of human rights and freedoms. The legislator gives the
San Francisco's Matrix Program for the Homeless
Cities across the country are engaged in a great experiment: having lost control of their public spaces, can they reclaim them? Over the last three decades, judicial rulings and changing social
Zero Tolerance: Quality of Life and the New Police Brutality in New York City
New York City in the 1990s was haunted by the fate of Amadou Diallo, Abner Louima, and Anthony Baez, among other men of color who were victims of police violence. This Introduction to the anthology
Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison
This writer who has warned us of the “ideological” function of both the oeuvre and the author as unquestioned forms of discursive organization has gone quite far in constituting for both these
The Place of Law
It has long been standard practice in legal studies to identify the place of law within the social order. And yet, as The Place of Law suggests, the meaning of the concept of "the place of law" is
Crimes of Style: Urban Graffiti and the Politics of Criminality
Jeff Ferrell draws on his own extensive field research to thoroughly examine the practices of graffiti artists. Focusing on the city of Denver, he takes a close look at the war against graffiti and
The Exclusive Society: Social Exclusion, Crime and Difference in Late Modernity
From Inclusive to Exclusive Society Crime and Discord in an Age of Late Modernity Cannibalism and Bulimia Essentialising the Other Demonisation and the Creation of Monstrosity The Criminology of