Dialogical approaches to struggles over recognition and distribution

  title={Dialogical approaches to struggles over recognition and distribution},
  author={Michael Temelini},
  journal={Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy},
  pages={423 - 447}
  • Michael Temelini
  • Published 31 March 2014
  • Sociology
  • Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy
This paper contrasts three non-skeptical ways of explaining and reconciling political struggles: monologue, instrumental dialogue, and a comparative dialogical approach promoted by Charles Taylor and James Tully. It surveys the work of Taylor and Tully to show three particular family resemblances: their emphasis on practice, irreducible diversity, and periodic reconciliation. These resemblances are evident in the way they employ dialogical approaches to explain struggles over recognition and… 
Learning Politics by Means of Examples
My aim is to explain Wittgenstein’s remarks on the epistemology of giving examples and to consider how this ramifies in the study of politics . In parts of The Blue and Brown Books (Preliminary
On Global Citizenship
  • J. Tully
  • Political Science, Sociology
  • 2014
As the world becomes increasingly interdependent in commerce, technology, and popular culture, people of different cultures must reconcile diametrically opposed views of fairness, equity, and
Is non-formal learning a solution to enhance immigrant children’s empowerment in northern Finnish communities?
ABSTRACT The increasing diversity in northern Finland calls for innovative ways to support the development of immigrant children’s socio-cultural skills so that they may improve their integration and


Recognition and dialogue: the emergence of a new field
The field comprising both the theory and practice of struggles over recognition developed over the last 50 years in relative independence of the parallel field of deliberative and agonistic
Political philosophy in a post-imperial voice: James Tully and the politics of cultural recognition
This essay analyses Tully's approach to political philosophy and his arguments concerning the constitutional recognition of cultural diversity. It contextualizes Tully's approach within a discussion
Political Reconciliation Through a Struggle for Recognition?
In societies divided by a history of political violence, political reconciliation depends on transforming a relation of enmity into one of civic friendship. In such contexts, the discourse of
A Deliberative Approach to Conflicts of Culture
How should liberal democratic states respond to cultural practices and arrangements that run afoul of liberal norms and laws? This article argues for a reframing of the challenges posed by
Perspectives on Charles Taylor's reconciled society
This article explores Charles Taylor's Hegelian and Aristotelian ethic of reconciliation. It comments on the critical work provided by Joel Anderson, Jürgen Habermas, Chandras Kukathas, Morag
Reconciling the Solitudes: Essays on Canadian Federalism and Nationalism
Taylor is one of the world's pre-eminent experts on Hegel and brings to his reflections on nationalism and federalism the fruits of a more universal philosophical discourse rooted in the
Public Philosophy in a New Key. Volume I: Democracy and Civic Freedom,
These two ambitious volumes from one of the world's most celebrated political philosophers present a new kind of political and legal theory that James Tully calls a public philosophy, and a
Authenticity and the Politics of Identity: A Critique of Charles Taylor's Politics of Recognition
This essay evaluates Charles Taylor's defence of a politics of recognition in light of his broader account of modern identity and the self. I argue that his call for a politics of recognition betrays
Meaning And Context Quentin Skinner And His Critics
Quentin Skinner is one of the leading thinkers in the social sciences and humanities today. Since the publication of his first important articles some two decades ago, debate has continued to develop
Hermeneutics, Political Inquiry, and Practical Reason: An Evolving Challenge to Political Science
  • M. Gibbons
  • Psychology
    American Political Science Review
  • 2006
In its evolution over the past century, mainstream political science has failed to take account of changes in the development of interpretive approaches to politics. Adherents of the dominant