• Corpus ID: 8491773

Determinism: What We Have Learned and What We Still Don’t Know

  title={Determinism: What We Have Learned and What We Still Don’t Know},
  author={John Earman},
The purpose of this paper is to give a brief survey the implications of the theories of modern physics for the doctrine of determinism. The survey will reveal a curious feature of determinism: in some respects it is fragile, requiring a number of enabling assumptions to give it a fighting chance; but in other respects it is quite robust and very difficult to kill. The survey will also aim to show that, apart from its own intrinsic interest, determinism is an excellent device for probing the… 

Figures from this paper


Determinism and Indeterminism

Determinism is a rich and varied concept. At an abstract level of analysis, Jordan Howard Sobel (1998) identifies at least ninety varieties of what determinism could be like. When it comes to


The inconsistencies involved in the foundation of set theory were invariably caused by infinity and self-reference; and only with the opportune axiomatic restrictions could them be obviated.

Determinism and General Relativity

We investigate the fate of determinism in general relativity (GR), comparing the philosopher’s account with the physicist’s well-posed initial value formulations. The fate of determinism is

Does the Dome Defeat the Material Theory of Induction?

According to John D. Norton's Material Theory of Induction, all inductive inferences are justified by local facts, rather than their formal features or some grand principles of nature's uniformity.

Kant on Freedom, Nature and Normativity

In typical debates about freedom, compatibilists and incompatibilists dispute whether and how one can defuse the threat that a naturalistic worldview seems to pose for our conception of free will.

Quantum mechanics as a deterministic theory of a continuum of worlds

The theory explains (1) the subjective occurrence of probabilities, (2) their quantitative value as given by the Born rule, and (3) the apparently random “collapse of the wavefunction” caused by the measurement, while still being an objectively deterministic theory.

Quantum mechanics as a deterministic theory of a continuum of worlds

A non-relativistic quantum mechanical theory is proposed that describes the universe as a continuum of worlds whose mutual interference gives rise to quantum phenomena. A logical framework is

Approaching the Planck Scale from a Generally Relativistic Point of View: A Philosophical Appraisal of Loop Quantum Gravity

My dissertation studies the foundations of loop quantum gravity (LQG), a candidate for a quantum theory of gravity based on classical general relativity. At the outset, I discuss two---and I claim


Hoefer (2007, p. 550) offers the opinion that ‘the vast majority of scientists using non-subjective probabilities overtly or covertly in their research feel little need to spell out what they take



The Transcendental Character of Determinism

DETERMINISM in philosophical discussions of determinism I believe it is fair to say that there is not ordinarily a sharp separation of a process being deterministic and a process being predictable.

Just How Radical is Hyperplane Dependence

Recently Tim Maudlin of Rutgers University has published a book, entitled Quantum Nonlocality and Relativity (1994), in which some of the peculiar twists taken by the quantum measurement problem in

Quantum Measurement: Beyond Paradox

This volume of Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science has a decided commitment to modal interpretations and shows the varied perspectives that one expects to find at a conference and a focussed framework for examining the nuances of quantum mechanics.

Extension of Quantum Mechanics to Individual Systems

The Copenhagen Interpretation describes individual systems, using the same Hilbert space formalism as does the statistical ensemble interpretation (SQM). This leads to the well-known paradoxes

The expanding worlds of general relativity

I Relativity in the Making.- The Search for Gravitational Absorption in the Early Twentieth Century.- Minkowski, Mathematicians, and the Mathematical Theory of Relativity.- Heuristics and

Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime and Black Hole Thermodynamics

In this book, Robert Wald provides a pedagogical introduction to the formulation of quantum field theory in curved spacetime. He begins with a treatment of the ordinary one-dimensional quantum

The Hawking Information Loss Paradox: The Anatomy of Controversy

Stephen Hawking has argued that universes containing evaporating black holes can evolve from pure initial states to mixed final ones. Such evolution is non-unitary and so contravenes fundamental

Unified dynamics for microscopic and macroscopic systems.

A modified quantum dynamics for the description of macroscopic objects is constructed and it is shown that it forbids the occurrence of linear superpositions of states localized in far-away spatial regions and induces an evolution agreeing with classical mechanics.

What is observable in classical and quantum gravity

The problem of the identification of the observable quantities in quantum gravity (or in any diffeomorphism invariant quantum theory) is considered. The author recalls Einstein's 'hole argument' on

The Modal Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Preface D. Dieks, P.E. Vermaas. Introduction D. Dieks, P.E. Vermaas. Lorentz-Invariance in Modal Interpretations M. Dickson, R. Clifton. Locality and Lorentz-Covariance in the Modal Interpretation of