Declarations of Independence: Arendt and Derrida on the Problem of Founding a Republic

@article{Honig1991DeclarationsOI,
  title={Declarations of Independence: Arendt and Derrida on the Problem of Founding a Republic},
  author={Bonnie Honig},
  journal={American Political Science Review},
  year={1991},
  volume={85},
  pages={97 - 113}
}
  • B. Honig
  • Published 1 March 1991
  • Art
  • American Political Science Review
Beginning with Hannah Arendt's depiction of the American Revolution and founding, I critically examine Arendt's reading of the Declaration of Independence, comparing it with Jacques Derrida's reading of (a draft of) the same document, in order to show that Arendt is careless in her easy dismissal of the declaration's essentialist moments. Derrida, it seems to me, has a better, more subtle appreciation of the both necessary and impossible role of essentialism in modern political theory and… 

Jacques Derrida on the secular as theologico-political

The article explores Jacques Derrida’s view of the secular as the field of the socio-political. It focuses on his argument as to why religion and politics cannot be strictly separated as in the

GLOBAL WAR, POPULAR REFERENDUMS, AND (NON-)DECLARATIONS OF INDEPENDENCE

  • E. Illas
  • Sociology, Political Science
    Angelaki
  • 2021
Abstract The formation of new states has always been an uncertain process. Yet with the emergence of global war and the destabilization of the political categories of modernity, state founding has

Sovereignty Without Sovereignty: Derrida’s Declarations Of Independence

This article questions the common assumptions in legal theory regarding Derrida’s well-known Declarations of Independence. Through a close reading of this text, well-known ground such as the relation

Believing in the USA: Derrida, Melville and the Great American Charlatan

ABSTRACT This essay considers the relationship between the prophet and the charlatan, particularly as they figure in the contemporary American political landscape. It argues that at moments of

Derrida’s Jefferson 1

Hannah Arendt claims that the American Revolution provides a standard against which political modernity can be analyzed, also that subsequent revolutions failed to engage the conceptual purity of the

Derrida's Rethinking of Professorial Authority

  • Samir Haddad
  • Sociology
    Journal of the American Philosophical Association
  • 2017
ABSTRACT: In this paper I argue that Derrida's writings on education contain a profound rethinking of professorial authority. I first outline the sources of professorial authority and describe how

Colonising ‘Free’ Will

While colonialism, in general, is a contested concept, as are the conditions that constitute its negation, political decolonisation seems to be a relatively settled argument. Where such

Declaration as Disavowal: The Politics of Race and Empire in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights

This article argues that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), by claiming certain inheritances from eighteenth-century American and French rights declarations, simultaneously disavowed

The Crisis of German Historicism: The Early Political Thought of Hannah Arendt and Leo Strauss

Introduction 1. The untimely generation 2. The problem of politics in Arendt's and Strauss' early writings 3. History and political understanding: an ambivalent symbiosis 4. Liberalism and modernity:

‘A living document’: promises of the ASEAN Charter

Abstract Many recent analyses of the ASEAN Charter have tended to view the document very critically, judging the chances for implementation as low. In order to assess the potential of the Charter,
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 30 REFERENCES

The social contract.

  • W. Blundell
  • Medicine, Political Science
    Health law in Canada
  • 1993
To be effective, the process must be 'customer friendly,' and therefore, the need for the local community panel to deal with all of the health care needs of that community is seen.

Between past and Future

The reader will find in this volume essentially two points of view presented, one largely sociological and the other psychological in orientation. The sociological point of view presented by

Feminists Theorize the Political

Introduction I. Contesting Grounds II. Signifying Identity III. Subjects Before the Law IV. Critical Practices V. Postmodern Post-Script.

The Government of Poland

This edition includes a translator's preface, note on the text, and suggestions for further reading.

Thoughts on Machiavelli.

Preface Introduction I: The Twofold Character of Machiavelli's Teaching II: Machiavelli's Intention: The Prince III: Machiavelli's Intention: The Discourses IV: Machiavelli's Teaching Notes Index

Devant la Loi

  • J. Derrida
  • Philosophy
    Royal Institute of Philosophy Lecture Series
  • 1983
…: ainsi faict la science (et nostre droict mesme a, diet-on, des fictions légitimes sur lesquelles il fonde la vérité de sa justice);(…) (Montaigne, Essais II, f. XII). Un titre résonne parfois

Fortune Is a Woman