Death and Furniture: the rhetoric, politics and theology of bottom line arguments against relativism

  title={Death and Furniture: the rhetoric, politics and theology of bottom line arguments against relativism},
  author={Derek Edwards and Malcolm Ashmore and Jonathan Potter},
  journal={History of the Human Sciences},
  pages={25 - 49}
and participants in the 15th Discourse and Reflexivity Workshop (University of Sheffield, September 1992) for making helpful comments on an earlier draft of this paper. In this version pages are counted according to the published numbers with breaks following the published version. 
Let's get real: a critical semiotic analysis of Irish print media discourses
ABSTRACT In what follows, I critically assess the merits of the relativist and realist positions in the social and human sciences, and argue that the relativisation of truth claims operates to mask
Where Constructionism and Critical Realism Converge: Interrogating the Domain of Epistemological Relativism
The paper interrogates the status, nature and significance of epistemological relativism as a key element of constructionism and critical realism. It finds that epistemological relativism is espoused
The Mangle of Practice: Agency and Emergence in the Sociology of Science
Some difficult but important issues have arisen in recent social studies of science concerning temporally emergent phenomena and the decetering of the human subject in scientific practice. This essay
Regulating criticism: some comments on an argumentative complex
This commentary identifies a range of flaws and contradictions in Parker’s critical realist position and his critique of relativism. In particular we highlight: (1) a range of basic errors in
Gergen's Social Constructionism
There has been increasing interest in the epistemological and ontological implications of social constructionism. The debate has been conducted on almost overwhelmingly neo-Kantian terms: Do concepts
(Mis)constructing social construction: Answering the critiques
This article aims to review the main criticisms of social construction (SC) after its formalization as a “movement” in the social sciences. The critiques are organized into six dominant areas that
Review Essay: Boudon's European Diagnosis of and Prophylactic against Relativism
Raymond Boudon is the doyen of French sociology. His 2004 book The Poverty of Relativism counters the relativist plague with philosophical, historical, and comparative deconstruction and proposes an
A genealogy of postmodern subjects: Discourse analysis and late capitalism
Critiques of psychology’s complicities with the ideological workings of capitalism have focused on psychologies developed prior to the 1980s, against which discursive and postmodern theories are
Post‐truth politics and discursive psychology
This paper argues for the potential of discursive psychology (DP) in the study of post-truth politics. Work produced outside of psychology is considered, particularly from political science and
Discursive Study of Religion: From States of the Mind to Communication and Action
This article addresses the predicament of the academic study of religions and directs the debate into more fruitful fields of research. After a brief account of the most important problems -


Mapping the Language of Racism. Discourse and the Legitimation of Exploitation. (Löschper)
The topics of race and racism are often treated narrowly in social psychological and other social scientific literature, usually being presented as subcategories of stereotyping or prejudice or
Opening Pandora's Box: A Sociological Analysis of Scientists' Discourse
Acknowledgements Preface 1. Scientists' discourse as a topic 2. A possible history of the field 3. Contexts of scientific discourse 4. Accounting for error 5. The truth will out 6. Constructing and
The Dialectic of Ideology and Technology: The Origins, Grammar and Future of Ideology
Let us begin with the closing consecration: “Knowing it will win no easy victories, relying upon its continual work and struggle, as well as upon a sometimes quiet capacity for ‘surrender,’ critical
Science, the very idea
The notion of science is a dominant and enduring feature of Western thought. This book looks at the social study of science, which has begun to transform attitudes to science traditionally upheld by
Literary Rhetoric of Science - Comedy and Pathos in Drinking Driver Research
This paper is part of a larger study of how knowledge is used in strategies for the solution of public issues. I examine research papers on the issue of drinking and driving, treating the scientific
The Dialectic of Ideology and Technology: The Origins of Grammar and Future of Ideology
In the ordinary language of everyday life, as in the extraordinary language of sociology (be it academic sociology or Marxist), “ideology” is stigmatized as a pathological object. It is seen as
Knowledge and social imagery
The first edition of this book profoundly challenged and divided students of philosophy, sociology, and the history of science when it was published in 1976. In this second edition, Bloor responds in
Mundane Reason: Reality in Everyday and Sociological Discourse
Preface Acknowledgements 1. The problem of mundaneity 2. Mundane idealizations 3. The self-preservation of mundane reason 4. Mundane puzzles and the politics of experience 5. Mundane autobiography 6.
The Politics of Postmodernism
General editor's preface. Acknowledgements. 1. Representing the postmodern: What is postmodernism? Representation and its politics, Whose postmodernism? Postmodernity, postmodernism, and modernism.
The Reflexive Thesis: Wrighting Sociology of Scientific Knowledge
This unusually innovative book treats reflexivity, not as a philosophical conundrum, but as a practical issue that arises in the course of scholarly research and argument. In order to demonstrate the