David Dudley Field and the Field Code: A Historical Analysis of an Earlier Procedural Vision

  title={David Dudley Field and the Field Code: A Historical Analysis of an Earlier Procedural Vision},
  author={Stephen N. Subrin},
  journal={Law and History Review},
  pages={311 - 373}
With current procedure under assault, this is a particularly important time to study the procedural rules and thought of David Dudley Field's era. The present espousal of such devices as case management and alternative dispute resolution is both a sign of and a reaction to a procedural regime that is in question and in decline, if not in its death throes. But before embarking on new procedural roads or recommitting ourselves to old paths, we need to reflect upon our procedural ancestry in some… 

The Union of Law and Equity

From the colonial era to the present day, a number of jurisdictions in the United States have purported to fuse the disparate systems of common law and equity. This chapter focuses on the

Adr: The New Equity

The proliferation of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) has transformed the administration of civil justice. As both a rival and a complement to formal adjudication, ADR presents an alternative

Langdell on Contracts and Legal Reasoning: Correcting the Holmesian Caricature

During the first decade of his tenure as dean of Harvard Law School (HLS) from 1870 to 1895, Christopher C. Langdell (1826–1906) produced closely related works on contracts and sales that exercised

United States: Harmonisation and voluntarism. The role of elites in creating an influential national model, the federal rules of civil procedure

The starting place for any discussion of civil procedure in the United States is the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (‘FRCP’), rules first enacted in 1938 and made applicable solely to federal

The Fable of the Codes: The Efficiency of the Common Law, Legal Origins & Codification Movements

The superior efficiency of the common law has long been a staple of the law and economics literature. Generalizing from this claim, the legal origins literature uses cross-country empirical research

Happy Anniversary to the CPLR: A Joint Achievement of the Practicing Bar and the Academy

This September, we celebrated the 50th anniversary of the Civil Practice Law and Rules of New York State. The CPLR was the handiwork of the Advisory Committee on Practice and Procedure, appointed in

The costs of class actions: allocation and collective redress in the US experience

Once a preserve of the American legal landscape, the class action device today transcends geographic boundaries. In the past decade, efforts have intensified to establish collective litigation

The “Science” of Legal Science: The Model of the Natural Sciences in Nineteenth-Century American Legal Education

In the first half of the nineteenth century, a model of legal education called “legal science” became prominent in American universities. The idea of teaching law as a science was not new in American

Civil Justice, Privatization, and Democracy

This project is about the privatization of civil justice and its potential ramifications for democracy. Privatization is rapidly and increasingly occurring at all levels of the public justice system,

Judging Equity



Failing Faith: Adjudicatory Procedure in Decline

We are approaching the fiftieth anniversary of the enactment of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.1 Reconsideration of the Rules is appropriate for several reasons, not the least of which is to

How Equity Conquered Common Law: The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure in Historical Perspective

Part I of this Article first looks at the major components of common law and equity procedure, and then examines the domination of an equity mentality in the Federal Rules. Part II explores the

History, Systems and Functions of Pleading

WHAT IS PLEADING? Before any dispute can be adjusted or decided it is necessary to ascertain the actual points at issue between the disputants. Conceivably this may be done in several ways. Perhaps


In working out the details of the great pleading reform of i848, the New York "Commissioners on Practice and Pleadings" attempted to employ a technique based upon two utterly inconsistent principles.


When the New York Commissioners on Practice and Pleadings substituted the one form of civil action for the separate actions at law and suits in equity they did not succeed in establishing a system

The Causes of Popular Dissatisfaction with the Administration of Justice

DISSATISFACTION with the administration of justice is as old -*-&dquo; as law. Not to go outside of our own legal system, discontent has an ancient and unbroken pedigree. The Anglo-Saxon laws

Treating Blacks as If They Were White: Problems of Definition and Proof in Section 1982 Cases

Immediately after the Civil War, the United States Congress enacted, over presidential veto, a statute popularly known as the 1866 Civil Rights Act. In 1870 that statute was reenacted, and a major

The social and political foundations of adjudication

Adjudication is the process by which the values embodied in an authoritative legal text, such as the Constitution, are given concrete meaning and expression. In my judgment, this has always been the

The American political tradition and the men who made it

A revised edition of the clasic study of American politics from the Founding Fathers to FDR. In american view all of as, liberal franklin delano. Roosevelt hofstadter truly has been built that the

The Graying of Civil Rights Law: The Age Discrimination Act of 1975

Nondiscrimination laws have come to play a central role in the design of public policy in the modem welfare state. Such laws place those who administer them in the difficult business of allocating