• Corpus ID: 845274

D1.2.3 Methods for ontology evaluation

@inproceedings{Hartmann2004D123MF,
  title={D1.2.3 Methods for ontology evaluation},
  author={Jens Hartmann and York Sure-Vetter and Alain Giboin and Diana Maynard and Mari Carmen Su{\'a}rez-Figueroa and Roberta Cuel},
  year={2004}
}
The deliverable D1.2.3 analyses and evaluates existing methods for ontology content evaluation according requirements from an industrial point of view. EU-IST Network of Excellence (NoE) IST-2004-507482 KWEB Deliverable D1.2.3 (WP 1.2) Document Identifier: KWEB/2004/D1.2.3/v1.3 Class Deliverable: KWEB EU-IST-2004-507482 Version: Revised V 1.3.1 Date: January 31, 2005 State: Final Distribution: Public Page 2 of 49 Knowledge Web Consortium This document is part of a research project funded by the… 
A Synthesis Survey of Ontology Evaluation Tools, Applications and Methods to Propose a Novel Branch in Evaluating the Structure of Ontologies: Graph-Independent Approach
TLDR
This paper attempts to propose a novel branch in structural analysis of ontology through analyzing current methods, which is called Graph-independent approach.
Semi-automatic Ontology Construction based on Patterns
TLDR
Results show that it is possible to improve the results of typical existing ontology learning methods by selecting and reusing patterns, and this thesis introduces a typology of patterns, a general framework of pattern-based semi-automatic ontology construction called OntoCase, and specific methods to solve some specific tasks within this framework.
Ontology-based methodology for error detection in software design
TLDR
The Methodology for Objects to Agents enhances software design quality by integrating multiple software design views, integrating object-oriented and agent-oriented concepts, and defining an error detection method that associates rules with ontological properties.
Challenges in Ontology Evaluation
TLDR
This section considers two main types of ontology errors, T-Box errors of logic or A- box errors of fact, and how well current tools identify these errors.
An Automated System for the Assessment and Ranking of Domain Ontologies
TLDR
This thesis provides an in-depth analysis of the current research in domain ontology evaluation, including the development of a taxonomy to categorize the numerous directions the research has taken and a suite of ontology quality assessment metrics grounded in semiotic theory are presented.
Deriving an Australian marine ontology from existing ontological models: a practical evaluation.
TLDR
This paper presents some selection criteria that are deemed important for choosing potentially reusable ontologies when dealing with marine science data.
OntoKBEval : a support tool for OWL ontology evaluation
The Support Tool for OWL Ontology Evaluation (OntoKBEval) has been developed to apply Description Logics reasoning to ontology evaluation by deriving information from knowledge bases. The principal
OntoAbsolute as a ontology evaluation methodology in analysis of the structural domains in upper, middle and lower level ontologies
  • M. Amirhosseini, J. Salim
  • Computer Science
    2011 International Conference on Semantic Technology and Information Retrieval
  • 2011
TLDR
A new ontology evaluation methodology which it is proposed to evaluate structural domains in semantic relations and concepts in upper, middle and lower ontologies through proposed criteria and related measures, called OntoAbsolute.
The Evaluation of Ontologies: Toward Improved Semantic Interoperability
TLDR
Issues and problems in ontology evaluation are discussed, some current strategies are described, and some approaches that might be useful in the future are suggested.
The Evaluation of Ontologies
TLDR
Issues and problems in ontology evaluation are discussed, some current strategies are described, and some approaches that might be useful in the future are suggested.
...
1
2
3
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 123 REFERENCES
On the query refinement in the ontology-based searching for information
TLDR
This paper presents a novel approach for determining possible refinements of an ontology-based query based on measuring the ambiguity of a query with respect to the original user's information need and presents a ranked list of the potentially useful refinement of her query.
Methodology for the Design and Evaluation of Ontologies
TLDR
The goal of the TOVE (TOronto Virtual Enterprise) Enterprise Modelling project is to create the next generation Enterprise Model, a Common Sense Enterprise Model that has the ability to deduce answers to queries that require relatively shallow knowledge of the domain.
The Usable Ontology: An Environment for Building and Assessing a Domain Ontology
TLDR
This paper presents a method and a set of software tools aimed at supporting domain experts in populating a domain ontology and obtaining a shared consensus on its content.
Usage-Oriented Evolution of Ontology-Based Knowledge Management Systems
TLDR
A novel approach based on the analysis of the users' behaviour in two phases of a knowledge management cycle, which results in the recommendations for changes in the underlying ontology, the annotations and/or the knowledge repository in order to make the whole system more efficient.
ODEVAL: A Tool for Evaluating RDF(S), DAML+OIL and OWL Concept Taxonomies
TLDR
ODEval is offered, a language-dependent tool for evaluating, from the point of view of knowledge representation, concept taxonomies in ontologies implemented in such languages.
Ontologies: principles, methods and applications
TLDR
This paper outlines a methodology for developing and evaluating ontologies, first discussing informal techniques, concerning such issues as scoping, handling ambiguity, reaching agreement and producing definitions, and considers, a more formal approach.
Data Driven Ontology Evaluation
TLDR
It is proposed in this paper that one approach to ontology evaluation should be corpus or data driven, because a corpus is the most accessible form of knowledge and its use allows a measure to be derived of the ‘fit’ between an ontology and a domain of knowledge.
Evaluation of RDF(S) and DAML+OIL Import/Export Services within Ontology Platforms
TLDR
Assessment of ontology evaluation functionalities of OilEd, OntoEdit, Protege-2000, and WebODE reveals that most of these ontology platforms only detect some mistakes in concept taxonomies during building ontologies and do not detect any taxonomic mistake when exporting ontologies to such languages.
A Comprehensive Guideline for Building a Domain Ontology from Scratch
Conceptual analysis and knowledge representation often require to develop an ontological support. The activity of developing a domain ontology is therefore one of the fundamental steps to be carried
Assessment of Ontology-based Tools: A Step Towards Systemizing the Scenario Approach
TLDR
This paper accounts for the CoMMA experience and its major lesson: the necessity to apply the scenario approach more systematically for assessing the usability and utility of ontology-based tools.
...
1
2
3
4
5
...