Culture, dialectics, and reasoning about contradiction.

@article{Peng1999CultureDA,
  title={Culture, dialectics, and reasoning about contradiction.},
  author={Kaiping Peng and Richard E. Nisbett},
  journal={American Psychologist},
  year={1999},
  volume={54},
  pages={741-754}
}
Chinese ways of dealing with seeming contradictions result in a dialectical or compromise approach—retaining basic elements of opposing perspectives by seeking a "middle way." On the other hand, European-American ways, deriving from a lay version of Aristotelian logic, result in a differentiation model that polarizes contradictory perspectives in an effort to determine which fact or position is correct. Five empirical studies showed that dialectical thinking is a form of folk wisdom in Chinese… Expand

Figures from this paper

Dialectical Thinking, Psychology of
Dialectical thinking, as a psychological concept, refers to a purposeful and effortful mental process for contemplating facts, views, and goals of opposing perspectives. It is commonly associatedExpand
Understanding Dialectical Thinking from a Cultural-Historical Perspective
The present essay aims to throw light on the study of dialectical thinking from a cultural-historical perspective. Different forms of dialectic are articulated as ideal types, including the GreekExpand
Dialectical responses to questions about dialectical thinking.
TLDR
Instead of responding to individual comments, a synthesis is proposed that may resolve some of the seeming contradictions between the authors' statements and the statements of the critics. Expand
Dialectics of culture and dynamic balancing between individuality and collectivity
This study offers an Eastern alternative to the Western perspective that is fundamentally disjunctive in its approach to culture and communication. Inspired by Cartesian dualism and HegelianExpand
Dialectical Versus Linear Thinking Shapes People’s Anticipation of Climate Change
TLDR
Chinese participants demonstrated a stronger non-linear pattern regarding the anticipation of climate change as compared with American participants, in which Chinese participants were more likely to anticipate a stable trend but less likely to anticipating an increasing trend for global warming. Expand
Naïve Dialecticism and Indecisiveness
Previous research suggests that individuals of East Asian (vs. European) cultural backgrounds are more indecisive, and this cultural difference is related to naïve dialecticism, a lay belief systemExpand
Cultural Differences in Expectations of Change and Tolerance for Contradiction: A Decade of Empirical Research
TLDR
The authors show how dialectical thinkers show greater expectation of change in tasks related to explanation and prediction and greater tolerance of contradiction in tasks involving the reconciliation of contradictory information in the domains of the self, emotional experience, psychological well-being, attitudes and evaluations, social categorization and perception, and judgment and decision making. Expand
The Dialectical Self-Concept: Contradiction, Change, and Holism in East Asian Cultures
TLDR
Naïve dialecticism provides a comprehensive theoretical framework for understanding cultural differences and the contradictory, changeable, and holistic nature of the East Asian self-concept. Expand
The Influence of Naive Dialecticism on Cultural Differences in Decision-Making
This paper examines the research literature addressing the influence of culture-related naïve dialecticism on indecisiveness. We define naïve dialecticism and discuss literature laying out itsExpand
Problem Finding and Contradiction: Examining the Relationship Between Naive Dialectical Thinking, Ethnicity, and Creativity
This research examined the association between naive dialectical thinking and creativity, measured as originality in problem construction and reframing (types of problem finding). Ethnic identityExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 112 REFERENCES
Reasons for the lack of argumentation and debate in the Far East
Abstract This essay examines Chinese and Japanese attitudes towards speech communication, particularly in public settings. Social, linguistic, and philosophical perspectives are used to explain theExpand
Running Head: CULTURE AND THOUGHT Culture and Systems of Thought: Holistic vs. Analytic Cognition
We propose a theory of how systems of thought arise on the basis of differing cultural practices and argue that the theory accounts for substantial differences in East Asian and Western thoughtExpand
Dialectic operations: the final period of cognitive development.
TLDR
Although Piaget's interpretations capture a rich variety of performances during childhood they fail to represent adequately the thought and emotions of mature and creative persons, and a return to the dialectic basis is necessary for an interpretation of adulthood and aging. Expand
Dialectics of Nature
Preface MARXISM has a two-fold bearing on science. In the first place Marxists study science among other human activities. They show how the scientific activities of any society depend on itsExpand
Culture and development of everyday social explanation.
  • J. G. Miller
  • Medicine
  • Journal of personality and social psychology
  • 1984
TLDR
Evidence suggests that these cross-cultural and developmental differences result from contrasting cultural conceptions of the person acquired over development in the two cultures rather than from cognitive. Expand
Causal attribution across cultures: Variation and universality.
Growing cross-cultural evidence suggests that East Asians are less likely to show the correspondence bias, or a preference for explanations of behavior in terms of traits, dispositions, or otherExpand
Dialectical Thinking and Adult Development
This book describes and illustrates the nature of dialectical thinking as a cognitive psychological phenomenon, and makes the case that this form of cognitive organizaton is a possible successor toExpand
Demystifying mentalities
Cultural psychology of surprise: holistic theories and recognition of contradiction.
  • I. Choi, R. Nisbett
  • Medicine, Psychology
  • Journal of personality and social psychology
  • 2000
TLDR
The authors testing the hypothesis that East Asians, because of their holistic reasoning, take contradiction and inconsistency for granted and consequently are less likely than Americans to experience surprise found that even when contradiction was created in highly explicit ways, Korean participants experienced little surprise, whereas American participants reported substantial surprise. Expand
Effects of devil's advocacy and dialectical inquiry on decision making: A meta-analysis
Abstract For the past two decades, researchers have been investigating the effects of two techniques for promoting and managing cognitive conflict on decision making; devil's advocacy (DA) andExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...