Cromwell, Robespierre, Stalin (and Lenin?): Must Revolution Always Mean Catastrophe?

  title={Cromwell, Robespierre, Stalin (and Lenin?): Must Revolution Always Mean Catastrophe?},
  author={Bill Bowring},
Leon Trotsky, reflecting on British history, wrote: ‘The ‘dictatorship of Lenin’ expresses the mighty pressure of the new historical class and its superhuman struggle against all the forces of the old society. If Lenin can be juxtaposed to anyone then it is not to Napoleon nor even less to Mussolini but to Cromwell and Robespierre. It can be with some justice said that Lenin is the proletarian twentieth-century Cromwell. Such a definition would at the same time be the highest compliment to the… 
1 Citations

United States Communist History Bibliography 2016, and a Selective Bibliography of Non-U.S. Communism and Communism-Related Theory

The principal subject of this annual bibliography is the English language scholarly literature of American Communism (supplemented by the occasional article from serious journals of opinion,



The many Robespierres from 1794 to the present

Biographies of Robespierre have been pouring out since the dawn of the century. Marc Belissa and Yannick Bosc’s book is an intervention by two historians of modern political thought to the problem of

Heroic Power in Thomas Carlyle and Leo Tolstoy

This paper explores two opposed paradigmatic approaches to heroic power: Thomas Carlyle's versus Leo Tolstoy's. In On Heroes, Hero Worship and the Heroic in History (1840), Carlyle argues for its

In Defence of the Terror: Liberty or Death in the French Revolution

For two hundred years after the French Revolution, the Republican tradition celebrated the execution of princes and aristocrats, defending the Terror that the Revolution inflicted upon on its

Constructing the Enemy: Stalin’s Political Imagination and the Great Terror

This article analyses Stalin’s political imagination, which is crucial in our understanding of the nature of the Great Terror. Through the minutes of the 1936–1938 show trials this article explores


This article examines the ‘Red Terror’ of the Russian Civil War through a comparative analysis with terror during the French Revolution. First, it suggests that the experiences of the Jacobins had a

History, hysteria, and the revolutionary subject in Thomas Carlyle's French revolution

Thomas Carlyle's French Revolution employs a mode of historicalrepresentation that constructs revolution as a form of social pathology, as opposed to envisioning it foremost as an instrument of

I Book Review: The Degradation of the International Legal Order? The Rehabilitation of Law and the Possibility of Politics

Providing the basis for critical engagement with the pessimism of the contemporary age, The Degradation of the International Legal Order? argues passionately for a rehabilitation of the honour of

The Origins of Totalitarianism

The vast majority of all human beings alive on earth is affected in some measure by the totalitarian mass movements of our time. Whether men are members, supporters, fellow-travellers, naive

Interpreting the French Revolution

Preface Part I. The French Revolution is Over: Part II. Three Approaches to the history of the French Revolution: 1. The revolutionary catechism 2. De Tocqueville and the problem of the French