• Corpus ID: 117132690

Critique of the Gibbs volume entropy and its implication

@article{Wang2015CritiqueOT,
  title={Critique of the Gibbs volume entropy and its implication},
  author={Jian-Sheng Wang},
  journal={arXiv: Statistical Mechanics},
  year={2015}
}
Dunkel and Hilbert, "Consistent thermostatistics forbids negative absolute temperatures," Nature Physics, {\bf 10}, 67 (2014), and Hilbert, H\"anggi, and Dunkel, "Thermodynamic laws in isolated systems," Phys. Rev. E {\bf 90}, 062116 (2014) have presented an unusual view of thermodynamics that sets aside several properties that have traditionally have been assumed to be true. Among other features, their results do not satisfy the postulates of thermodynamics originally proposed by Tisza and… 

Figures from this paper

Meaning of temperature in different thermostatistical ensembles
TLDR
This work surveys the notion of thermodynamic temperature in different statistical ensembles, focusing in particular on subtleties that arise when ensembled become non-equivalent, and addresses open mathematical problems that arise for systems with discrete energy spectra.
de Meaning of temperature in different thermostatistical ensembles
Depending on the exact experimental conditions, the thermodynamic properties of physical systems can be related to one or more thermostatistical ensembles. Here, we survey the notion of thermodynamic
Resolving the debate about proposed expressions for the classical entropy
Despite well over a century of effort, the proper expression for the classical entropy in statistical mechanics remains a subject of debate. The Boltzmann entropy (calculated from a surface in phase
Thermodynamics, Statistical Mechanics and Entropy
TLDR
The postulates for thermodynamics are examined critically, and some modifications are suggested to allow for the inclusion of long-range forces, inhomogeneous systems with non-extensive entropy, and systems that can have negative temperatures.
The question of negative temperatures in thermodynamics and statistical mechanics
  • D. A. Lavis
  • Physics
    Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics
  • 2019
Phase transitions at high energy vindicate negative microcanonical temperature.
TLDR
It is shown that Boltzmann (negative) temperature allows the description of phase transitions occurring at high energy densities, at variance with Gibbs temperature, to be applied to nonlinear lattice models standardly employed to describe the propagation of light in arrays of coupled wave guides and the dynamics of ultracold gases trapped in optical lattices.
Meaning of temperature in different thermostatistical

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 37 REFERENCES
Gibbs, Boltzmann, and negative temperatures
In a recent paper, Dunkel and Hilbert [Nat. Phys. 10, 67–72 (2014)] use an entropy definition due to Gibbs to provide a “consistent thermostatistics” that forbids negative absolute temperatures.
Negative temperatures and the definition of entropy
Thermodynamics and Statistical Mechanics at Negative Absolute Temperatures
TLDR
A thermodynamic system that is in internal thermodynamic equilibrium, that is otherwise essentially isolated, and that has an energetic upper limit to its allowed states can possess a negative temperature.
Consistent thermostatistics forbids negative absolute temperatures
Over the past 60 years, a considerable number of theories and experiments have claimed the existence of negative absolute temperature in spin systems and ultracold quantum gases. This has led to
An Introduction to Statistical Mechanics and Thermodynamics
This is a textbook on statistical mechanics and thermodynamics. It begins with the molecular nature of matter and the fact that we want to describe systems containing many (1020) particles. The first
Phase transitions at high energy vindicate negative microcanonical temperature.
TLDR
It is shown that Boltzmann (negative) temperature allows the description of phase transitions occurring at high energy densities, at variance with Gibbs temperature, to be applied to nonlinear lattice models standardly employed to describe the propagation of light in arrays of coupled wave guides and the dynamics of ultracold gases trapped in optical lattices.
The physics and mathematics of the second law of thermodynamics
Unnormalized probability: A different view of statistical mechanics
All teachers and students of physics have absorbed the doctrine that probability must be normalized. Nevertheless, there are problems for which the normalization factor only gets in the way. An
In Defense of Gibbs and the Traditional Definition of the Entropy of Distinguishable Particles
TLDR
The traditional Gibbs calculation of the entropy of distinguishable classical particles that leads to Gibbs Paradox has been criticized recently, but the traditional definition of entropy works quite well in situations where the distinguishability of classical particles is taken seriously while a suggested replacement definition fails.
Gibbs volume entropy is incorrect.
We show that the expression for the equilibrium thermodynamic entropy contains an integral over a surface in phase space, and in so doing, we confirm that negative temperature is a valid
...
...