Critique of Callicott's Biosocial Moral Theory

@article{Hadley2007CritiqueOC,
  title={Critique of Callicott's Biosocial Moral Theory},
  author={John Hadley},
  journal={Ethics \& the Environment},
  year={2007},
  volume={12},
  pages={67 - 78}
}
  • J. Hadley
  • Published 2 May 2007
  • Psychology
  • Ethics & the Environment
J. Baird Callicott's claim to have unified environmentalism and animal liberation should be rejected by holists and liberationists. By making relations of intimacy necessary for moral considerability, Callicott excludes from the moral community nonhuman animals unable to engage in intimate relations due to the circumstances of their confinement. By failing to afford moral protection to animals in factory farms and research laboratories, Callicott's biosocial moral theory falls short of meeting… 
View via Publisher
8 Citations
Background Citations
2

8 Citations

MIDGLEY AT THE INTERSECTION OF ANIMAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS
This paper explores the intersection of animal and environmental ethics through the thought of Mary Midgley. Midgley’s work offers a shift away from liberal individualist animal ethics toward a…
Communitarianism and Animals
We saw in the last chapter that John Rawls published his A Theory of Justice as a response to the dominant utilitarian ideas of the time. Rawls wanted to offer a defence of liberal democratic…
Two Views of Animals in Environmental Ethics
This chapter concerns the role accorded to animals in the theories of the English-speaking philosophers who created the field of environmental ethics in the latter half of the twentieth century. The…
Canine Justice: An Associative Account
A prominent view in contemporary political theory, the ‘associative view’, says that duties of justice are triggered by particular cooperative relations between morally significant agents, and that…
Addressing anthropocentrism in nonhuman ethics: evolution, morality, and nonhuman moral beings
TLDR
This thesis puts forward a new definition of anthropocentrism based on a thorough overview of use in the literature and via analogy with other centrisms, such as androcentrism, and proposes a nonhuman ethic that aims to be less anthropocentric.
For the Sake of the Friendship: Relationality and Relationship as Grounds of Beneficence
I contend that there are important moral reasons for individuals, organisations and states to aid others that have gone largely unrecognised in the literature. Most of the acknowledged reasons for…
The Planner¿s Guide to Natural Resource Conservation:
Exurbanization occurs on privately owned lands that are found beyond the metropolitan fringe and outside the jurisdiction of federal and state lands held in the public trust. This chapter describes…
An ethical defense of modern zoos

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 38 REFERENCES
Environmental Ethics, Animal Welfarism, and the Problem of Predation: A Bambi Lover's Respect For Nature
Many environmentalists criticize as unecological the emphasis that animal liberationists and animal rights theorists place on preventing animal suffering. The strong form of their objection holds…
In Nature's Interests? Interests, Animal Rights, and Environmental Ethics (review)
This book offers a powerful response to what Varner calls the "two dogmas of environmental ethics"-the assumptions that animal rights philosophies and anthropocentric views are each antithetical to…
Morals, Reason and Animals
TLDR
Anyone with an interest in ethical decision-making would find great value in this book, and Gert has dealt with complex issues in a manner which is likely to appeal to the intelligent lay reader.
The Animal Ethics Reader
TLDR
This book discusses the history and current state of animal ethics, as well as some of the theories of Animal Ethics and its applications to human rights and vegetarianism.
The Sexual Politics of Meat: A Feminist-Vegetarian Critical Theory
What does the eating of meat have to do with the women's movement? Is there a cultural correlation between our image of and attitude toward women and the slaughter of animals? This study answers…
SINGER AND HIS CRITICS
Notes on Contributors. Preface. 1. Singer and the Practical Ethics Movement: Dale Jamieson (Carleton College). 2. Noncognitivism, Validity, and Conditionals: Frank Jackson (Australian National…
Morals, reason, and animals
Preface Acknowledgments Part I: The Moral (In)Significance of Reason 1. Why Should I Be Rational? "Rationality" and Its Alternatives * The Methodological Counterattack * The Moral of the Story 2.…
A companion to ethics
Introduction, Peter Singer. Part 1 The roots: the origins of ethics ethics in small-scale societies ancient ethics (Mary Midgley, George Silberbauer, Gerald A.Larue). Part 2 The great ethical…
Encyclopedia of Animal Rights and Animal Welfare
TLDR
The encyclopedia helps readers understand the different viewpoints of animal welfare advocates who want to improve conditions for animals and animal rights activists who don't want animals used at all.
Hume on Regulating Belief and Moral Sentiment
There have been numerous discussions in recent years of Hume's general point of view. Some of the issues raised have been (1) Is the general point of view the moral point of view? (2) Is the general…
...
...