Critical remarks on Landauer's principle of erasure-dissipation: Including notes on Maxwell demons and Szilard engines

@article{Kish2015CriticalRO,
  title={Critical remarks on Landauer's principle of erasure-dissipation: Including notes on Maxwell demons and Szilard engines},
  author={Laszlo B. Kish and Sunil P. Khatri and Claes G{\"o}ran Granqvist and Janusz M. Smulko},
  journal={2015 International Conference on Noise and Fluctuations (ICNF)},
  year={2015},
  pages={1-4}
}
  • L. Kish, S. Khatri, J. Smulko
  • Published 22 September 2014
  • Physics
  • 2015 International Conference on Noise and Fluctuations (ICNF)
We briefly address Landauer's Principle and some related issues in thermal demons. We show that an error-free Turing computer works in the zero-entropy limit, which proves Landauer's derivation incorrect. To have a physical logic gate, memory or information-engine, a few essential components necessary for the operation of these devices are often neglected, such as various aspects of control, damping and the fluctuation-dissipation theorem. We also point out that bit erasure is typically not… 

Figures from this paper

Zero and negative energy dissipation at information-theoretic erasure

TLDR
A new non-volatile, charge-based memory scheme wherein the erasure can be associated with even negative energy dissipation; this implies that the memory’s environment is cooled during information erasure and contradicts Landauer's principle of erasure dissipation.

Hidden Dissipation and Irreversibility in Maxwell’s Demon

TLDR
The transport fluxes of mass, momentum, and energy involved in the demon's operation are analyzed and show that they imply "hidden" external work and dissipation, indicating one mechanism by which macroscopic irreversibility may emerge from microscopic dynamics.

Response to “Comment on ‘Zero and negative energy dissipation at information-theoretic erasure”’

TLDR
It is proved that statistical information-theoretic quantities, such as information entropy, cannot generally be interrelated with the lower limit of energy dissipation during information erasure, and that information entropy does not convert to thermodynamic entropy and to the related energy Dissipation.

The Thermodynamics of Computation: A Contradiction

  • W. Porod
  • Physics
    Energy Limits in Computation
  • 2018
TLDR
This chapter examines in detail Landauer's influential argument that erasure of information is a fundamental source of energy dissipation in computation, and concludes that the thermodynamics of computation is a contradiction in terms.

Algorithmic Entropy and Landauer’s Principle Link Microscopic System Behaviour to the Thermodynamic Entropy

TLDR
Algorithmic information theory in conjunction with Landauer's principle can quantify the cost of maintaining a reversible real-world computational system distant from equilibrium as bit flows are used to track the way a highly improbable configuration trends toward a highly probable equilibrium configuration.

Information entropy and thermal entropy: apples and oranges

TLDR
It is shown that, contrary to fortuitous situations and common beliefs, there is no general interrelation between the information entropy and the thermodynamical entropy and this can violate the Third Law of Thermodynamics.

Information, Noise, and Energy Dissipation: : Laws, Limits, and Applications

This chapter addresses various subjects, including some open questions related to energy dissipation, information, and noise, that are relevant for nano- and molecular electronics. The object is to

Hybrid Analog Signal-Based Models of Computation

The present work attempts both a review of previous methods for transferring digital and symbolic computations in an analog or optical substrate and also to offer certain alternatives not yet fully

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 26 REFERENCES

Demons: Maxwell's demon, Szilard's engine and Landauer's erasure-dissipation

This talk addressed the following questions in the public debate at HoTPI: (i) energy dissipation limits of switches, memories and control; (ii) whether reversible computers are possible, or does

Experimental verification of Landauer’s principle linking information and thermodynamics

TLDR
It is established that the mean dissipated heat saturates at the Landauer bound in the limit of long erasure cycles, demonstrating the intimate link between information theory and thermodynamics and highlighting the ultimate physical limit of irreversible computation.

All Shook Up: Fluctuations, Maxwell's Demon and the Thermodynamics of Computation

TLDR
A new argument concerning conservation of phase space volume shows that all Maxwell’s demons must fail.

Comments on the breakdown of the Landauer bound for information erasure in the quantum regime

Upon reviewing the article by Allahverdyan and Nieuwenhuizen in PRE, we conclude that neither the Landauer principle nor the counterexamples presented by the authors have any relation (i) to

Stability versus reversibility in information processing

The paper is motivated by the discussion of feasibility of large scale quantum computations which should incorporate both unitarity of quantum dynamics for information bearing degrees of freedom and

Irreversibility and heat generation in the computing process

TLDR
Two simple, but representative, models of bistable devices are subjected to a more detailed analysis of switching kinetics to yield the relationship between speed and energy dissipation, and to estimate the effects of errors induced by thermal fluctuations.

Electrical Maxwell Demon and Szilard Engine Utilizing Johnson Noise, Measurement, Logic and Control

TLDR
A purely electrical version of Maxwell's demon which does not involve mechanically moving parts and has purely electronic controls and is free of the major weakness of the original Szilard engine in not requiring removal and repositioning the piston at the end of the cycle.