Cosmology, calendars and society in Neolithic Orkney: a rejoinder to Euan MacKie

  title={Cosmology, calendars and society in Neolithic Orkney: a rejoinder to Euan MacKie},
  author={Clive Ruggles and Gordon J Barclay},
  pages={62 - 74}
The authors examine critically MacKie's long-standing contentions concerning Neolithic Britain — theocratic control of society, the relationships between monuments and sunrise or sunset on significant days of the year, the use of an ‘elaborate and accurate’ solar calendar and its survival into the Iron Age and into modern times. 

The Great Stone Circle (B) at Grange, Co. Limerick: A Ceremonial Space for All Seasons?

Prehistoric stone circles are generally interpreted as having had a variety of roles and meaning in the Neolithic and Bronze Age, especially as places for gathering and ceremony in the case of the

Foragers, fishers and farmers: origins of the Taiwanese Neolithic

The Neolithic of Taiwan represents the first stage in the expansion of Austronesian-speaking peoples through the Pacific. Settlement and burial evidence from the Tapenkeng (TKP) or Dabenkeng culture

The Prehistoric Solar Calendar: An Out-of-fashion Idea Revisited with New Evidence

Abstract The work of Alexander Thom on the geometrical and astronomical achievements of prehistoric Britain—depending as it does almost entirely on data gained from surveying and statistical

The structure and skills of British Neolithic Society: a brief response to Clive Ruggles & Gordon Barclay

Introduction This 6s a summary of my reply to the criticisms of my views published recently in this journal (Ruggles & Barclay 2000); the original 36,000-word version [itself reduced from 33,000!),

Mobility in the Mountains: Late Third and Second Millennia Alpine Societies' Engagements with the High-Altitude Zones in the Southern French Alps

The assessment of the important changes that occurred in late third and second millennia societies across Europe often emphasizes changes in technology and the emergence of associated objects and art

Claish, stirling: an early Neolithic structure in its context

The excavation of a long timber-built structure of the early Neolithic near Callander (formerly Perthshire, now Stirling Council area) is described. The remains appear to be those of a structure

Rediscovering the Winter Solstice Alignment at Newgrange, Ireland

Newgrange was the first prehistoric site in Ireland to have its astronomical alignment widely accepted, and since its discovery in 1967 has remained the best-known astronomically oriented


This paper attempts to answer the question if the skyline phenomenon of the reappearing Sun can be seen from several monuments as part of an Neolithic Orcadian culture? Several sites are evaluated.

An investigation of an Aberdeenshire ritual landscape: a site of human sacrifice associated with Venus

  • D. Nance
  • History
    Scottish Geographical Journal
  • 2021
ABSTRACT A group of intervisible prehistoric monuments delineate a ritual landscape of 102 kilometres near Hatton of Fintray, Aberdeenshire. They act as back and foresights on solar and lunar horizon

Pushing back the frontiers or still running around the same circles? ‘Interpretative archaeoastronomy’ thirty years on

  • C. Ruggles
  • Physics
    Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union
  • 2011
Abstract This personal perspective on the development of archaeoastronomy over the last thirty years focuses on interpretative and methodological issues, picking up for example from the debate




Summary. This paper reviews some recent developments in the study of non-utilitarian monuments in relation to a new analysis of a group of earthworks at Dorchester on Thames, Oxfordshire, excavated

The Prehistory of Orkney

A series of essays which cover the prehistory of the Orkney Islands, from the Neolithic to the Viking period. Topics discussed include the first settlers, ritual monuments and chambered cairns,

Maeshowe and the winter solstice: ceremonial aspects of the Orkney Grooved Ware culture

A generation ago, enquiries into the astronomical and mathematical knowledge of the standing stone-erectors of prehistoric Britain dealt largely with statistical patterns. Since then, the great

Stonehenge: Neolithic man and the cosmos

There have been many attempts to explain the purpose of Stonehenge. Using archaelogical detail and a knowledge of the heavens as they were many millennia ago, North establishes the function of the

Neolithic and Bronze Age Scotland

"Crammed with information and open-minded...A good antidote to the mystical humbug the subject too often attracts."--"Scotland on Sunday."

Astronomy in prehistoric Britain and Ireland

Do prehistoric stone monuments in Britain and Ireland incorporate deliberate astronomical alignments, and if so, what is their purpose and meaning? This work provides an account of megalithic

Monuments as landscape: Creating the centre of the world in late Neolithic Orkney

Abstract In Britain and Ireland there is a tendency for late Neolithic monuments to be clustered in groups and located at similar topographic positions. In this paper a group of spectacular

Circumstance not context: the Neolithic of Scotland as seen from outside

An overall survey of the relative strengths and weaknesses of research on the Scottish Neolithic is attempted, focusing particularly on recent work. The high quality of much of the evidence is

Historic Britain From The Air

The landscape of Britain is scattered with the haunting traces of prehistoric man: the causeway camps and henges of the New Stone Age, the stone circles and standing stones of the Bronze Age and

Continuity Over Three Thousand Years of Northern Prehistory: The ‘tel’ at Howe, Orkney

The excavation report of Howe, a multi-period prehistoric site in Orkney, appeared, in 1994 and is reviewed here in detail. The Iron Age levels revealed a series of stone roundhouses and broch-like