Coordination and Status Influence

  title={Coordination and Status Influence},
  author={C. Robert Clark and Samuel J. Clark and Mattias Polborn},
  journal={Rationality and Society},
  pages={367 - 391}
We develop a model to explain why the influence of higher-status individuals is often accepted even when status is not an indication of superior information or competence. We propose such acceptance as a rational strategy in cases where coordination is important. In our model agents must select from among a set of alternatives after witnessing the choices of some group of initial movers, one of whom is assumed to be of high status. These agents would like to select the better alternative, but… 

Figures from this paper

Social status as a cue for tacit coordination
The present paper investigates how and when social status may serve as a cue for tacit coordination. In three experimental studies, we demonstrate that low status individuals are inclined to defer to
Status Hierarchies and the Organization of Collective Action
Most work on collective action assumes that group members are undifferentiated by status, or standing, in the group. Yet such undifferentiated groups are rare, if they exist at all. Here we extend an
Why is the Pack Persuasive? The Effect of Choice Status on Perceptions of Quality
The logic of social proof and related arguments posits that decision makers interpret an actor’s sociometric position (such as popularity) as a signal for quality, especially when quality itself is
A social-psychological perspective on tacit coordination: How it works, when it works, (and when it does not)
We present a programmatic line of experimental studies which focus on the how and when of tacit coordination (i.e., the phenomenon that people can successfully coordinate their decisions without
A social-psychological perspective on tacit coordination: How it works, when it works, (and when it does not)
We present a programmatic line of experimental studies which focus on the how and when of tacit coordination (i.e., the phenomenon that people can successfully coordinate their decisions without
The Many Gifts of Status: How Attending to Audience Reactions Drives the Use of Status
An empirical test of this argument is provided by analyzing how the sales gap between prizewinning books and their shortlisted-only peers changes during the December holidays, when the purchase of books as gifts increases relative to purchases for one’s own personal use.
The Paradox of Publicity
Although increases in status often lead to more favorable inferences about quality in subsequent evaluations, in this paper, we examine a setting in which an increase to an actor’s status results in
It’s the Conventional Thought That Counts
A core claim of sociological theory is that modern institutions fall short of their meritocratic ideals, whereby rewards should be allocated based on achievement-related criteria. Instead,
Ideological Boundaries of Status Advantages: Legislative Effectiveness in the United States House of Representatives
Prior research assumes that high-status actors have greater organizational influence than lower-status ones, that is, it is easier for the former to get their ideas and initiatives adopted by the
The Dynamics of Prosocial Leadership: Power and Influence in Collective Action Groups
This paper bridges insights from theories of collective action, power, and influence to address the conditions under which group leaders solve collective action problems. We show how leaders’


Information and crowding externalities
Summary.We analyze a model in which agents have to make a binary choice under incomplete information about the state of the world, but also care about coordination with other agents who have the same
Structure and Strategy in Collective Action1
  • M. Chwe
  • Sociology
    American Journal of Sociology
  • 1999
This article considers both structural and strategic influences on collective action. Each person in a group wants to participate only if the total number taking part is at least her threshold;
Learning from neighbours
When payoffs from different actions are unknown, agents use their own past experience as well as the experience of their neighbours to guide their decision making. In this paper, we develop a general
Expectation States Theory and the Motivational Determinants of Social Influence
In this chapter we give an overview of our research program in which we investigate how status affects the influence behavior of people in co-operative task groups. Based on expectation states theory
Does the self conform to the views of others
The interactionist tenet that we come to see ourselves as others see us has received only inconsistent support throughout its history, in part because of a number of factors that can disrupt the
Global Games: Theory and Applications
Many economic problems are naturally modeled as a game of incomplete information, where a player’s payoff depends on his own action, the actions of others, and some unknown economic fundamentals. For
Rational Ritual: Culture, Coordination, and Common Knowledge.
Game theory shows that in order to coordinate its actions, a group of people must form "common knowledge." Each person wants to participate only if others also participate. Members must have
A Simple Model of Herd Behavior
We analyze a sequential decision model in which each decision maker looks at the decisions made by previous decision makers in taking her own decision. This is rational for her because these other
Access to occupations through social ties
Abstract Previous studies which examine the theory linking social resources to instrumental action have focused on a particular activated set of social ties in order to assess the effects of social
This chapter reviews theory and research on status organizing processes. A status organizing process is any process in which evaluations of and beliefs about the characteristics of actors become the