Cooperative Advocacy: An Approach for Integrating Diverse Perspectives in Anomaly Response

  title={Cooperative Advocacy: An Approach for Integrating Diverse Perspectives in Anomaly Response},
  author={Jennifer Watts-Perotti and David D. Woods},
  journal={Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW)},
This paper contrasts cooperative work in two cases of distributed anomaly response, both from space shuttle mission control, to learn about the factors that make anomaly response robust. In one case (STS-76), flight controllers in mission control recognized an anomaly that began during the ascent phase of a space shuttle mission, analyzed the implications of the failure for mission plans, and made adjustments to plans (the flight ended safely). In this case, a Cooperative Advocacy approach… Expand
Accountability on the Fly - Accounting for Trouble in Space Operations
This paper shows how accounts of trouble are designed to manage uncertainty in the larger network, while also positioning the operators as competent and reliable members of the network. Expand
The High Reliability Organization Perspective
Publisher Summary High reliability theory describes the extent and nature of the effort that people, at all levels in an organization, have to engage in to ensure consistently safe operations despiteExpand
Ordering networks : motorways and the work of managing disruption
This thesis contributes to a new understanding of the motorway network and its traffic movements as a problem of practical accomplishment. It is based on a detailed ethnomethodological study ofExpand
Human factors in mission control centers
This chapter focuses on mission control centers that provide direct support of spaceflight operations in real time and the human factors and training that facilitate their effectiveness in support of flight safety. Expand
How Human Adaptive Systems Balance Fundamental Trade-offs: Implications For Polycentric Governance Architectures
Investigations into complex adaptive systems (CAS) have identified multiple trade-offs that place hard limits on the behavior of adaptive systems of any type. Complexity theory continues to searchExpand
Performing Under Uncertainty: Contextualized Engagement in Wildland Firefighting
In this paper, we propose that performance under uncertainty and ambiguity is enabled by a two‐pronged set of practices enacted by leaders and frontline workers. These contextualized practices fuelExpand
The theory of graceful extensibility: basic rules that govern adaptive systems
  • D. Woods
  • Computer Science
  • Environment Systems and Decisions
  • 2018
The theory of graceful extensibility is introduced which expresses fundamental characteristics of the adaptive universe that constrain the search for sustained adaptability and attempts to provide a formal base and common language that characterizes how complex systems sustain and fail to sustain adaptability as demands change. Expand
Capturing the dynamics of attention control from individual to distributed systems: the shape of models to come
New technology presents opportunities for enhancing the performance of human systems that are tasked to meet multiple, often competing demands. Yet, mistakes in designing and deploying theseExpand
Uncertainty and Transparency: Augmenting Modelling and Prediction for Crisis Respons
This work discusses ethically and socially motivated demands for transparency and develops methods to render ‘the world’ transparent in ways that can inform, fine-tune and validate models. Expand
Relational Reasoning and Its Manifestations in the Educational Context: a Systematic Review of the Literature
Relational reasoning, the ability to discern meaningful patterns within otherwise unconnected information, is regarded as central to human learning and cognition and as particularly critical forExpand


Shift Changes, Updates, and the On-Call Architecture in Space Shuttle Mission Control
Targeted field observations were conducted to investigate what it means to date a supervisory controller on the status of a continuous, anomaly-driven process in a complex, distributed environment and demonstrate how missing updates can leave flight controllers vulnerable to being vulnerable toBeing unprepared. Expand
Shift Changes, Updates, and the On-Call Model in Space Shuttle Mission Control
A field study was conducted to investigate what it means to update a supervisory controller on the status of a continuous, anomaly-driven process in a complex, distributed environment. Expand
How Anomaly Response is Distributed Across Functionally Distinct Teams in Space Shuttle Mission Control
In this paper, we describe the coordinative anomaly response processes of functionally distinct teams who encountered a space shuttle anomaly at the beginning of a shuttle mission. Anomaly responseExpand
Strategies for designing distributed systems: case studies in the design of an air traffic management system
An abstract characterization of a number of different conceptual approaches to deal with cognitive complexity and redundancy in the National Airspace System are provided and their effectiveness is illustrated and evaluated in terms of concrete realizations found within the Nationalairspace System. Expand
Information flow during crisis management: challenges to coordination in the emergency operations center
Challenges to coordination in the emergency operations center (EOC) of a county-level EOC are discussed and recommendations for better supporting coordination in crisis management are offered. Expand
Mission Control Knowledge Synchronization: Operations to Reference Performance Cycles
Capturing and utilizing previously generated knowledge is crucial to an organization's development and responsiveness in a dynamic environment. Even so, the creation of a reference source fromExpand
Voice Loops as Coordination Aids in Space Shuttle Mission Control
By understanding how voice loops meet the particular demands of the mission control environment, insight can be gained for the design of groupware tools to support cooperative activity in other event-driven domains. Expand
Brittleness in the design of cooperative problem-solving systems: the effects on user performance
The results show that the presentation of a suggestion or recommendation by the computer early in the person's own problem evaluation can have a significant impact on that person's decision processes, influencing situation assessment and the evaluation of alternative solutions. Expand
Communication of Intent in Military Command and Control Systems
Military command and control (C2), air traffic control, and nuclear power plant control rooms are examples of distributed supervisory control systems. Distributed supervisory control systems areExpand
Flexecution as a Paradigm for Replanning, Part 1
  • G. Klein
  • Computer Science
  • IEEE Intelligent Systems
  • 2007
This is the first of two essays about planning and execution with ill-defined and conflicting goals to describe the importance of goal discovery to planners and project managers who might not appreciate the difficulties posed by ill- defined goals. Expand