Controversy: Politics of Technical Decisions

  title={Controversy: Politics of Technical Decisions},
  author={Dorothy Nelkin},
This book of controversies over science and technology describes and analyses the struggles between different perspectives: between those who see technological development as a rational and objective process and those who see this process as primarily political. 'No one has produced a more formidable body of work on technology, politics, and decision-making than Dorothy Nelkin; and I, like many others, have come to look forward to each new instalment. Controversy, a set of case studies edited… 
Multiple Meanings of Alar after the Scare: Implications for Closure
The group politics approach to controversy analysis describes the closure of public controversies involving scientific or technological issues as an interest group's triumph over competing groups in
Controversies in Science and Technology—A Protocol for Comparative Research
The case study method has dominated scholarly examination of scientific and technical controversies, largely because the approach provides great richness of detail about particular fea-tures of a
Public Perceptions of Technological Risks
Technology that is developed for benefits and profits will always produce risks and costs. Although technology assessments evaluate and compare these consequences, balancing the trade-offs and
Public Disputes about Risky Technologies Stakeholders and Arenas
On their way to social acceptance, many technologies experience periods of public concern, controversy, and social opposition. Sometimes these responses to technologies are short episodes, motivated
Sociology and Science Policy: Opening and Managing the ‘Black Box’
So far, we have presented science as a form of social and cognitive activity. But it is of course a very powerful form of activity: while sociologists may challenge the conventional image of science
Framing Science
Applying the theories of agenda building and frame building and previous work related to the shared negotiations between sources and journalists in constructing news dramas, this article examines the
Scientific Knowledge, Public Policy, and Democracy
knowledge, its production, and its codification is intrinsically linked to power and influence. The political role of science, apparent since World War II, has shaped the development of scientific
The Importance of Being European: The Science and Politics of BSE in Portugal
This article provides a comparative analysis of the contents of two parliamentary hearings on BSE carried out in Portugal in 1993 and 1996 as instances of interaction between science and politics.
Controversies as Informal Technology A ssessment
Controversies, especially those that surround "early warnings" about impacts of a technology or a large project, may be welcomed as an informal way of technology assessment. This is not always
Bourdieu’s Cleft Sociology of Science
The paper examines Pierre Bourdieu’s extensive writings on the production of scientific knowledge. The study shows that Bourdieu offered not one but two - significantly different - approaches to