Contemporary Theory of Conservation

  title={Contemporary Theory of Conservation},
  author={Salvador Mu{\~n}oz-Vi{\~n}as},
Classical conservation theories (from Ruskin to Brandi) are characterized by their close adherence to Truth. These theories are currently dominant, but criticism and new alternatives are developing and gaining momentum. Three crucial notions in classical theories have been criticised: reversibility, universality and objectivity (including objective determination of damage and the notion of scientific conservation). As a result of these criticisms, emerging contemporary theory of conservation… 

Figures from this paper

Normal and Extraordinary Conservation Knowledge: Towards a Post-normal Theory of Cultural Materials Conservation

Abstract The two fundamental words and concepts that have come to delineate the field of cultural materials conservation—conservation and restoration—represent an essential tension in both theory and

‘There is nothing more practical than a good theory’: Conceptual tools for conservation practice

Faced with the growing number of case studies in contemporary art, philosophy provides conservators with a series of conceptual tools that allow to theorize their practice. The notion of

On the origins of Alois Riegl’s conservation theory

  • M. Hayes
  • Art
    Journal of the American Institute for Conservation
  • 2019
ABSTRACT Recent years have seen an increased interest in theoretical writing on conservation, notably in Alois Riegl’s seminal early text Der moderne Denkmalkultus sein Wesen und seine Entstehung,

From values to narrative: a new foundation for the conservation of historic buildings

Since its inception, modern conservation has derived the significance of a heritage asset from the identification and prioritisation of distinct classes of values. Different systems of values have

Revisiting the evaluation of heritage objects

This article explores the idea that heritage is historically and socially contingent and is inseparable from the relativistic conception of society and culture. It puts forward the proposition that

Conservation in the Performative Turn

ABSTRACT Over the last century, conservation practice and discourse have undergone several turns. One of the most recent – the cultural turn – prompted discussions on the importance of values-led

Heritage studies and the privileging of theory

Heritage studies is yet to have a debate about its theorisation at the global level. Many of the core ideas that shape the field are rooted in the contexts of Europe and the USA and geographically

Becoming Difference: On the Ethics of Conserving the In-Between

ABSTRACT Notions of authenticity underpinning conservation practice have been challenged by artistic and museum practices that contest the mere possibility of singular material existence of objects.

Sustainability in Conservation

Why do we preserve? The thesis questions and explores an undoubted belief in the preservation of a material past. This founding heritage of conservation is traced back to the Victorian preoccupation

Authenticity and Originality, Objectivity and Subjectivity in Conservation Decision-making – or is it Just a Matter of Taste?

ABSTRACT In an era of modern science-based conservation, heritage professionals pride themselves on their objective and interdisciplinary approach in conservation decision-making. However, supposedly



The social and historic construction of professional values in conservation

This paper discusses the social history of the emergence of conservation as a profession distinct from traditional restoration. It proposes that the development of conservation as a distinct field

Cultural heritage protection: legitimacy, property, and functionalism

  • M. Müller
  • Sociology
    International Journal of Cultural Property
  • 1998
This article argues that the question of whether the nation-state or the international community is the legitimate guardian of cultural property can only be answered with reference to what we expect

The Interface Between Science and Conservation

Twenty-nine papers which aim to pool the insights and gains made by research carried out by conservation scientists in order to improve conservation techniques in the museums themselves. Papers

Reversibility: A Questionable Philosophy

Le principe de reversibilite dans la conservation des documents: definitions, application, dilemme qu'il suscite: resolution de celui-ci par les rencontres d'experts, consensus sur certains

Values and Urban Conservation Planning: Some Reflections on Principles and Definitions

AbstractThe aim of this paper is to discuss the question of values in relation to the planning and conservation management of historic cities. It is structured in order to expose the logical problems


List of illustrations Introduction Part I. Wanting The Past: 1. Reliving the past: dreams and nightmares 2. Benefits and burdens of the past 3. Ancients vs. moderns 4. The look of age Part II.

Durability and Change: The Science, Responsibility, and Cost of Sustaining Cultural Heritage

Partial table of contents: Preservation of Books and the Electronic Storage of Information (F. Westheimer). Durability and Change: A Biochemist's View (F. Cramer). The Value of Age and Decay (D.

Criteria for treatment: reversibility

AbstractThe author reconsiders the “Principle of Reversibility” by clarifying its definition and by examining the variables that make a treatment reversible. Different criteria for different parts of

Restoration: acceptable to whom?

Examines the problems of conserving polychrome wooden sculpture that is still in use in religious buildings, and considers who should make treatment decisions. -- AATA