Constraints on multiple center-embedding of clauses

@article{Karlsson2007ConstraintsOM,
  title={Constraints on multiple center-embedding of clauses},
  author={Fred Karlsson},
  journal={Journal of Linguistics},
  year={2007},
  volume={43},
  pages={365-392}
}
  • Fred Karlsson
  • Published 1 July 2007
  • Linguistics
  • Journal of Linguistics
A common view in theoretical syntax and computational linguistics holds that there are no grammatical restrictions on multiple center-embedding of clauses. Syntax would thus be characterized by unbounded recursion. An analysis of 119 genuine multiple clausal center-embeddings from seven ‘Standard Average European’ languages (English, Finnish, French, German, Latin, Swedish, Danish) uncovers usage-based regularities, constraints, that run counter to these and several other widely held views… 

Tables from this paper

Constraints on multiple initial embedding of clauses

The received view is that there are no constraints on clausal embedding complexity in sentences. This hypothesis will be challenged here on empirical grounds from the viewpoint of multiple initial

Multiple final embedding of clauses

There are no grammatical limits on multiple final embedding of clauses. But converging corpus data from English, Finnish, German and Swedish show that multiple final embedding is avoided at levels

When missing NPs make double center-embedding sentences acceptable

TLDR
It is suggested that the illusion of grammaticality arises when the parser can establish thematic relations between all verbs and nouns, and an interference-and-repair approach provides a unified analysis of the missing VP and missing NP illusions, while accounting for the observed difference in thematic Relations.

Center-Embedding Relative Clauses in Coahuilteco1

  • R. Troike
  • Linguistics
    International Journal of American Linguistics
  • 2015
Coahuilteco, a long-extinct language of South Texas known primarily from a confessor’s manual (García 1760), had a basic SOV constituent order, with relative clauses occurring between the noun (NRel

A Usage-Based Approach to Recursion in Sentence Processing

TLDR
A connectionist model embodying this alternative theory is outlined, along with simulation results showing that the model is capable of constituent-like generalizations and that it can fit human data regarding the differential processing difficulty associated with center-embeddings in German and cross-dependencies in Dutch.

Center-Embedded Sentences: An Online Problem or Deeper?

TLDR
It is maintained that previewing by reading aloud, as in the Double Reading design that is reported on here, can be more informative of prosodic competence than the typical silent reading preview.

The properties of rare and complex syntactic constructions in English. A corpus-based comparative study

The study adopts a corpus-based approach to investigate rare and complex constructions in English, such as it-clefts and topicalization. Two dependency-based metrics, namely dependency distance (DD)

An interference account of the missing-VP effect

TLDR
It is proposed that the missing-VP effect in particular, and processing difficulties with multiply center-embedded clauses more generally, are best understood as resulting from interference during cue-based retrieval, which is superior to accounts in terms of limited memory resources or in Terms of experience with embedded structures.

Data convergence in syntactic theory and the role of sentence pairs

TLDR
It is argued that for theory-critical data, the process of community agreement should be accompanied by quantitative methods whenever possible, and that replication of only contrasts is not sufficient, because theory building necessarily includes comparison across pairs and across papers.

A Corpus Investigation of Syntactic Embedding in Pirahã

TLDR
An analysis of a novel corpus of natural Pirahã speech that was originally collected by Dan Everett and Steve Sheldon is presented and it is found that the corpus is plausibly consistent with an analysis ofPirahã as a regular language, although this is not the only plausible analysis.
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 76 REFERENCES

Constraints on multiple initial embedding of clauses

The received view is that there are no constraints on clausal embedding complexity in sentences. This hypothesis will be challenged here on empirical grounds from the viewpoint of multiple initial

Constraints on the Distribution of NP Clauses

TLDR
It is argued that the proposed alternative restrictions exhibit non-trivial correlations with independently established facts of language processing, and that the latter can explicate to an important degree the existence of the former in the languages of the world.

The type and structure of clausal embedding in legal English

In the study of legal English, syntax has so far received relatively little altention. This article reports on soine preliminary results of a project aimed at an analysis of the salient syntactic

A New Look at the Acquisition of Relative Clauses

This study reconsiders the acquisition of relative clauses based on data from two sentencerepetition tasks. Usingmaterials modeled on the relative constructions of spontaneous child speech, we asked

Interference in short-term memory: The magical number two (or three) in sentence processing

TLDR
This article suggests that an interesting range of core sentence processing phenomena can be explained as interference effects in a sharply limited syntactic working memory, including difficult and acceptable embeddings, as well as certain limitations on ambiguity resolution, length effects in garden path structures, and the requirement for locality in syntactic structure.

Linguistic complexity: locality of syntactic dependencies

Cultural Constraints on Grammar and Cognition in Pirahã

The Pirah language challenges simplistic application of Hocketts nearly universally accepted design features of human language by showing that some of these features (interchangeability,

Toward a connectionist model of recursion in human linguistic performance

Postmodifying Clauses in the English Noun Phrase: A Corpus-Based Study

This book reports on the results of a project whose aim was to give a detailed description of a number of syntactic properties of postmodifying clauses in the English NP, and study the way in which

Self Embedded Relative Clauses in a Corpus of German Newspaper Texts

The distribution of center self-embeddings and extrapositions in German is assumed to reflect a universal performance strategy of minimizing memory load during parsing. Self-embedded relative clauses
...